Canada Revenue Agency Digital Acceleration Research
Final Report

Prepared for the Canada Revenue Agency

Supplier name: Earnscliffe Strategy Group
Contract number: 46637-227501/001/CY
Contract value: $130,060.74 (including HST)
Award date: March 31, 2021
Delivery date: July 16, 2021

Registration number: POR 142-20
For more information, please contact: cra-arc.media@cra-arc.gc.ca

Ce rapport est aussi disponible en français.

Canada Revenue Agency Digital Acceleration Research

Prepared for the Canada Revenue Agency

Supplier name: Earnscliffe Strategy Group
July 2021

This public opinion research report presents the results of the telephone survey conducted by Earnscliffe Strategy Group on behalf of the Canada Revenue Agency. The research was conducted in May and June 2021.

Cette publication est aussi disponible en français sous le titre : Recherche sur l'accélération numérique de l'Agence du revenu du Canada.

This publication may be reproduced for non-commercial purposes only. Prior written permission must be obtained from the Canada Revenue Agency. For more information on this report, please contact the CRA at: cra-arc.media@cra-arc.gc.ca or at:

Canada Revenue Agency
4th Floor 555 Mackenzie Ave
Ottawa Ontario K1A OL5

Catalogue Number: Rv4-151/1-2021E-PDF
International Standard Book Number (ISBN): 978-0-660-39864-8

Related publications (POR registration number: POR 142-20):
Catalogue Number: Rv4-151/1-2021F-PDF (Final Report, French)
ISBN: 978-0-660-39866-2

© Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada, as represented by the Minister of National Revenue, 2021

Table of Contents

Executive Summary

Earnscliffe Strategy Group (Earnscliffe) is pleased to present this report to the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) summarizing the results of the quantitative research aimed at better understanding the habits and behaviours of paper-tax filers as well as the likelihood of them switching to file online in the future.

Background and Research Objectives

Given the current environment and as more Canadians make use of online services, CRA wished to take the opportunity to reach out to Canadians to determine their communication channel preferences when interacting with the Agency. There is still a sizeable proportion of taxpayers who are conducting their business with the CRA through paper, rather than taking advantage of digital services which are much more timely and efficient. In fact, CRA spent $6,947,903 and mailed out 1,399,705 T1 packages in 2019-2020. With this information in mind, the objectives of the research were to better understand why paper filers are still choosing to conduct business and meet their tax obligations using paper and better understand what the barriers and challenges are to moving to digital processes.

This research will help CRA meet the expectations and the needs of Canadians as it relates to service delivery and digital offerings. More specifically, research results will provide CRA with a better understanding of the barriers to using online services that exist with paper filers. For those who do not have barriers to online, but prefer paper-based processes, the research will demonstrate which particular processes paper-users are most agreeable to switch to online and which are not. This can help determine where support, outreach and education are most required.

The total contract value of this research project was $130,060.74 including HST.

Research Methodology

To meet the research objectives, Earnscliffe conducted a telephone survey of 2,000 Canadians who did not file their 2019 personal income taxes online, using a list of 697,715 individuals provided by CRA. The survey was conducted in collaboration with our sub-contractor, Léger. The telephone survey was conducted from Léger's centralized call-centre using their state-of-the-art Computer Aided Telephone Interviewing (CATI) system. The survey was conducted from May 11 to June 2, 2021, and the average length of interview was 16 minutes. The margin of error for this sample of 2,000 Canadians who filed their 2019 return by paper/mail is +/-2.19%, 19 times of out 20.

The final data was weighted to reflect the demographic composition (age and gender within region) of the list of paper tax filers provided by CRA.

The key findings from the research are presented below.

Key Findings

Political Neutrality Statement and Contact Information

Research Firm:

Earnscliffe Strategy Group Inc. (Earnscliffe)
Contract Number: 46637-227501/001/CY
Contract award date: March 31, 2021

I hereby certify as a Representative of Earnscliffe Strategy Group that the final deliverables fully comply with the Government of Canada political neutrality requirements outlined in the Communications Policy of the Government of Canada and Procedures for Planning and Contracting Public Opinion Research. Specifically, the deliverables do not include information on electoral voting intentions, political party preferences, standings with the electorate or ratings of the performance of a political party or its leaders.

Signed: Date: July 16, 2021

Doug Anderson
Principal, Earnscliffe

Introduction

Earnscliffe Strategy Group (Earnscliffe) is pleased to present this report to the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) summarizing the results of the quantitative research aimed at better understanding the habits and behaviours of paper-tax filers as well as the likelihood of them switching to file online in the future.

Given the current environment and as more Canadians make use of online services, the CRA wished to take the opportunity to reach out to Canadians to determine their channel preferences when interacting with the Agency. There is still a sizeable proportion of taxpayers who are conducting their business with the CRA through paper, rather than taking advantage of digital services which are much more timely and efficient. In fact, CRA spent $6,947,903 and mailed out 1,399,705 T1 packages in 2019-2020.

The objectives of the research were to better understand why paper filers are still choosing to conduct business and meet their tax obligations using paper and to learn more about the barriers and challenges to moving to digital processes. More specifically, the objectives of the research included:

This research will help CRA meet the expectations and the needs of Canadians as it relates to service delivery and digital offerings. Research results will also provide CRA with a better understanding of the barriers to using online services that exist with paper filers. For those who do not have barriers to online, but prefer paper-based processes, the research will demonstrate which particular processes paper-users are most agreeable to switch to online and which are not. This can help determine where support, outreach and education are most required.

To meet the research objectives, Earnscliffe conducted a telephone survey of 2,000 Canadians who did not file their 2019 income taxes online, using a list of 697,715 Canadians provided by CRA. The survey was conducted in collaboration with our sub-contractor, Leger. The telephone survey was conducted from Léger's centralized call-centre using their state of the art Computer Aided Telephone Interviewing (CATI) system. The survey was conducted from May 11 to June 2, 2021, and the average length of interview was 16 minutes.

Provincial/territorial quotas were set as outlined in the table below, based on the distribution of paper tax filers by province from the CRA list. The final data was weighted to reflect the demographic composition (age and gender within region) of the list of paper tax filers provided by CRA.

Table 1. Provincial/Territorial Quotas
Province/Territory Percentage Sample Size
Newfoundland and Labrador 3.01% 61
Prince Edward Island .44% 9
Nova Scotia 3.62% 72
New Brunswick 2.99% 61
Quebec 34.72% 694
Ontario 28.07% 561
Manitoba 3.08% 62
Saskatchewan 2.77% 55
Alberta 8.67% 173
British Columbia 12.47% 249
Nunavut .03% 1
Northwest Territories .05% 1
Yukon .07% 1
Total 100% 2,000

The detailed findings from this research are presented in subsequent sections of this report. Appended to this report are the survey methodology report, questionnaire, and data tables (presented under a separate cover).


Detailed Findings

This research report is divided into three sections. The first deals with respondents' current behaviours related to filing their personal income taxes and interacting with CRA. The second analyzes paper filers' barriers to filing electronically and factors that might make them more likely to switch how they file. The final sections presents a segmentation analysis based on the likelihood of switching to electronic filing.

