Citizenship and Immigration Canada Canada wordmark

Forging Our Legacy: Canadian Citizenship and Immigration, 1900-1977

Chapter 2 (continued)
The Arrival of the Europeans


top of page  British immigration

Although there were relatively few good agriculturalists left to court in the "mother country," the Canadian government continued to promote immigration from the United Kingdom--often called Great Britain or simply Britain--during the Sifton years, principally because English Canadians took it for granted that their federal government would do everything possible to retain the British character of the country. Prior to 1903, Canada's immigration service in Britain had been under the control of the Canadian High Commission, but in January of that year immigration was removed from its jurisdiction. To handle immigration, Sifton established an emigration office in London that would be effectively independent of the high commissioner's office.

The new office was housed in Trafalgar House, an imposing building that commanded a central location overlooking the historic open space of Trafalgar Square. As one enthusiastic observer remarked:

No one passing to and from the Houses of Parliament and official Westminster can fail to notice "Trafalgar House." The eye is caught at once by the familiar Canadian "Arch" of Coronation days, a representation of which is emblazoned on one of the windows, whilst elsewhere the intending emigrant is invited to enter by the mottoes, "Improved Farms at Reasonable Prices," "Healthy Climate, Light Taxes, Free Schools," "160-acre Free Farms."

line

The establishment of an independent emigration office in a central location in London paved the way for a dramatic increase in British immigration. In the first six months of 1900, just over 5,000 Britons came to Canada. Five years later the annual number soared to above 65,000, exceeding the numbers of new settlers arriving from the United States.

Most British newcomers in this pre-war period emigrated to Canada in hopes of finding a higher standard of living and freedom from the rigidities of the hallowed British class system. Included in the ranks of these unsponsored immigrants were not only people of modest means but also individuals with substantial funds who would often invest in large-scale ranching or farming ventures in Western Canada.

Many of these well-heeled middle- and upper-class Britons had set off for Canada because it was difficult to find suitable employment in Britain's amply supplied and highly competitive professions. Others had left large estates burdened by heavy debts and tithes. For these prosperous Britons, emigration seemed to offer the only way that they could maintain their own and their children's lifestyle in a rapidly changing world. They chose Canada largely because of the efforts of the emigration and booking agents, the aggressive campaigns mounted by Canadian colonization companies, and the seductive promotional material that extolled the attractions of the various provinces for "gentlemen emigrants."

Not all of these well-off British newcomers were warmly welcomed in their adopted country. In fact, there was widespread resentment against those of them who seemed to expect special treatment in the "colony." Not infrequently, employment ads in western newspapers included the words "No English need apply." And when the London reporter H.R. Whates was researching the immigration boom for an article for the London Standard in 1905, Canadians bluntly informed him: "The Englishman is too cocksure; he is too conceited, and he thinks he knows everything and he won't try to learn our ways."

The great influx from Britain in these years also included poor immigrants who had been assisted by charitable organizations wanting to rid the United Kingdom of paupers and help them make a fresh start in the colonies. One of the many philanthropic agencies involved in this endeavour was the Salvation Army, which was established in Canada in 1882. From 1884, when a branch of the Church Army--the Self-Help Emigration Society--began its work, until 1914, the "Army next to God" assisted 150,000 of Great Britain's deserving poor to emigrate to Canada. The Salvation Army's immigration program did not escape controversy, however. Organized labour was especially hostile, charging the dominion government with paying the agency bonuses for recruiting individuals who posed as "agriculturalists" but soon became industrial workers.

 
top of page  The home children

Most of the British poor who emigrated to Canada in this first European wave came in families, but an impressive number did not. Conspicuous in the latter's ranks were thousands of young boys and girls who arrived in this country unaccompanied by an adult family member. These children, once here, were apprenticed as agricultural labourers or, in the case of girls, sent to smaller towns or rural homes to work as domestic servants.

These were the "home children," slum youngsters plucked from philanthropic rescue homes and parish workhouse schools and dispatched to Canada (and to other British colonies) to meet the soaring demand for cheap labour on Canadian farms and household labour in family homes. Many of these youngsters, most of whom ranged in age between eight and ten, came from families of the urban poor who could not care for them properly. Other children, perhaps one-third their number, were orphans, while the balance were runaways or abandoned youngsters. At a time when few British emigrants were indentured in their overseas destinations, nearly all these child immigrants were apprenticed shortly after their arrival in Canada.

Although Canadian farms had received orphaned and destitute British children as early as the 1830s, it was not until 1868 that the home-children movement began in an organized way. In that year, Maria Susan Rye, the feminist daughter of a distinguished London solicitor, purchased an old jail on the outskirts of Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario, had it refurbished, and then made preparations to bring her first party of children to Canada. They arrived in October 1869 with the well-publicized blessings of both the Archbishop of Canterbury and The Times of London.

