Survey on Banking of Canadians

Final Report

Prepared for the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada

Supplier Name: Phoenix SPI
Contract Number: 5R000-182334-001-CY
Contract Value: $202,640.58 (including HST)
Award Date: 2019-01-25
Delivery Date: 2019-07-12

Registration Number: POR 114-18

For more information on this report, please contact the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada at: info@fcac-acfc.gc.ca

Ce rapport est aussi disponible en français.

This public opinion research report presents the results of a telephone survey of 3,007 Canadians that was conducted between February 8 and March 10, 2019. Surveys averaged 15 minutes to complete.    

This publication may be reproduced for non-commercial purposes only. Prior written permission must be obtained from FCAC. For more information on this report, please contact FCAC at:

Financial Consumer Agency of Canada
427 Laurier Ave. West,
Ottawa ON
K1R 1B9

Catalogue Number:
FC5-62/2019E-PDF

International Standard Book Number (ISBN):
978-0-660-31828-8

Related publications (registration number: POR 114-18):
Catalogue Number FC5-62/2019F-PDF (Final Report, French)
ISBN 978-0-660-31829-5

© Her Majesty the Queen in Right of Canada, as represented by the Minister of Finance Canada, 2019. 

Table of Contents

• 1. Executive Summary
• 2. Introduction
  • 1. Background and Objectives
  • 2. Methodology
  • 3. Notes to Reader
• 3. Detailed Findings
  • 1. Banking Responsibilities
  • 2. Views on Dealing with their Bank
  • 3. Communication and Disclosure
  • 4. Relationship with Bank Employees
  • 5. Fraud and Financial Abuse
  • 6. Technology and Accessibility
  • 7. Suggestions for Improving Bank Products and Services
• 4. Conclusions
• 5. Appendix
  • 1. Technical Specifications of Research
  • 2. Survey Questionnaire
    

List of Figures

Figure 1: Banking Responsibility
Figure 2: Banking Proxies
Figure 3: Trusted Contact
Figure 4: Most Common Method of Banking
Figure 5: Most Common Method of Banking [all age segments]
Figure 6: Frequency of Banking
Figure 7: Banking Products [seniors]
Figure 8: Issues Using Banking Products
Figure 9: Banking Products with Issues [seniors]
Figure 10: Preferred Method of Receiving Banking Information
Figure 11: Preferred Method of Receiving Banking Information [all age segments]
Figure 12: Clarity of Information Received from Bank.
Figure 13: Frequency of Receiving Difficult to Understand Information [seniors]
Figure 14: Perceptions of Bank Employees
Figure 15: Perceptions of Bank Employees [all age segments]
Figure 16: Perceptions of Bank Employees' Skills & Knowledge
Figure 17: Perceptions of Bank Employees' Skills & Knowledge [all age segments]
Figure 18: Financial Abuse, Fraud, or Scams [all age segments]
Figure 19: Frequency of Online Banking
Figure 20: Issues with Online Banking
Figure 21: Health Issues
Figure 22: Bank Closures

1. Executive Summary

The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) is a federal government agency that protects and educates consumers about financial products and services. In the fall of 2018, the Minister of Finance tasked FCAC with creating a code of conduct to guide banks in their delivery of services to Canada’s seniors.

FCAC commissioned Phoenix Strategic Perspectives (Phoenix SPI) to conduct a 15-minute telephone survey of Canadians aged 18 and older. A total of 3,007 interviews were completed via dual-frame (landline and cell phone) random digit dialling: 2,254 interviews were completed with Canadians aged 55 and older,^[1] and 753 interviews were completed with Canadians under 55 years of age. The fieldwork was conducted from February 8 to March 10, 2019. The sample of 2,254 Canadians aged 55 and older can be considered accurate to within ±2.1% at the 95% confidence level. The sample of 753 Canadians under the age of 55 can be considered accurate to within ±3.6% at the 95% confidence level. The margin of error for the overall sample of 3,007 Canadians aged 18 and older is ±1.8% at the 95% confidence level.