Current Behaviours

Three-quarters (74%) of respondents filed their last personal income tax return by mail, while almost a quarter (23%) filed online. As noted earlier, the survey was conducted using a list of paper-filers from 2019. It is important for context to note that at the time the survey was conducted, many would have likely filed their 2020 returns and, based on our findings, it seems some switched to filing online.

The older the respondent, the more likely they are to file by mail. For example, well over three-quarters of those 75+ (83%) and 65-74 (81%) file by mail, a significantly greater percentage than those 18-34 (42%). Other significant demographic differences include:

Table 2. How were your last personal income taxes sent in?

Base: Total sample (n=2,000)
Filing Method Percent Selected
By mail 74%
Online (INCLUDES EFILE AND NETFILE) 23%
Other 2%
Don't know 2%

When it comes to the ways in which respondents get the forms they need for preparing their personal income taxes, the vast majority (73%) have at least one form mailed to them. This percentage is even higher for mail filers (81%) and lower for those who file online (51%). Significantly fewer print forms off (14%), or pick up a tax package themselves (9%), or have a tax professional (13%) or friend/family member (6%) get them on their behalf.

Analysis by age shows clear differences in how younger vs older age groups access forms. Over three-quarters of those 55-64 (78%), 65-74 (79%) and 75+ (79%) have forms mailed to them, a significantly greater proportion than among those 18-34 (47%) and 35-54 (68%). In contrast, younger paper filers are more likely to have received their forms from a tax professional or family member than older filers. A quarter (25%) of those 18-34 and one-fifth (20%) of those 35-54 receive forms from a tax professional, compared to 13% of those 55-64 and just 8% of those 65-74 and 7% of those 75+. Those 18-34 are also more likely to have a family member who provided them with their forms (14%) compared to all other age groups.

Table 3. Which of the following ways, if any, did you get any forms needed for preparing your last personal income taxes?


Base: Total sample (n=2,000)
Methods of Accessing Forms Percent Selected
I had a form or forms mailed to me 73%
I printed off at least one form 14%
A tax professional or accountant provided me with forms or got them on my behalf 13%
I picked up a tax package 9%
A friend or family member provided me with forms or got them on my behalf 6%
I never personally accessed or used any forms 3%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 2%

Most (79%) are satisfied with the way in which they go about preparing and submitting their personal income taxes. Just 9% are dissatisfied. Current mail filers are just as satisfied (80%) as those who file electronically (80%). Women are more satisfied overall than men (82% vs 77%).

Table 4. Generally speaking, how satisfied are you with the way in which you go about preparing and submitting your personal income taxes to the Canada Revenue Agency?

Base: Total sample (n=2,000)
Level of Satisfaction with Current Method of Filing Percent Selected
Very dissatisfied 3%
Somewhat dissatisfied 5%
Neither satisfied nor dissatisfied 9%
Somewhat satisfied 34%
Very satisfied 45%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 3%

Just over half (54%) prepared their last personal income taxes on their own, while 46% had help. Of note, those 18-34 (67%) and 35-54 (57%) are more likely than older cohorts to have received help. Quebeckers are more likely to have received help (58%) than respondents from other regions. Indigenous (70%) and racialized (57%) respondents are more likely to have received help than white respondents (43%). Also worth noting, over two-thirds (69%) of those with a university degree and more than half (59%) of those with a college degree say they prepared their own taxes, significantly more than those with a high school education or less (37%).

Table 5. Did you prepare your last personal income taxes on your own, or did you receive help from someone else?

Base: Total sample (n=2,000)
Receiving vs not Receiving Help with Taxes Percent Selected
Prepared on my own 54%
Received help 46%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 0%

Among those who received help with their personal income taxes, six in ten respondents (61%) say the person who helped them also submitted them. Among those who filed their last return online, 91% say the person who helped them also submitted them, compared to 42% who filed by paper. Almost three-quarters (73%) of those 18-34 say that the individual who helped them also submitted for them, significantly more than among those 35-54 (57%) and 55-64 (57%).

Table 6. Did the person who provided you with help preparing your last personal income taxes also send in your forms to Canada Revenue Agency for you?

Base: Received help preparing person income taxes (n=876)
Did the person who helped you prepare your taxes also submit them? Percent Selected
Yes 61%
No, I sent them in myself 38%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 1%

About half (49%) have visited the tax pages of the Canada.ca or CRA website to search for information on tax-related matters. Over half of respondents 18-34 (61%), 35-54 (56%) and 55-64 (52%) have visited these pages, significantly more than those 65-74 (45%) and 75+ (36%). More affluent respondents are more likely than those in the lowest income brackets to have visited these pages (e.g., 73% of those with a household income of $150K+ vs 26% of those with a household income of less than $20K and 37% of those with an income between $20K and $40K). Similarly, more educated respondents are more likely to have visited these pages (70% of those with a university degree and 50% of those with a college agree, vs. just 30% of those with high school or less).

Table 7. Have you ever visited the tax pages of either the Canada.ca or Canada Revenue Agency website to search for information on tax-related matters?

Base: Total sample (n=2,000)
Visiting CRA website Percent Selected
Yes 49%
No 50%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 1%

Just 16% of those who did not submit their last taxes electronically report ever having personally submitted federal tax forms online or electronically. Respondents 75+ are the least likely to have done so (9%) among all age groups, while those 18-34 are the most likely (21%). Again, respondents with a household income of $150K+ (27%) are most likely to have submitted a tax form online, particularly compared to those with incomes under $20K (13%) and between $20K and $40K (15%). Those with a university (19%) or college degree (18%) are also more likely than those with a high school education or less (12%) to have submitted a form electronically.

Table 8. Have you personally ever submitted federal tax forms online or electronically?

Base: Did not submit last taxes online (n=1,577)
History Submitting Forms Electronically Percent Selected
Yes, I have submitted a form to CRA online or electronically 16%
No, I have never submitted a form to CRA online or electronically 83%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 1%

About half (49%) have registered with CRA's My Account online service. Registration is higher among those who filed their most recent personal income taxes online (62%) than among paper filers (45%).

Registration is significantly higher among those 18-34 (68%) and 35-54 (64%) than among those 55-64 (50%), 65-74 (43%) and 75+ (28%). Those with higher household incomes are also more likely to be registered than those in lower income brackets – roughly two-thirds of those with household incomes exceeding $60K have registered, compared to 32% of those with an income less than $20K and 37% of those with an income between $20K and $40K. Similarly, those with higher levels of education are more likely to have registered. Almost two-thirds (64%) of those with a university degree have registered, as have half (50%) of those with a college degree, compared to 36% among those with high school education or less. Those born outside Canada are more likely to be registered (56%) than those born in Canada (48%).

Table 9. Have you ever registered with CRA's My Account online service?

Base: Total sample (n=2,000)
Registration for CRA's My Account Services Percent Selected
Yes 49%
No 48%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 3%

About three-quarters (74%) have access to a computer, while two-thirds have high-speed internet (69%) or a tablet/mobile device (65%). Fewer, though still over half (57%) have a printer. Compared to those who reported filing their last returns online, those who file by mail are less likely to have access to high-speed internet (68% vs 78%) or a tablet/mobile device (63% vs 75%) but still well over half do have access to these things. Access to resources that could be used to file electronically among the sample of 2019 paper filers appears to be less widespread than among the Canadian population as a whole. While it does not offer exact comparative data, the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission's 2019 Communications Monitoring Report suggests that the level of access among Canadian households is higher. Results showed that 84% of Canadian households have a home computer, 89% have a home internet subscription and 90% have mobile phone(s).