A few months later, Annie Macpherson, a Quaker working independently of Rye, brought another party of young children to Ontario. Soon, Louisa Birt of Liverpool (Macpherson's sister), Thomas Barnardo of London, Leonard Shaw of Manchester, and William Quarrier of Glasgow--to name but a few of the best-known child-savers--were launching their own child-emigration programs. Before long there was a proliferation of similar programs, some of the more notable being implemented by the National Children's Homes, Mr. Fegan's Homes of Southwark and Westminster, the Middlemore Homes in Birmingham, the Church of England Waifs and Strays Society, and Miss Stirling of Edinburgh. Because Canada was closer to Britain than was Australia or New Zealand, it became the favoured destination for these charges, especially during the Sifton years.

Underlying all these schemes was the activists' belief that emigration was an effective way to rescue impoverished British children from the poorest and most crowded districts of Britain's teeming cities. On Canadian farms, far from the temptations and polluted air of city life, their slum protégés would grow into healthy, industrious adults. Or so the thinking went.

Among the many names closely associated with this unique immigration program, the one most familiar to Canadians was undoubtedly that of Irish-born Thomas John Barnardo. Barnardo's vanity and thirst for prestige led him to use the title "Doctor," although he had never completed his medical studies.

Born into a Dublin family of modest means in 1845, Barnardo headed to London in 1866 to train as a medical missionary for China. Shortly after his arrival in London, the young medical student came across the city's homeless waifs sleeping in its alleys and on its rooftops. The plight of London's homeless children so affected Barnardo that when he was rejected for missionary work in China, he abandoned all plans to be a physician and vowed to make helping these street children his life's work. To this end, the authoritarian trailblazer established a home for boys in 1870, the first of his numerous homes for destitute children.

Initially Barnardo was able to find work for his protégés in Britain, but when employment opportunities started to dry up in both the trades and domestic service, he decided to explore emigration possibilities. In the autumn of 1882, he launched a comprehensive emigration program that would see some 30,000 children sent to Canada before it petered out in 1939.


A group of boys from Barnardo homes in England shown after their arrival in Belleville, Ontario, circa 1922.

National Archives of Canada (C 34840)


Most of the Barnardo children led anonymous lives. One exception was George Everitt Green, a young agricultural labourer from England, although it would not be until after his death that Canadians would learn more about him than about any of the other home children dispatched to Canada. Only seven months after his arrival on an Ontario farm in 1895 Green was dead, his limbs gangrenous and his body emaciated and covered with sores, the visible marks of the cruel treatment dealt him by his spinster employer.

The inquest and trial that followed caused such a sensation that the federal and Ontario governments introduced legislation to prevent a similar tragedy from ever happening again. Even more far-reaching action was taken after three home children committed suicide in the winter of 1923­24. In the wake of these suicides, a British parliamentary delegation travelled to Canada to interview immigration officials, social workers, representatives of women's, labour, and farm organizations, and child immigrants themselves. Its findings led the delegation to declare that future child emigrants should be of working--that is, school-leaving--age. Taking its cue from the delegation's report, Canada's Immigration Branch introduced a regulation in 1925 that prohibited voluntary immigration societies from bringing children under 14 years of age to this country. Intended to last three years, the ban was made permanent in 1928.

The long-lived program eventually came to a halt in 1939, its end hastened not only by the Great Depression and the opposition of the Canadian labour movement but also by a change of thinking on the part of Canadians and Britons. Both, it seems, could no longer tolerate the idea of philanthropic organizations separating young children from their parents and sending them to work in distant lands, no matter how salubrious the setting.

 
top of page  The Barr Colony

The Barr Colony does not appear on contemporary maps of Canada. Nevertheless, early in this century this British settlement on the plains of what became Saskatchewan attracted countless curious visitors and inspired many column inches of print in daily newspapers in Canada and Britain.


This poster was reproduced in the magazine Canada West, circa 1900­1920.

National Archives of Canada (C 126302)


The colony was noteworthy because it defied the belief held by many officials and journalists that a group of British immigrants without farming experience could survive on the bald prairie, 300 kilometres from the nearest city, without even a road or a rail line to link them to civilization. Within five years of the settlement's founding, these same sceptics were lauding the achievements of the Barr colonists. Their achievements were certainly remarkable but no more so than the journey that took them to the Canadian wilderness in the vicinity of present-day Lloydminster. This unforgettable migration was inspired by the lofty vision of two clerics, Isaac Barr (1847­1937), after whom the colony was named, and George Lloyd (1861­1940), who worked with the Colonial and Continental Church Society.