The purpose of this research was to assess the banking experiences of seniors as well as to identify challenges and potential solutions.

The following are key findings from the survey:

Communication and Disclosure

• Over the past 12 months, seniors (Canadians aged 55 and older) most commonly conducted their banking in one of two ways: online or using their bank’s website (42%), or in-person at a branch (32%). Seniors aged 75 and older were more likely than any other age group to bank in person at a branch (54%) compared to 11% of Canadians under 55 years of age.
• Seniors aged 75 and older were less likely to report using online banking (23%) than younger seniors (45% of 65 to 74 year olds and 50% of 55 to 64 year olds) and non-seniors (Canadians under 55 years of age; 45%). Seniors who do not use online banking pointed to safety and security concerns as the primary barrier (32%).
• Almost one-third of seniors spoke with an employee at a bank branch at least several times a month over the past 12 months. Similar proportions said they did so once a month (27%) or once every few months (26%). Among those aged 75 and older, more than two-thirds (68%) have conducted their banking in person at a branch by speaking with a bank employee at least once a month over the past 12 months.
• Over the past 12 months, fewer than one in 10 seniors experienced issues when using their banking products or services. Issues most commonly faced by seniors were a mistake or error on the bank’s part (24%) and issues with security or fraud (20%).
• Seniors prefer more traditional methods of receiving information about their banking products and services, such as by regular mail (37% compared to 18% of non-seniors) and in person at a branch (25% compared to 12% of non-seniors). Whereas non-seniors were more likely to prefer to receive this information digitally through email or text message (37% compared to 17% of seniors) or via an online bank account or website (29% compared to 18% of seniors). Canadians aged 75 and older were more likely than any other age group to prefer to receive information about banking products and services in person at a branch.
• Relatively few seniors (12%) reported that the information provided by their bank over the past 12 months was difficult to understand. Seniors were no more likely than non-seniors to report difficulties in understanding.

Relationship with Banks

• Seniors reported a positive relationship with their bank. In general, seniors indicated that bank employees:
  • Treat them with respect (93%); 
  • Make an effort to understand their needs (82%);
  • Ensure they understand their banking products and services (81%); and
  • Know how to address their banking needs (79%).
• Seniors aged 75 and older were more likely than any other age group to indicate that they rely on the advice of their bank when making decisions about their banking products and services (64%).

Fraud and Financial Abuse

• Canadian seniors were more likely than non-seniors to agree that bank employees have the knowledge and skills to help them identify signs of financial abuse, fraud, or scams (68% and 62%, respectively). However, seniors were less likely to report that their bank provided them information about how to protect themselves from financial abuse, fraud or scams (57% and 64%, respectively).
• Seniors suggest banks might use consumer alerts (16%) or directly contact consumers if the bank identifies questionable transactions in their accounts (11%) to protect Canadians from financial abuse, fraud or scams.

Technology and Accessibility

• Four in 10 Canadian seniors (39%) bank online at least once a week. Almost three-quarters of seniors who bank online reported they have not encountered issues with their online banking over the past 12 months.
  • Seniors aged 75 and older are less likely to use online banking than are those in any other age group.
  • The primary barriers to online banking for seniors who do not bank online are safety or security concerns (32%), a preference for in-person or telebanking (20%), and not using the internet (20%).
• A small portion of (5%) seniors reported they had health issues that made it difficult for them to access products or services from their banks. Among those seniors who reported health issues, mobility issues (53%) were the most commonly cited.
• Within the past five years, 13% of seniors were affected by the closure of a local bank branch (compared to 10% of non-seniors). However, of these seniors, 39% were affected “a lot” because there are few or no other branches or banks nearby that they can get to easily.

The contract value was $202,640.58 (including HST).

I hereby certify as a Senior Officer of Phoenix Strategic Perspectives that the deliverables fully comply with the Government of Canada political neutrality requirements outlined in the Policy on Communications and Federal Identity of the Government of Canada and Procedures for Planning and Contracting Public Opinion Research. Specifically, the deliverables do not contain any reference to electoral voting intentions, political party preferences, standings with the electorate, or ratings of the performance of a political party or its leader.