Access to each of these resources that could be used to file taxes electronically varies by age. Over 80% of those 18-34 and 35-54 have access to a computer, mobile device and high-speed internet. Those 55- 64 and 65-74 are slightly less well-equipped, but still about three quarters of those 55-64 (74%) and 65-74 (71%) have access to a computer. Fewer have access to high-speed internet (73% and 63% respectively) and a mobile device (65% and 59%). The 75+ age category is the group most lacking the technology and equipment needed to file electronically, though over half do have access to a computer (60%) and high-speed internet (52%).

Table 10. Which of the following do you have?

Base: Total sample (n=2,000), last filed by paper (n=1511), last filed online (n=423)
Devices that Respondents Have at Home Percent Selected Last filed by paper Last filed online
A desktop or laptop computer or easy access to one at your household 74% 86% 92%
High speed internet 69% 74% 77%
A tablet, or mobile device such as a smartphone 65% 68% 78%
A printer 57% 63% 75%
None of the above 12% 58% 57%
Prefer not to say 0% 13% 7%
Don't know 0% 0% 0%

One objective of the research was to better understand paper filers' habits regarding other online transactions, particularly online banking and online purchasing.

When it comes to frequency of online banking, respondents are slightly polarized. Half (51%) of all respondents say they online bank frequently, while 31% say they never do it. Results among paper filers are similar - a third (33%) of paper filers never bank online while 49% do so frequently. Those who reported last filing electronically are more likely to bank online frequently (58%) and less likely to say they never bank online (24%).

Once again, there are demographic differences when it comes to online banking:

The majority bank in-person – 30% do so frequently, 30% do so sometimes. About three-in-ten (29%) say they rarely bank in person and just 9% never bank in-person (compared to 31% for online banking). Of note, those who file by mail are more likely to say they bank in-person frequently (32%) than those who filed their last return electronically (25%).

Again, there are age differences when it comes to the frequency of in-person banking, but they are less pronounced than for online banking. For example, 20% of those 18-34 bank in person frequently, significantly lower than the 38% of those 75+ who bank in-person frequently.

When it comes to making purchases online, behaviour is more evenly divided. Slightly less than half (45%) say they make online purchases frequently or sometimes, while just over half (54%) do so only rarely or never. Electronic filers (29%) are more likely to frequently make online purchases, compared to mail filers (17%). Over a third (36%) of paper filers never shop online, compared to 29% of electronic filers.

Frequency of online purchasing varies depending on a variety of demographic factors:

Table 11. For each of the following, please tell me whether this is something you do frequently, sometimes, rarely or if it is something you don´t do.

Base: Total sample (n=2,000)
Banking and/or online purchasing activity Do not do this Rarely Sometimes Frequently Don't know + Prefer not to say
Online banking 31% 5% 11% 51% 1%
Banking in-person or at a branch 9% 29% 30% 30% 2%
Make online purchases of any kind 34% 20% 25% 20% 1%

Slightly less than one-in-five (17%) have applied for the CERB, CRB or CESB since they launched. The percentage who have applied is significantly higher among those 18-34 (40%) compared to every other age group. It is also higher in BC than in other regions (27%) and among the self-employed (42%) compared to other workers.

Worth noting, the percentage of respondents who applied for the benefits among those with incomes less than $80K varies little by income level. Among those with incomes of less than $20K, 17% applied, same percentage as among those with an income between $40-$60K. One-in-five (21%) of those with an income of $20K-$40K and $60K to $80K have applied. Fewer with an income between $80K-$150K (15%) and $150K+ (8%) have applied for pandemic benefits.

Table 12. Since they were launched in 2020, have you ever registered online for either the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB), the Canada Recovery Benefit (CRB) or the Canada Emergency Student Benefit (CESB) ...?

Base: Total sample (n=2,000)
Registration with CERB, CRB or CESB Percent Selected
Yes 17%
No 82%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 1%

Among those who have applied for the CERB, CRB or CESB, a third (33%) registered for My Account in order to apply for the benefit.

Table 13. Did you register for My Account to apply for this benefit or were you already registered beforehand?

Base: Registered for CRA My Account and Applied for Benefit (n=207)
Were Respondents Registered for My Account Before Applying for Benefits Percent Selected
Registered to apply for the benefit 33%
Was already registered 60%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 7%

Barriers & Motivators

Among those who submit paper forms to file their personal income taxes, the most frequently mentioned reason for filing this way rather than electronically is simply that it is their preferred method (39%). Fewer say the main reasons involve security issues (13%), that it is the preferred method of the person who does their taxes (11%), that they lack the equipment (11%) or that it is easier/simpler (11%).

Notable differences between demographic groups include:

Table 14. Thinking about when you filed your last personal income taxes, what would you say are the main reasons you opted to submit paper forms instead of submitting your forms electronically?

Base: Submit paper forms (n=1,511)
Main Reasons for Submitting Paper Forms Rather Than Filing Electronically Percent Mentioned
Preferred method (habit, comfortable, like to do it, understand better, record keeping, can review, etc.) 39%
Security issues (safer to send in paper) 13%
Preferred method of person who does my taxes (accountant, etc.) 11%
Lack of equipment (laptop, computer, printer, etc.) 11%
Easier / Simpler 11%
Not computer savvy 5%
Cheaper / No fees / No software to buy 5%
Don't trust online system 4%
Don't know how to access/do 4%
Lack of internet services 4%
Too confusing / Difficult on computer/online 4%
Not permitted due to complexity 4%
Online system is not user friendly (can't go back, can't correct errors, find forms, etc.) 3%
Can do it at my leisure / Go back to it later 2%
Online services are unreliable (hard to reach, etc.) 1%
Forms/guide are mail to the house (convenient) 1%
Can send all receipts at the same time 1%
Other 2%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 1%

Respondents who do not currently file their personal income taxes electronically were asked whether a series of factors are a major factor, a factor but not a major one, or not a factor at all to their decision to file by paper.

The most consequential factor is simply a lack of interest in filing electronically – 43% say that not being interested a major factor for them, while 22% say it is a factor, though not a major one. Respondents 75+ (70% say it is a factor) and 65-74 (70%) cite the lack of interest more often than those 35-54 (59%).

Concern about privacy or security risk follows closely behind a simple lack of interest when it comes to why respondents do not file electronically. Over half (60%) say it is a factor, including 42% who say it is a major factor. Concern is significantly higher among those 55-64 (63%), 65-74 (63%) than among those at both the youngest and oldest ends of the age spectrum. Under half (44%) of those 18-34 and 54% of those 75+ are concerned about security risks. Quebeckers seem more concerned (67%) than respondents from other regions in Canada.