Canadian-born Isaac Barr was an Anglican clergyman who was fascinated by the career of Cecil Rhodes, the British diamond magnate and imperialist. He even attempted to join the famous Briton in a colonizing venture, leaving his Washington D.C. parish to travel to London in January 1902. But Rhodes died in March of that year, frustrating Barr's dream to serve the Empire by founding an overseas colony. Barr revived his plans, however, on learning of the Reverend George Lloyd's interest in organizing a settlement in Canada of unemployed British workers and soldiers demobilized from the Boer War. "Let us take possession of Canada," he wrote in a letter to The Times of London in 1902. "Let our cry be 'CANADA FOR THE BRITISH.'"

The two clerics joined forces to organize a Canadian settlement of almost 2,000 Britons, few of whom were of the sturdy farming stock traditionally considered necessary for successful homesteading. Barr handled nearly all the administrative arrangements. He persuaded the Canadian government to reserve a block of land for the settlers, collected settlers' fees, purchased supplies, and arranged for transportation. But he refused to act as a chaplain for the colonists, claiming that the colony was not to be an Anglican enclave in the prairie wilderness. As a result of this decision, the Reverend George Lloyd and his family were persuaded to join the group at the last minute.

Unfortunately for the colonists, Barr was no altruist. Determined to reap financial gain from this venture, he received a commission from the Canadian government for each immigrant and worked in league with local merchants. He was also no organizing genius. Things began to go wrong the day that the SS Lake Manitoba sailed from the Old Country in 1903. After a rough ocean voyage in a ship equipped to handle only about 550 passengers instead of 1,900, the exhausted immigrants arrived in Saint John, New Brunswick, where they faced countless delays and numerous baggage inspections. Eventually they boarded three filthy immigrant trains, none of them with overnight accommodation, for the five-day trip to Saskatoon.


In the 1880s, immigrants travelled by train to Western Canada.

Provincial Archives of Manitoba (N 7934)


The settlers experienced further disillusionment when they arrived at Saskatoon. Army-surplus bell tents had been erected to house them, and since there was no station house, their luggage was dumped onto the prairie. Local merchants charged inflated prices for basic necessities, and Barr's promises of wagons, oxen, and other supplies were not kept. In addition to these hardships, the settlers then had to endure a long and arduous wagon journey along a primitive trail that for part of the way wound through sloughs and down steep cliffs before reaching North Battleford. For many of the colonists who had no experience driving oxen and wagons this challenge was too much and they turned back. The majority, however, persevered, stopping overnight in large marquee tents set up by immigration officials.


This poster was reproduced in the magazine Canada West, circa 1900­1914.

National Archives of Canada (C 85854)


The remaining colonists' frustration with Barr finally boiled over in an explosive meeting in one of the trailside camps. Barr was accused of being in league with the Saskatoon merchants, of failing to deliver on his promise of a transportation company and a co-operative store, and, worst of all, of misleading the colonists about conditions on the Prairies. Most of the people at the meeting voted to depose Barr as their leader, but they did not want to break up the colony. Instead, they renamed the venture "Britannia Colony" and voted in a new leadership, George Lloyd and an elected committee of twelve, soon dubbed the "Twelve Apostles."

After finally reaching the reserve in May 1903, the settlers and Lloyd began homesteading. Soon a village, named Lloydminster to honour the man who had gained the settlers' confidence, grew up along the fourth meridian. In their first year, many of the colonists came close to starving. They battled mosquitoes, blizzards, and prairie fires, but thanks to their hard work and perseverance the settlement survived and began to prosper. As early as 1905, three large hotels were under construction. The town's success was finally assured when the railway arrived in July of that year.

Barr, meanwhile, had returned to the United States, but not before being publicly pelted with rotten eggs by the people of Regina. After working in various secular jobs south of the border, he joined the Closer Settlement near Melbourne, Australia. The settlement failed, but Barr stayed on after the other settlers departed, never to move again.

 
top of page  Immigration to British Columbia

Not only the Prairies attracted a strong flow of immigrants in the early years of this century. British Columbia, which had entered Confederation in 1871, was also a magnet for newcomers. Admittedly, the volume of immigration to this province did not begin to approach that to the Prairies, but it was nevertheless impressive.

 
top of page  The British

Retired businessmen, farmers, and the younger sons in aristocratic families were among the British newcomers who flocked to Canada's most westerly province. Their attention was first drawn by advertising material describing the joys of farming in lush interior valleys dotted with beautiful lakes filled with trout. Inspired further by the enthusiastic reports of Lord Aberdeen, Canada's Governor General from 1893 to 1898, well-to-do British immigrants purchased ranches and fruit farms in the Okanagan Valley, where the Scottish aristocrat had extensive properties.

Top of pageTable of contentsPreviousNext