Alethea Woods
President
Phoenix SPI

2. Introduction

The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) commissioned Phoenix Strategic Perspectives Inc. (Phoenix SPI) to conduct public opinion research (POR) on the use of banking products and services by Canadians.

1. Background and Objectives

FCAC is a federal government agency that protects and educates consumers about financial products and services. In November 2018, it was announced that FCAC was going to engage with banks and seniors’ groups to create a code of conduct to guide banks on how they can best deliver their services to meet the needs of Canada’s seniors.

FCAC commissioned POR and inform the development the code of conduct. While much research has been done on the issues older Canadians face with financial services, important gaps remain. The purpose of this research was to assess the banking experiences of seniors as well as to identify challenges and potential solutions.

2. Methodology

A nationally representative telephone survey of Canadians aged 18 or older was used for this research. All respondents were required to hold an account with a bank at the time of the interview. A total of 3,007 interviews were completed via dual-frame (landline and cell phone) random digit dialling—specifically, 2,254 interviews were completed with Canadians aged 55 and older, and 753 interviews were completed with Canadians under 55 years of age. The fieldwork was conducted February 8 to March 10, 2019.

The sample of Canadians aged 55 and older included an oversample of Canadians aged 75 and older.^[2] Canadians under 55 were sampled in proportion to the population. The sample of 2,254 Canadians aged 55 and older can be considered accurate to within ±2.1% at the 95% confidence level. The sample of 753 Canadians under the age of 55 can be considered accurate to within ±3.6% at the 95% confidence level. The overall sample of 3,007 Canadians aged 18 and older can be considered accurate to within ±1.8% at the 95% confidence level.

Survey data have been weighted by region, age and gender to ensure results that are representative of the Canadian population. Population figures from Statistics Canada (2016 Census) were used to construct the weights for the survey. The results of this research can be considered representative of the populations of Canadians aged 55 and older, Canadians under the age of 55, and the general population of Canadians aged 18 and older.

More information on the methodology can be found in the Appendix of this report: Technical Specifications of Research.

3. Notes to Reader

• The main findings presented in the detailed results are those pertaining to Canadians aged 55 and older. Throughout this report, these survey respondents are often referred to as “seniors” or Canadians aged 55 and older. The results for the sample of Canadians under 55 years of age are compared to the findings from the sample of seniors, where relevant. These respondents are often referred to as “non-seniors” or Canadians under the age of 55.
• All results in the report are expressed as a percentage, unless otherwise noted.
• Throughout the report, percentages may not always add to 100 due to rounding and/or multiple responses being offered by respondents.
• Unless otherwise noted, the response options, “don’t know” and “not applicable”, have been removed from the frequencies presented in the graphs.
• The survey questionnaire is appended to the report.

3. Detailed Findings

1. Banking Responsibilities

The majority of respondents are responsible for their own banking
Most seniors in Canada (70%) are responsible for conducting the majority of their banking. Seniors were less likely than non-seniors (75%) to be solely responsible for their banking and were more likely to share this responsibility equally with someone else, such as a family member or friend (22% versus 18%, respectively). Relatively few seniors (7%) have delegated all of their banking responsibility (Figure 1).

Figure 1: Banking Responsibility

Text Description - Figure 1

Intro1. To start, who does the majority of your banking?
Base: all respondents [Refusal=<1%]       

One in five Canadian seniors acts as a proxy with regards to banking
One in five Canadian seniors acts on behalf of someone else with regards to banking (Figure 2). Seniors were no more likely than non-seniors to indicate they act on behalf of someone else. However, Canadians aged 45 to 54 were more likely than most other age groups to indicate they act on behalf of someone else (28% compared to a low of 11% of 18 to 24 year olds and high of 20% of 65 to 74 year olds).