Over half (57%) say that not having the software they need is a factor, significantly more than say they do not have the hardware they would need (37%) or do not have a strong enough internet connection (29%). Notably, lacking the hardware is a larger issue for those 75+ - 43% say it is a factor. The same holds true for Internet access – 36% of those 75+ and 33% of those 65-74 say that their poor internet connection is a factor, compared to 21% of those 35-54 and 26% of those 55-64. In contrast, there are no significant age differences when it comes to lacking the software needed to file electronically.

Around half believe that they would not be able to file electronically for a variety of personal reasons. Over half (55%) lack confidence in their ability to file electronically, while half feel it would be too stressful (51%) or too difficult for them (50%). These views are more commonly held among those 75+, compared to younger respondents. For example, 60% of those 75+ are not confident in their ability, compared to 50% among those 35-54 and 55-64. Similarly, 58% of those 75+ say it seems too difficult, compared to 47% among those 35-54 and 55-64. Respondents in Quebec are more likely to doubt their ability to file electronically (62%), find it stressful (59%) or difficult (57%) compared to respondents from other provinces/regions. It is possible that some of the differences observed between respondents from Quebec and those from other provinces in this study are due in part to Quebeckers needing to file separate provincial tax returns. In previous research conducted by the CRA, higher reported levels of stress and perceived complexity in tax processes seems to be more common among Quebeckers.

There also appears to be a link between income, education and whether respondents think they could personally handle filing electronically. Almost two-thirds (64%) of those with high school education or less are not confident in their ability to file electronically, compared to 53% among those with a college degree and 46% among those with a university degree. Similarly, 65% of those with a household income of less than $20K and between $20K-$40K and 58% of those with an income between $40K-$60K are not confident in their ability, compared to 48% among those with an income between $80K-$150K and just 33% of those with an income of $150K+.

Under half (41%) say that cost is a factor in their decision not to file online. Those with a household income of less than $20K (48%) are notably more concerned about cost than those with an income of $80K-$150K (35%) or more than $150K (34%). Respondents from Quebec (51%) are over twice as likely as respondents from Manitoba/Saskatchewan (24%) to cite cost as a factor.

There is some concern that forms will get lost if sent electronically, but less than half feel this is a factor that prevents them from filing electronically (39%). This concern is more pronounced among Quebeckers (50%), those with an income of less than $20K (49%), and those with only a high school education (43%).

Over a third (38%) believe their tax filing is too complex to submit electronically. Men are more concerned about this than women (42% vs 35%). Quebeckers (50%) are more likely to say their filing is too complex than respondents from all other regions. Those who received help filing their most recent taxes are significantly more likely to cite complexity as a barrier than those who did not receive help (51% vs 31%).

About a third (36%) say that for at least one form they submit, CRA requires them to submit it by paper. Men (39%), Quebeckers (49%) those with a household income under $20K (50%) and those with only a high school education (41%) are among the most likely to say this a factor.

Table 15. For each of the following, please tell me how big a factor it is for you personally.

Base: Submit paper forms (n=1,511)
Factors Influencing Decision to Submit Paper Forms Rather Than Filing Electronically A major factor A factor, but not a major one Not a factor at all Don't know + Prefer not to say
I am not interested in doing that 43% 22% 30% 4%
I'm concerned about the privacy or security risk 42% 19% 37% 3%
I don't have the software I'd need 37% 19% 38% 5%
I'm not confident in my ability to do it 34% 21% 43% 3%
It seems too difficult 30% 20% 45% 5%
It seems too stressful for me 30% 21% 46% 3%
I don't have the hardware I'd need 23% 13% 60% 3%
It would cost me money 23% 18% 54% 5%
My tax filing is too complex to do that 22% 17% 57% 5%
For at least one form I submit, CRA requires I submit it in paper form 22% 13% 48% 17%
I worry my forms will get lost if I submit them electronically 21% 17% 58% 4%
I don't have a good enough Internet connection 17% 11% 68% 3%

About one third (32%) say it is likely they will switch to filing electronically. Slightly less than a third say it is not very likely that they will switch (29%) while over a third (36%) are not at all likely to switch. There are significant differences across several demographic segments, including the following:

Table 16. How likely is it that you will ever switch from filing paper copies of your personal tax forms to filing your forms electronically?

Base: Submit paper forms (n=1,511)
Likelihood of Switching to Electronic Filing Percent Selected
Not at all likely 36%
Not very likely 29%
Somewhat likely 21%
Very likely 11%
Don't know + Prefer not to say 2%

Respondents who do not currently file electronically were presented with six factors and asked if they would increase their likelihood of switching to filing online. It is worth noting that each of these factors seem to have a greater influence on younger respondents (under 55) compared to those 65+.

The factors that most increase likelihood of switching to electronic filing are:

Even among those who say they are not likely to switch to filing electronically, roughly a third say that pre-filling their returns (32%) and knowing that My CRA was easy to use (30%) could make them certain or more likely to switch. Over two-thirds of those who say they are likely to switch overall say that ease of use (72%) and pre-filling returns (67%) would make them certain or more likely to switch.

A noted above, younger respondents are more likely than older respondents to say that pre-filling their information and knowing that the CRA My Account service was easy would make them certain or more likely to switch to filing electronically. In fact, two-thirds (65%) of those 18-34 say that knowing the service was easy to use would make them certain or more likely to switch, along with 58% of 35-54 year-olds. In contrast, under half (45%) of those 55-64 and roughly a third of those 65-74 (37%) and 75+ (34%) say knowing this would make them certain or more likely to switch. The 35-54 age group are particularly enthusiastic about the ability to pre-fill their returns (59%), compared to those 75+ (32%).

In keeping with trends noted throughout this report, there are differences based on income and education when it comes to the impact of these two factors on likelihood of switching to electronic filing. Over half (58%) of those with a household income of $80K-$150K say that knowing that the CRA My Account was easy to use would make them certain or more likely to switch, compared to a low of 36% among those with an income between $20K-$40K. Half (51%) of those with a university degree say knowing My Account was easy to use would make them certain or more likely to switch, compared to 44% among those with college education and 36% among those with high school education or less. When it comes to pre-filling information, over half of those with a household income of $80K-$150K (56%) and $150K+ (54%) say this would make them certain or more likely to switch, compared to just 39% among those with incomes less than $40K. University graduates are also more likely to say this would make them certain/more likely to switch (51%) than college educated people (45%) and those with high school education or less (34%).

Over a third would be certain or more likely to switch to filing electronically if they knew that all forms they needed could be filled out electronically (39%), if someone helped them do it (35%) and if they could be certain their forms were received by CRA (35%). Among those who already say they are likely to switch to filing electronically, over two-thirds (69%) say that knowing all their forms could be submitted electronically would make them certain/more likely to switch. Fewer, though still over half say that having help (57%) and knowing that CRA received their forms (59%) would also make them certain/more likely to switch. Roughly one-quarter of those who initially say they are not likely to switch to filing electronically say that knowing all forms could be filled out electronically (24%), having someone help them (25%) and if they could be certain their forms were received (24%) would make them certain or more likely to switch.

Again, younger respondents are more likely to say that knowing their forms could all be submitted electronically, having help, and confirmation that CRA received their forms would make them more likely to switch compared to older respondents. For example, over half (55%) of 18-34 year-olds would be more likely to switch if they had help, along with 46% of those 35-54. In contrast, a third or less of those 55-64 (31%) 65-74 (33%) and 75+ (29%) would be more likely to switch if they had help.

Knowing that their forms could be filled out electronically seems particularly influential for those with a household income of $80K-$150K and those with a university degree. Half (52%) of those with a household income of $80K-$150K and just under half (46%) of those with a university degree would be certain or more likely to file online if they knew this. Being certain that their forms were received by CRA is more important for Quebeckers (40%) than residents of Manitoba/Saskatchewan (27%), Alberta (26%) and BC (31%).

Finally, the possibility of submitting forms via online banking is the least influential factor. Just a quarter (27%) say this would make them certain or more likely to switch, though this number is significantly higher among those 35-54 (40%) and 18-34 (37%).

Table 17. For each of the following, please tell me if that would make certain that you would ...If Base: Submit paper forms (n=1,511)
Factors That Could Increase Likelihood of Switching to Filing Electronically Would make me certain to switch Would make me more likely to switch Would not make me any more likely to switch Don't know + Prefer not to say
The CRA would pre-fill my returns based on information they already had on file 12% 31% 50% 7%
I knew all the forms I needed could be filled out electronically 12% 27% 57% 5%
Using CRA's My Account online service was easy 11% 32% 51% 6%
I could be certain my forms were received by CRA 10% 25% 59% 6%
Someone helped me do it 9% 26% 60% 5%
My forms could be submitted over my online banking website 8% 19% 67% 7%

Tax Filing Segments

Three segments emerge from the data that may be of strategic value to CRA. First, there is the 23% of respondents who claim to have filed their last return electronically. They represent a significant portion of 2019 paper filers who the CRA may not need to devote efforts to convincing to file electronically. Second, there is a segment of 2019 paper filers who say they are at least somewhat likely to switch to filing electronically. They represent 25% of the overall sample. Finally, there is a segment comprising of half (50%) of the 2019 paper filers who say they are unlikely to ever switch to filing electronically. The breakdown of each segment by a number of demographic variables is noted in the tables below.

The "Already Switched" segment includes a greater percentage of 18–34-year-olds (19%) than the other two, and also includes a greater percentage with just high school education (40%) and incomes less than $20K (20%) than the Likely Switchers. However, the segment also includes a relatively high percentage of respondents with incomes of $80K-$150K (24%), compared to Unlikely Switchers.

Arguably, the "Likely Switchers" represent the most promising target for immediate conversion. This stands out in a number of ways. First, it skews slightly male (52%) and to the 35-54 age range (31%). They are also more likely to be residents of BC (18%), have a household income of $80K or more, and have a university degree (41%)

Conversely, the "Unlikely Switchers" are the most challenging segment and skew older (over 50% are 65+) and female (55%). They are more likely to have no formal education beyond high school (36%) and a household income under $40K. They are also more likely than the Likely Switchers to be from Quebec (38%).

Note: Results with subscript capital letters in the tables below indicate that the difference between the demographic groups analysed are significantly higher than results found in other columns in the table.

Table 18: Age Breakdown of Tax Filing Segments

Base: Respondents who file by mail and provide a response as to whether they would be likely to switch or respondents who file electronically (n=1901): Already Switched (n=423) Likely Switchers (n=462); Unlikely Switchers (n=1016)
Demographic Category Already Switched
A
Likely Switchers
B
Unlikely Switchers
C
18-34 19%
B C
7% 4%
35-54 31%
C
31%
C
21%
55-64 20% 25% 21%
65-74 17% 22% 30%
A B
75+ 13% 16% 24%
A B

Table 19: Gender Breakdown of Tax Filing Segments

Base: Respondents who file by mail and provide a response as to whether they would be likely to switch or respondents who file electronically (n=1901): Already Switched (n=423) Likely Switchers (n=462); Unlikely Switchers (n=1016)
Demographic Category Already Switched
A
Likely Switchers
B
Unlikely Switchers
C
Male 48% 52%
C
44%
Female 51% 47% 55%
B

Table 20: Education Breakdown of Tax Filing Segments

Base: Respondents who file by mail and provide a response as to whether they would be likely to switch or respondents who file electronically (n=1901): Already Switched (n=423) Likely Switchers (n=462); Unlikely Switchers (n=1016)
Demographic Category Already Switched
A
Likely Switchers
B
Unlikely Switchers
C
High School 40%
B
28% 36%
B
College‎/Vocactional 30% 31% 36%
University 30% 41%
A C
28%

Table 21: Income Breakdown of Tax Filing Segments

Base: Respondents who file by mail and provide a response as to whether they would be likely to switch or respondents who file electronically (n=1901): Already Switched (n=423) Likely Switchers (n=462); Unlikely Switchers (n=1016)
Demographic Category Already Switched
A
Likely Switchers
B
Unlikely Switchers
C
<$20K 20%
B
11% 16%
A
$20K-$40K 20% 20% 28%
A C
$40K-$60K 21% 18% 19%
$60K-$80K 10% 15% 14%
$80K-$150K 24%
C
25%
C
17%
$150K 5% 11%
A C
6%

Table 22: Regional Breakdown of Tax Filing Segments

Base: Respondents who file by mail and provide a response as to whether they would be likely to switch or respondents who file electronically (n=1901): Already Switched (n=423) Likely Switchers (n=462); Unlikely Switchers (n=1016)
Demographic Category Already Switched
A
Likely Switchers
B
Unlikely Switchers
C
Atlantic Canada 10% 9% 9%
Quebec 38%
B
25% 38%
B
Ontario/Nunavut 28% 31% 27%
Manitoba/Saskatchewan 6% 7% 5%
Alberta/Northwest Territories 8% 10% 9%
BC/Yukon 10% 18%
A C
12%

Strategically, if CRA wishes to convince more Canadians to switch to electronic filing, it is valuable to identify the largest barriers and most influential "nudges" that would convert Likely Switchers.

Software seems to be the most significant barrier for Likely Switchers. Over half (58%) do not have the software that they would need to file electronically. Half are concerned about privacy/security (51%), are not interested (50%), or not confident (50%). Slightly less than half think it would be too difficult (45%) or stressful (43%). Slightly fewer say their filing is too complex (41%) or would cost them money (40%). About a third believe CRA requires them to submit a particular form by paper (34%) or worry that their form will get lost (30%). Not having the hardware (27%) or internet connection (21%) are the least significant barriers.

Unlikely Switchers face many of the same barriers as Likely Switchers but tend to view almost all of them as more significant hurdles and rank them slightly differently. Lack of interest (74%) is the greatest barrier. Privacy concerns follow (65%). Over half lack confidence (57%), don't have the software (56%), and say it seems too stressful (55%) or difficult (53%). Under half are concerned about cost (42%) and forms getting lost (43%) or lack the hardware (41%). Complexity of their tax filing (37%), requirement to submit by paper (37%) and not having a good internet connection (33%) are the least significant barriers.