Figure 2: Banking Proxies

Text Description - Figure 2

Intro2. Do you currently act on behalf of someone else with regards to banking?
Base: all respondents [DK/Refusal=<1%]

Six in 10 Canadian seniors would give their bank permission to contact someone they trust if their bank had concerns about their well-being
If presented with the opportunity, six in 10 seniors (61%) would give their bank permission to contact someone they trust if the bank had concerns about their well-being or about questionable transactions in their accounts. Just over one-third (35%) would not give their bank permission to contact someone they trust, and 3% were unsure. Non-seniors were just as likely as seniors to indicate they would give their bank permission to contact someone they trust (Figure 3).

Figure 3: Trusted Contact

Text Description - Figure 3

GE1. If given the opportunity, would you give your bank permission to contact someone you trust if your bank had concerns about your well-being or about questionable transactions in your accounts?
Base: all respondents [Refusal=<1%]

2. Views on Dealing with their Bank

Most seniors generally feel positively about dealing with their bank
The vast majority of seniors (91%) generally feel positively about dealing with their bank.^[3] In contrast, fewer non-seniors (83%) expressed positive feelings about dealing with their bank.

Among seniors, positive feelings were most often based on good customer service (18%) or aspects of customer service, such as having a good experience with the bank and being a long-term client (14%), receiving personal and attentive service (10%), receiving friendly and courteous service (9%), being treated with respect (7%), and receiving service from helpful (7%) and knowledgeable (3%) bank employees.

Other reasons for satisfaction or positive feelings included simply having no issues or problems with the bank (21%), having one’s needs met (8%), receiving fast service in branch (7%), and having trust and confidence in the bank and its employees (7%).

Feelings of discontent were relatively limited and expressed through references to poor customer service (7%), dissatisfaction with fees (3%), and financial products that do not meet one’s needs (1%).  

3. Communication and Disclosure

Seniors are more likely to bank in person
Over the past 12 months, the majority of seniors most commonly did their banking online or using their bank’s website (42%), or in person at a branch (32%). Fewer seniors most commonly banked using an ATM (15%), via a mobile app (5%), or by phone (4%).

Compared to non-seniors, seniors were more likely to have banked most commonly over the past 12 months in person (11% and 32%, respectively) or using an ATM (6% and 15%, respectively) and were far less likely to have most commonly banked via a mobile app (5% and 35%, respectively; Figure 4).

Figure 4: Most Common Method of Banking

Text Description - Figure 4

Q1. Over the past 12 months, what is the most common way you did your banking?
Base: all respondents; [DK/Refusal=<1%]

Over the past 12 months, Canadians aged 75 and older were more likely than any other age group to have most commonly banked in person at a branch (54%) and were less likely to have most commonly banked online (23%; Figure 5).

Figure 5: Most Common Method of Banking [all age segments]

Text Description - Figure 5

Q1. Over the past 12 months, what is the most common way you did your banking?
Base: all respondents; [DK/Refusal=<1%]

Seniors bank by speaking with an employee at a branch more frequently than do non-seniors
Over the past 12 months, 58% of seniors have conducted their banking by speaking with an employee at a branch at least once a month (i.e., at least once a week, several times a month or once a month) as compared to 39% of non-seniors (Figure 6).

Canadians 75 and older were the most likely to bank in person relatively frequently: at least once a week (16%) or several times a month (22%).  

Figure 6: Frequency of Banking

Text Description - Figure 6

Q2. Over the past 12 months, how often did you do your banking in person?
Base: all respondents; [DK/Refusal=<1%]

Seniors use a variety of banking products and services
Almost all seniors have a chequing or savings account (97%) and the majority (87%) have a credit card. Nearly-two thirds (64%) have a registered account, such as a Registered Retirement Savings Plan (RRSP), Registered Retirement Income Fund (RRIF), or a Tax-Free Savings Account (TFSA), and 54% have a personal line of credit or other loan. Fewer seniors have other savings (such as a GIC (29%), a mortgage (26%), or a home equity line of credit (24%). Very few (2% or less) identified having other banking products, such as a reverse mortgage (2%; Figure 7).

In comparing the banking products used by seniors and non-seniors, seniors are more likely to have a personal line of credit or other type of loan (54% and 49%, respectively), a home equity line of credit (24% and 17%, respectively), an RRSP, RRIF, or TFSA (64% and 56%, respectively) and other savings, such as a GIC (29% and 16%, respectively).    