Table 23: Percentage who indicate that each barrier is a major factor or a factor, but not a major one

Base: Respondents who file by mail and provide an answer as to whether they would be likely to switch (n=1,478): Likely Switchers (n=462); Unlikely Switchers (n=1016)
Barrier Likely Switchers
A
Unlikely Switchers
B
I don't have the software I'd need 58% 56%
I'm concerned about the privacy or security risk 51% 65%
A
I am not interested in doing that 50% 74%
A
I'm not confident in my ability to do it 50% 57%
A
It seems too difficult 45% 53%
A
It seems too stressful for me 43% 55%
A
My tax filing is too complex to do that 41% 37%
It would cost me money 40% 42%
For at least one form I submit, CRA requires I submit it in paper form 34% 37%
I worry my forms will get lost if I submit them electronically 30% 43%
I don't have the hardware I'd need 27% 41%
I don't have a good enough Internet connection 21% 33%
A

When it comes to the most helpful nudges that CRA could present to Likely Switchers, knowing that My Account is easy to use would be the most influential. Almost three-quarters (72%) say this would make them certain or more likely to file electronically. Over two-thirds say that knowing that all forms could be filled out electronically (69%) and pre-filling returns (67%) would make them certain or more likely to switch. Over half would be more likely to switch if they could be certain the CRA received their forms (59%) or if someone helped them (57%). Finally, while submitting forms via their online banking website is the least influential factor, still half (49%) say it would make them certain or more likely to switch.

Less than a third of Unlikely Switchers say that any of the factors presented would make them more likely or certain to switch to online filing, but among the most influential are pre-filling returns (32%) and knowing My Account is easy to use (30%).

Table 24: Percentage who indicate that each factor would make them certain or more likely to switch to filing electronically

Base: Respondents who file by mail and provide an answer as to whether they would be likely to switch (n=1,478): Likely Switchers (n=462); Unlikely Switchers (n=1016)
Barrier Likely Switchers
A
Unlikely Switchers
B
If using CRA's My Account online service was easy 72%
B
30%
If I knew all the forms I needed could be filled out electronically 69%
B
24%
If the CRA would pre-fill my returns based on information they already had on file 67%
B
32%
If I could be certain my forms were received by CRA 59%
B
24%
If someone helped me do it 57%
B
25%
If my forms could be submitted over my online banking website 49%
B
16%

Conclusions

The findings of the research suggest that among those who have previously filed by paper, there is some willingness to file electronically. First, about a quarter of those who filed their 2019 return by paper filed their most recent return electronically. These individuals can be easily reminded to continue to file online in the future. Second, another quarter seem likely to switch to filing online. By targeting the latter group, based on their demographic characteristics, eliminating barriers, and emphasizing the most powerful incentives that would make them more likely to file online, CRA can likely increase uptake.

Knowing the demographic profile of the Likely Switchers can help CRA target this group more effectively. They skew male, and towards the 35-54 age category. They are also more likely to be residents of BC, have a household income of $80K or more, and have a university degree.

While Likely Switchers are open to the idea of electronic filing, they still face barriers to doing so. Not having the software they would need is the top concern (58% say it is a barrier). About half are concerned about privacy and security (51%). For these two barriers, Likely Switchers may require additional information on how to procure the software and about security measures to feel comfortable filing online.

Other significant barriers may require a slightly different approach. First, with half (50%) saying they lack confidence to file online and 45% indicating that it seems too difficult, reassurance that the process is easy could be helpful. In fact, when asked what impact knowing that My Account is easy to use would have on their likelihood to file, 72% say it would make them either certain or more likely to switch. Knowing that all their forms can be filed electronically (69% say it would make them certain or more likely to file online) and that information can be pre-filled (67%) are influential pieces of knowledge that may also help directly address the lack of confidence and concerns about difficulty.

Apathy is another barrier – 50% of Likely Switchers say they are simply not that interested in switching. Therefore, CRA will have to demonstrate the value of switching, whether that be through saving time, simplifying the process, etc.

While the Likely Switchers represent lower-hanging fruit for CRA to convince to file electronically, there remains a significant segment of filers (about half of respondents in this study) who say they are unlikely to switch. They are older (most likely 65 and over) and have lower levels of income and education. They are more likely to view almost all the barriers tested as significant and stand out as being more apathetic towards filing online and more concerned about security and privacy. If, in the future, CRA wishes to target this segment, demonstrating the value of filing electronically will be even more important, as will be reassurances regarding data security.

In summary, as CRA seeks to encourage more Canadians to file electronically, targeting the Likely Switchers first may be a relatively easier task than convincing the Unlikely Switchers. However, even the Likely Switchers segment will still require some education about the process and how it can be advantageous to them, as well as reassurances about the most common concerns.

Appendix A – Survey Methodology Report

Survey Methodology

Earnscliffe Strategy Group's overall approach for this study was to conduct a telephone survey of 2,000 Canadians aged 18 and older who filed their 2019 tax return by mail/paper rather than online, using Léger's centralized call-centre and state of the art Computer Aided Telephone Interviewing (CATI) system. A detailed discussion of the approach used to complete this research is presented below.

Questionnaire Design

The questionnaire for this study was designed by Earnscliffe in consultation with CRA and provided for fielding to Léger. The survey was offered to respondents in both English and French and completed based on their preferences.

Sample Design and Selection

CRA provided Earnscliffe with a list of 697,715 Canadians who filed their 2019 tax return by mail/paper. The list included each individual's province of residence and phone number. Earnscliffe provided the list to Leger for data collection.

Data Collection

The survey was conducted in English and French from May 11 to June 2, 2021. The survey was undertaken by Léger's virtual call-centre and state of the art Computer Aided Telephone Interviewing (CATI) system. Leger sampled from the list provided on a randomized basis.

Targets/Weighting

Initially, we did not set any quotas. As the survey was to be conducted on a randomized basis, we decided to monitor the natural fallout for province, age and gender before moving ahead with strict quotas or a weighting scheme. However, as data collection reached the midway point, we decided to implement provincial quotas in order to ensure the final sample reflected the composition of the list. The quotas were as follows:

Table 25: Provincial/Territorial Quotas
Province/Territory Percentage Sample Size
Newfoundland and Labrador 3.01% 61
Prince Edward Island .44% 9
Nova Scotia 3.62% 72
New Brunswick 2.99% 61
Quebec 34.72% 694
Ontario 28.07% 561
Manitoba 3.08% 62
Saskatchewan 2.77% 55
Alberta 8.67% 173
British Columbia 12.47% 249
Nunavut .03% 1
Northwest Territories .05% 1
Yukon .07% 1
Total 100% 2,000

Upon completion of the data collection, we decided to weight the sample by age (<55, 55-64, 65-74 and 75+) and gender within province, to the proportions from the CRA list.

Reporting

Results with subscript capital letters in the tables presented in this report (and under a separate cover) indicate that the difference between the demographic groups analysed are significantly higher than results found in other columns in the table. In the text of the report, unless otherwise noted, demographic differences highlighted are statistically significant at the 95% confidence level. The statistical test used to determine the significance of the results was the Z-test.

Quality Controls

Léger conducted a soft-launch pre-test of the survey, and Earnscliffe reviewed the data to ensure that all skip patterns were working and that all respondents were completing the survey in an appropriate amount of time. Initially, the average length of interview exceeded the 15 target, and the questionnaire was edited to shorten it. An additional pre-test was conducted to ensure that the revised questionnaire was an appropriate length.

Léger's data collection quality control process as it relates to telephone interviewing is concretely based on the following elements:

Table 26. Final dispositions
Numbers Attempted 71,295
Invalid 31
NIS, fax/modem, business/non-res. 15273
Unresolved (U) 39314
Busy 1452
No answer, answering machine 37862
In-scope - Non-responding (IS) 14658
Household refusal 10841
Respondent refusal
Language problem 774
Illness, incapable 628
Selected respondent not available 2080
Qualified respondent break-off 335
In-scope - Responding units (R) 2019
Language disqualify 19
No one 18+
Other disqualify
Completed interviews 2000
Response Rate = R/(U+IS+R) 3.61%

NONRESPONSE
Any survey that is conducted is potentially subject to bias or error. The possibility of non-response bias exists within the current sample. In particular, this survey would not include members of the population who do not have access to a telephone or who are not capable of responding to a survey in either English or French. In addition, some groups within the population are systemically less likely to answer surveys.

As is typically the case for telephone surveys, older individuals are easier to reach, so the survey underrepresented those age under age 55 and overrepresented those 65 to 74 and 75+.

SAMPLE PROFILE: UNWEIGHTED VS. WEIGHTED DISTRIBUTIONS

Table 27. Unweighted sample vs weighted sample by region
Region Unweighted Sample Weighted Sample
Atlantic 10% 10%
Quebec 35% 35%
Ontario 28% 28%
Manitoba/Saskatchewan 6% 6%
Alberta 9% 9%
British Columbia/Territories 13% 13%
Table 28. Unweighted sample vs weighted sample by gender
Gender Unweighted Sample Weighted Sample
Female 56% 52%
Male 44% 48%
Table 29. Unweighted sample vs weighted sample by age
Age Unweighted Sample Weighted Sample
<55 24% 35%
55-64 22% 22%
65-74 31% 25%
75+ 23% 19%

MARGIN OF ERROR
The margin of error for this sample of 2,000 Canadians who filed their 2019 return by paper/mail is +/-2.19%, 19 times out of 20.

SURVEY DURATION
The average survey duration was 16 minutes.

Appendix B – Survey Questionnaire

SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE

CRA Digital Acceleration Survey 2021

Telephone Survey Introduction

Hello/Bonjour. My name is _______ and I am calling from Earnscliffe Strategy Group, a public opinion research company. We are conducting a survey on behalf of the Government of Canada. May I please speak with [INSERT PARTICIPANT FIRST AND LAST NAME]?

[IF NECESSARY: Hello/Bonjour, am I speaking with [INSERT PARTICIPANT FIRST AND LAST NAME]?]

Would you prefer that I continue in English or French? Préfèrez-vous continuer en français ou anglais?

We are conducting a survey for the Government of Canada to gain insights to better understand how Canadians prefer to submit tax-related information to the Canada Revenue Agency. More specifically, the Canada Revenue Agency is interested in hearing from people who submit their tax returns by paper.

The survey should only take about 15 minutes to complete. Your participation in this survey is voluntary. Please be assured that your responses are confidential and will not be reported individually nor attributed to you personally. Your decision on whether or not to participate will not affect any dealings you may have with the Government of Canada nor with the Canada Revenue Agency.

All information relating to this survey is managed in accordance with requirements of the Privacy Act, the Access to Information Act, and any other pertinent legislation.

May I continue?

Yes
No

[IF NO: Is there a reason that prevents you from answering this survey by phone?
IF REASON IS DISABILITY, OFFER ALTERNATE FORMAT (ONLINE QUESTIONNAIRE OR PDF VIA EMAIL), WHERE APPROPRIATE. IF ACCEPTED, TAKE RESPONDENT EMAIL ADDRESS]

And, just to confirm, have I reached you on a landline phone or a cell phone?

Landline
Cell phone
Don't know/Refused

For your safety, are you currently driving?

Yes – SCHEDULE CALLBACK
No

Don't know/Refused

Thank you, let's begin the survey.

[INTERVIEWER NOTE: Additional background information if required]
This research is being conducted by Earnscliffe Strategy Group, a Canadian public opinion research firm on behalf of the Canada Revenue Agency, a department of the Government of Canada.

The purpose of this survey is to better understand Canadians' opinions and behaviours relating to submitting tax forms.

What about your demographic/personal information?

[ONLY IF ASKED HOW EARNSCLIFFE HAS THEIR NAME: Earncliffe is working under contract for the Canada Revenue Agency to conduct this research, and have been provided with a list of contact information of people who have submitted their tax returns by paper. Your name has been selected randomly from this list. All information relating to this survey is managed in accordance with requirements of the Privacy Act, the Access to Information Act, and any other pertinent legislation.

[ONLY IF NECESSARY] You can confirm the validity of this research by searching Canada Revenue Agency public opinion research or visiting www.Canada.ca/por-cra. If you have any questions about the survey, you may contact Krista Holmes, Senior Public Affairs Advisor at 343-551-6112 or Krista.Holmes@cra-arc.gc.ca.

Your help is greatly appreciated, and we look forward to receiving your feedback. [CONTINUE TO Q1]

Section 1: Current Perceptions and Behaviours

Newfoundland and Labrador 1
Nova Scotia 2
Prince Edward Island 3
New Brunswick 4
Quebec 5
Ontario 6
Manitoba 7
Saskatchewan 8
Alberta 9
British Columbia 10
Yukon 11
Nunavut 12
Northwest Territories 13
Prefer not to say [TERMINATE] 99

The first questions are about the ways that Canadians can file federal tax forms with the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA). These forms include the T1 income tax package that applies to most Canadians, but also includes many other types of forms that people may be required to complete when completing and submitting their annual tax filing.

2. How were your last personal [QUEBEC ONLY: federal] income taxes sent in? That is, was it sent in by mail or online?
By mail 1
Online (INCLUDES EFILE AND NETFILE) 2
Other 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99
3. Which of the following ways, if any, did you get any forms needed for preparing your last personal [QUEBEC ONLY: federal] income taxes? [SELECT ALL THAT APPLY]
Method Option
[DO NOT READ. VOLUNTEERED ONLY.] I never personally accessed or used any forms 0
I had a form or forms mailed to me 1
I printed off at least one form 2
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99
4. Generally speaking, how satisfied are you with the way in which you go about preparing and submitting your personal [QUEBEC ONLY: federal] income taxes to the Canada Revenue Agency?
Very dissatisfied 1
Somewhat dissatisfied 2
Neither satisfied nor dissatisfied 3
Somewhat satisfied 4
Very satisfied 5
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99
5. Did you prepare your last personal [QUEBEC ONLY: federal] income taxes on your own, or did you receive help from someone else?
Prepared on my own 1
Received help 2
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99
6. [IF RECEIVED HELP] Did the person who provided you with help preparing your last personal [QUEBEC ONLY: federal] income taxes also send in your forms to Canada Revenue Agency for you?
No, I sent them in myself 1
Yes 2
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99
7. Have you ever visited the tax pages of either the Canada.ca or Canada Revenue Agency website to search for information on tax-related matters?
Yes 1
No 2
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99
8. [UNLESS Q2=2 “ONLINE”] Have you personally ever submitted federal tax forms online or electronically?
No, I have never submitted a form to CRA online or electronically 1
Yes, I have submitted a form to CRA online or electronically 2
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99
9. Have you ever registered with CRA’s My Account online service?
Yes 1
No 2
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99 99