Figure 7: Banking Products [seniors]

Text Description - Figure 7

Q3. Which of the following banking products and services do you have? [multiple responses accepted]
Base: n=2,254; those 55 plus [DK/Refusal=1%] [Multiple responses accepted]

Few seniors and non-seniors report experiencing issues with banking products and services
Over the past 12 months, nearly one in 10 (8%) Canadians aged 55 and older have experienced an issue when using a banking product or service (Figure 8). ^[4] In general, non-seniors were more likely than seniors to have had experienced such an issue (11% versus 8%, respectively).  However, seniors and non-seniors did not differ in the products and services with which they experienced issues.

Figure 8: Issues Using Banking Products

Text Description - Figure 8

CD_4. Over the past 12 months, did you experience any issues when using these banking products or services?
Base: all respondents who use banking products [DK=<1%]

Seniors who have experienced issues when using their banking products and services most commonly experienced an issue with a chequing or savings account (44%), or credit card (21%). A smaller proportion of seniors have experienced issues with a registered account (8%), a personal line of credit or other loan (6%), other savings (5%), a mortgage (3%), or a home equity line of credit (1%; Figure 9). Among these seniors, the most frequently cited issues were a mistake on the bank’s part (24%), an issue related to security or fraud (20%), being overcharged fees (13%), or not receiving the expected interest rate (9%).

Fewer than 5% of seniors identified other issues. Other issues identified most often related to information, such as taking too long to get information or service, receiving unclear or incorrect information, receiving conflicting information or advice, not receiving requested information, services, or forms, and not knowing where to obtain information. A small proportion also identified problems with online banking and taking too long to process an application or receive a decision.

Just over one in 10 seniors who experienced an issue with a banking product or service could not recall with which product or service they experienced an issue.

Figure 9: Banking Products with Issues [seniors]

Text Description - Figure 9

Q4a. With what product or service did you experience an issue?
Base: n=170; those 55 plus who experienced issues with banking products

Seniors prefer more traditional methods of receiving information about their banking products or services
The majority of Canadian seniors prefer to receive information about their banking products and services through more traditional methods, such as by mail (37%) or in person at a branch (25%). A little over one-third prefer to receive this information electronically, for example, via online or through a mobile app (18%), or via email or text message (17%). A small proportion prefer to receive this information by phone (3%; Figure 10).

Figure 10: Preferred Method of Receiving Banking Information

Text Description - Figure 10

Q5. How do you prefer to receive information about your banking products and services?
Base: all respondents [DK/Refusal=1%]

In general, older Canadians prefer traditional methods of communication, while younger Canadians prefer electronic communication (Figure 11). Correspondingly, Canadians aged 75 and older were more likely than any other age group to prefer to receive information about their banking products and services in person at a branch (35%). When looking at the different age groups of seniors, these seniors were also more likely than Canadians under the age of 65 to prefer mail (40%) and less likely to prefer to receive information electronically via online or through a mobile app (10%), or through email or text message (8%).

Figure 11: Preferred Method of Receiving Banking Information [all age segments]

Text Description - Figure 11

CD_5. How do you prefer to receive information about your banking products and services?
Base: all respondents [DK/Refusal=1%]

Some Canadians have received information from their bank that was difficult to understand
Over the past 12 months, a little over one in 10 (12%) seniors said there were times when the information they received from their bank was difficult to understand. Seniors were no more likely to report this than were individuals in any other age group (Figure 12).

Figure 12: Clarity of Information Received from Bank.

Text Description - Figure 12

CD_6. Over the past 12 months, have there been times when you’ve received information from your bank that was difficult to understand?
Base: all respondents [DK=1%]

Among seniors who have received information that was difficult to understand, almost half (45%) specified this occurred rarely, 35% specified this occurred sometimes, 11% specified often and 8% specified nearly always. Canadians aged 65 or older are more likely to report they rarely receive information from their bank that is difficult to understand than are Canadians aged 55 to 64 (34% versus 55% and 53% of Canadians aged 55 to 64, 65 to 74, and 75 years and older, respectively).

Figure 13: Frequency of Receiving Difficult to Understand Information [seniors]

Text Description - Figure 13

CD_6a. How often would you say this tended to happen?
Base: n=262; those 55 plus who received difficult information [DK/Refusal=1%]

Seniors who had received information from their bank that was difficult to understand (n=262) suggested communications might be enhanced through better explanations of terminology (25%), better in-person or over the phone explanations (18%), more detailed information (13%) and using simpler language (13%). Seniors also suggested the organization of the content might be improved (8%), and relevant information could be explained more clearly and concisely (7%).

Fewer seniors (less than 5%) suggested banks might provide a written copy of information, make pages less cluttered, use larger text/font, use visual aids such as pictures, charts or graphs, and use videos.

Nearly one-quarter (23%) of seniors who received information they found difficult to understand did not provide a suggestion.

4. Relationship with Banks

In general, seniors and non-seniors report a positive relationship with their bank
Seniors and non-seniors used a five-point Likert scale (1=strongly disagree; 5=strongly agree) to rate their level of agreement or disagreement with the following five statements about their interactions with bank employees^[5]:

• You are treated with respect and professionalism when you do your banking;
• Bank employees make an effort to understand your needs;
• Bank employees ensure that you understand your banking products and services;
• Bank employees know how to address your needs; and
• You rely on the advice of your bank when you make decisions about your banking products and services.

More than nine in 10 seniors and non-seniors agreed they are treated with respect and professionalism when they do their banking (93% and 91%, respectively). In addition, smaller majorities of seniors and non-seniors agreed that bank employees try to understand their needs (82% and 78%, respectively), ensure they understand their banking products and services (81% and 73%, respectively), and know how to address their needs (79% and 73%, respectively). A little over half of seniors and non-seniors rely on the advice of their bank when making decisions about their banking products and services (58% and 53%, respectively).^[6] With the one exception—being treated with respect and professionalism—seniors were more likely to offer positive assessments of their bank and bank employees compared to non-seniors (Figure 14).

Figure 14: Perceptions of Bank Employees

Text Description - Figure 14

TR. Thinking about the interactions you’ve had during the past 12 months, please tell me how much you agree or disagree with the following statements….
Base: all respondents who use banking products [DK/Refusal=1% or less]

In general, seniors who bank in person report the most positive relationships with their banks.
Seniors who most commonly bank in person were more likely than seniors who most commonly bank using other methods to provide positive assessments of bank employees and their bank. Specifically:

• Seniors who most commonly bank in person were more likely than seniors who most commonly bank online or via a mobile app to agree that bank employees make an effort to understand their needs (87% versus 80% and 80%, respectively) and that they rely on the advice of their bank when making decisions about their banking products and services (66% versus 52% and 55%, respectively).
• Seniors who most commonly bank in person were also more likely than seniors who most commonly bank via an ATM, online, or a mobile app to agree that bank employees know how to address their needs (86% versus 76%, 75% and 74%, respectively).
• Further these seniors were most likely to agree that bank employees ensure they understand their banking products and services (89% versus phone: 78%; ATM: 81%; online: 76%; and mobile app: 76%).
• Lastly, seniors who bank most commonly in person were more likely than those who most commonly banked online to agree they are treated with respect and professionalism when they do their banking (96% versus 90%, respectively).

In addition, seniors who most commonly banked using a mobile app were less likely to strongly agree that bank employees make an effort to understand their needs (40% versus 52% of those who bank via ATM, 52% who bank online, and 59% who bank via telephone).
Seniors who most commonly banked via an ATM were more likely than those who banked online to agree (generally and strongly) that bank employees ensure they understand their banking products and services (81% versus 76%, respectively), to strongly agree that they rely on the advice of their bank when making decisions about banking products and services (31% versus 25%), and to agree that they are treated with respect and professional when they do their banking (24% versus 17%, respectively).