10. Which of the following do you have? [SELECT ALL. RANDOMIZE.]

A desktop or laptop computer or easy access to one at your household 1
A tablet, or mobile device such as a smartphone 2
High speed internet 3
A printer 4
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99

For each of the following, please tell me whether this is something you do frequently, sometimes, rarely or if it is something you don’t do. [RANDOMIZE]

11. Banking in-person or at a branch

12. Online banking

13. Make online purchases of any kind

Do not do this 1
Rarely 2
Sometimes 3
Frequently 4
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99

14. Since they were launched in 2020, have you ever registered online for either the Canada Emergency Response Benefit (CERB), the Canada Recovery Benefit (CRB) or the Canada Emergency Student Benefit (CESB) that the Government of Canada made available to individuals as a result of the pandemic?

No 1
Yes 2
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99

15. [IF YES AT Q9 AND Q14] Did you register for My Account to apply for this benefit or were you already registered beforehand?

Registered to apply for benefit 1
Was already registered 2
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99

[ASK Q16-Q35 IF Q2=1 “MAIL”]

The Canada Revenue Agency provides the option for people to submit forms electronically. You indicated earlier that you filed your last personal [QUEBEC ONLY: federal] income taxes by mail. The next questions are to help understand why you choose that method for submitting your tax forms, rather than submitting your form or forms electronically or in other words, online.

16. Thinking about when you filed your last personal [QUEBEC ONLY: federal] income taxes, what would you say are the main reasons you opted to submit paper forms instead of submitting your forms electronically? [OPEN END. ACCEPT UP TO THREE RESPONSES.]

[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99

17. I don’t have the hardware I’d need [INTERVIEWER NOTE IF NECESSARY: such as a personal computer or tablet]

18. I don’t have the software I’d need [INTERVIEWER NOTE IF NECESSARY: such as tax-filing application or program]

19. I don’t have a good enough Internet connection

20. I’m concerned about the privacy or security risk

21. It seems too difficult

22. I am not interested in doing that

23. It would cost me money

24. I’m not confident in my ability to do it

25. It seems too stressful for me

26. My tax filing is too complex to do that

27. I worry my forms will get lost if I submit them electronically

28. For at least one form I submit, CRA requires I submit it in paper form

Not a factor at all 1
A factor, but not a major one 2
A major factor 3
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99

Section 2: Forward Looking

29. [IF Q2= “MAIL”] How likely is it that you will ever switch from filing paper copies of your personal tax forms to filing your forms electronically?

Not at all likely 1
Not very likely 2
Somewhat likely 3
Very likely 4
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99

It’s possible there are some ways the process for submitting personal forms electronically could change or that there are existing options of which people are unaware. For each of the following, please tell me if that would make certain that you would switch to submitting your personal tax forms electronically, make you more likely to switch or not make you any more likely to switch. [RANDOMIZE]

30. If my forms could be submitted over my online banking website

31. If someone helped me do it

32. If I knew all the forms I needed could be filled out electronically

33. If I could be certain my forms were received by CRA

34. If using CRA’s My Account online service was easy

35. If the CRA would pre-fill my returns based on information they already had on file

Would not make me any more likely to switch to submitting electronically 1
Would make me more likely to switch to submitting electronically 2
Would make me certain to switch to submitting electronically 3
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99

Section 3: Demographics

The last few questions are strictly for statistical purposes. All of your answers are completely confidential.

36. What gender do you identify with?
Male 1
Female 2
Other (SPECIFY) 3
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to answer 9

37. In what year were you born?

[INSERT YEAR]

38. What is the language you speak most often at home?
English 1
French 2
Other (SPECIFY) 3
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to answer 9
39. What is the highest level of schooling that you have completed?
Grade 8 or less 1
Some high school 2
High school diploma or equivalent 3
Registered apprenticeship or other trades certificate or diploma 4
College, CEGEP or other non-university certificate or diploma 5
University certificate or diploma below bachelor’s level 6
Bachelor’s degree 7
Post graduate degree above bachelor’s level 8
40. What is your current employment status?
Student 1
Self-employed 2
Employed (full time) 3
Employed (part time) 4
Unemployed (looking for work) 5
Unemployed (not currently looking for work) 6
Unable to work 7
Retired 8
Homemaker 9
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99
41. Would you describe the community you live in as…
Urban 1
Suburban 2
Rural 3
Remote 4
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99
42. Which of the following categories best describes your total household income for 2020? That is, the total income of all persons in your household combined, before taxes?
Under $20,000 1
$20,000 to just under $40,000 2
$40,000 to just under $60,000 3
$60,000 to just under $80,000 4
$80,000 to just under $100,000 5
$100,000 to just under $150,000 6
$150,000 to just under $200,000 7
$200,000 and above 8
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to say 88
[DO NOT READ] Don’t know 99

43. Were you…?

Born in Canada 1
Born outside of Canada 2
[DO NOT READ] Prefer not to answer 9
44. Are you an Indigenous person, that is, First Nations, Métis or Inuk (Inuit)?
Yes 1
No 2
Prefer not to answer 9

45. [IF NOT INDIGENOUS] Are you…? [SELECT ALL THAT APPLY]

White 1
South Asian (e.g., East Indian, Pakistani, Sri Lankan, etc.) 2
Chinese 3
Black 4
Filipino 5
Latin American 6
Arab 7
Southeast Asian (e.g., Vietnamese, Cambodian, Malaysian, Laotian, etc.) 8
West Asian (e.g., Iranian, Afghan, etc.) 9
Korean 10
Japanese 11
Other [SPECIFY] 12
Prefer not to answer 99

46. Do you identify as a person with a disability? A person with a disability is a person who has a long-term or recurring impairment (such as vision, hearing, mobility, flexibility, dexterity, pain, learning, developmental, memory or mental health-related) which limits their daily activities inside or outside the home (such as at school, work, or in the community in general).

Yes 1
No 2
[Do not read] Don’t know 88
[Do not read] Prefer not to answer 99

[FOR PRE-TEST ONLY: ADD QUESTIONS A THRU J]

A. Did you find any aspect of this survey difficult to understand? Y/N

B. [IF A=YES] Please describe what you found difficult to understand.

C. Did you find the way of the any of the questions in this survey were asked made it difficult for you to provide your answer? Y/N

D. [IF C=YES] Please describe the problem with how the question was asked.

E. Did you experience any difficulties with the language? Y/N

F. [IF E=YES] Please describe what difficulties you had with the language.

G. Did you find any terms confusing? Y/N

H. [IF G=YES] Please describe what terms you found confusing.

I. Did you encounter any other issues during the course of this survey that you would like us to be aware of? Y/N

J. [IF I=YES] What are they?

This concludes the survey. In the coming months the report will be available from Library and Archives Canada. We thank you very much for taking the time to participate, it is greatly appreciated.