In general, seniors aged 75 and older were more likely than younger Canadians to provide positive assessments of bank employees and their bank (Figure 15). Specifically:

• Seniors aged 75 and older were more likely than those between the ages of 18 and 64 to both strongly and generally agree that bank employees make an effort to understand their needs and ensure that they understand their banking products and services;
• Seniors aged 75 and older were more likely than any other age group to strongly agree bank employees know how to address their needs; and
• Seniors aged 75 and older were more likely than any other age group to both strongly and generally agree they rely on the advice of their bank when making decisions about their banking products and services.

Figure 15: Perceptions of Bank Employees [all age segments]

Text Description - Figure 15

TR1-5. Thinking about the interactions you’ve had during the past 12 months, please tell me how much you agree or disagree with the following statements….
Base: all respondents who use banking products [DK/Refusal=1% or less]

5. Fraud and Financial Abuse

Seniors were more likely than non-seniors to agree bank that employees have the knowledge and skills to help identify signs of financial abuse, fraud, or scams
Seniors (68%) were more likely than non-seniors (62%) to agree that bank employees have the knowledge and skills to help them if their bank identified questionable transactions in their accounts that might be signs of financial abuse, fraud, or scams (Figure 16).

Figure 16: Perceptions of Bank Employees' Skills & Knowledge

Text Description - Figure 16

FR1. Thinking about the interactions you’ve had during the past 12 months, please tell me how much you agree or disagree with he following statements….
Base: all respondents who use banking products [DK/Refusal=4%]

Seniors were more likely than non-seniors to strongly agree that bank employees have the skills and knowledge to help them if their bank identified questionable transactions in their accounts (Figure 17).

Figure 17: Perceptions of Bank Employees' Skills & Knowledge [all age segments]

Text Description - Figure 17

FR1. Thinking about the interactions you’ve had during the past 12 months, please tell me how much you agree or disagree with he following statements….
Base: all respondents who use banking products [DK/Refusal=4%]

Seniors were less likely to report they have been provided information about how to protect themselves from financial abuse, fraud, or scams
Four in 10 seniors have not received information from their bank about how to protect themselves from financial abuse, fraud, or scams (Figure 18). Further, half of Canadians aged 75 and older (51%) reported they have not received information from their bank about protecting themselves from financial abuse, fraud or scams. In contrast, almost one-third of non-seniors reported not having received this information from their bank.

Figure 18: Financial Abuse, Fraud, or Scams [all age segments]

Text Description - Figure 18

FR2. Has your bank ever provided you with information about protecting yourself from financial abuse, fraud, or scams?
Base: all respondents who use banking products [Refusal=<1%]

Seniors who received information about protecting themselves from their bank were more likely to report banking online (63%) than banking by phone (44%), in person (51%), or via an ATM (55%). Among non-seniors, there were no statistically significant differences in terms of the channels used to bank and receive information about protecting themselves from financial abuse, fraud or scams.

Suggestions to help protect seniors from financial abuse/fraud
Canadian seniors suggested banks could help protect their clients from financial abuse, fraud and scams by providing consumer alerts (16%), contacting customers if questionable transactions are identified (11%), providing customer education on financial abuse, fraud and scams (9%), providing more information and updates (8%), having better online security/technology (7%) and better detecting fraud through technology (7%).^[7] 

6. Technology and Accessibility

Seniors bank online less frequently than non-seniors
Seniors bank online less frequently than non-seniors, with 39% of seniors using online banking at least once a week compared to 74% of non-seniors (Figure 19). Further, 34% of seniors indicated they never bank online compared to only 3% of non-seniors. The likelihood of never banking online increases with age, from 1% of Canadians under 45 years of age to 8% of those 45 to 54, 22% of those 55 to 64, 33% of those 65 to 74, and 57% of seniors aged 75 and older.

Figure 19: Frequency of Online Banking

Text Description - Figure 19

TE1. How often do you use online banking?
Base: all respondents [DK/Refusal=1%]

Seniors who do not bank online identified safety and security concerns (32%) as their primary barrier. Safety and security concerns were followed by a preference for banking in person or by phone (20%) and not using the internet (20%). Other barriers include not having a computer (12%), finding online banking to be too difficult or complex (11%), and a lack of trust in online banking (10%). Reasons identified less frequently include lacking reliable internet access at home (6%), not being shown how to bank online (6%), no need or interest (4%), and their banking is done by someone else (2%).

Those 55 to 64 and 65 to 74 years of age were more likely to point to safety or security concerns as the reason they do not bank online (39% and 37%, respectively, versus 23% of seniors aged 75 and older).

The majority of seniors who bank online do not encounter issues
Of seniors who have used online banking over the past 12 months, nearly three-quarters (74%) have not experienced issues. Non-seniors (58%) were more likely to experience issues than were seniors. Issues experienced by seniors are presented in Figure 20.

Figure 20: Issues with Online Banking

Text Description - Figure 20

TE3. Over the past 12 months, what issues, if any, did you encounter when using online banking?
Base: n=1,402; those 55 plus who use banking products and bank online [Refusal=<1%] [Multiple responses accepted]

Older seniors are more likely to experience health issues that make it difficult to access banking products or services than are any other age group
The vast majority (95%) of seniors reported that, over the past 12 months, they did not have health issues that made it difficult to access products or services from their bank (Figure 21). The likelihood of having these health issues was highest among seniors aged 75 and older (8%) (although caution should be exercised in interpreting this finding given small sample size).

Figure 21: Health Issues

Text Description - Figure 21

TE4. Over the past 12 months, have you had any health issues that made it difficult to access products or services from your bank?
Base: all respondents; those who use banking products [DK/Refusal=<1%]

Of those who experienced health issues that made it difficult for them to access products or services from their bank, over half (53% of seniors and 52% of non-seniors) indicated these issues were related to mobility and  just under one in five identified these issues as a chronic illness or injury (18% of seniors and 17% of non-seniors). Other issues identified less frequently (4% or less) include problems with vision, difficulty remembering, a diagnosed mental health condition, and difficulty hearing.

Various factors make it difficult to access bank services
Seniors and non-seniors were asked to indicate if the following barriers have made it difficult to access services at their bank over the past 12 months:

• You could not make it to your bank during their normal business hours;
• When you visited your bank, there were not enough employees to assist you;
• You lived far from a bank branch;
• You were not able to access a bank branch via public or personal transport;
• Your bank did not present information in your language of choice; and
• You were not treated with respect.

Similar proportions of seniors and non-seniors face barriers in accessing banking products and services. Among seniors, one in five (20%) pointed to a lack of employees to assist them as a factor that made it difficult for them to access services at their bank. Approximately one in 10 or fewer experienced other barriers. For example, 13% could not make it to their bank during normal business hours, 12% lived far from a bank branch, 7% were unable to access a bank branch via public or personal transport, 4% were not presented information in their language of choice, and 4% were not treated with respect.

Non-seniors were more likely than seniors to report difficulty making it to their bank branch during their normal business hours (31% and 13%, respectively). In addition, Canadians between the ages of 55 and 64 were more likely then those aged 65 years and older to report this as a barrier (16% and 11%, respectively).

A very small number of respondents (less than 1%) identified factors other than those that were asked about. These include issues with physical access to a bank branch, issues with customer service or support, issues with bank policies or practices, and issues with phone access.

Seniors are more likely than non-seniors to have been affected by the closure of a bank branch within the past five years
Seniors are more likely than non-seniors to have been affected by the closure of a bank branch within the past five years (13% and 10%, respectively; Figure 22).

Figure 22: Bank Closures

Text Description - Figure 22

TE5. Over the past 5 years, have you been affected by the closure of your local bank branch?
Base: all respondents [DK=<1%]

Of seniors who have been affected by a branch closure, close to half were affected ‘a lot’ either because there are few or no bank branches nearby (39%), or because they experienced issues with the location of the new branch (7%). In addition, just over one-third were affected ‘a little’ either because they had to change where they did their banking (28%), or because of general inconvenience (6%). A further 16% were affected ‘not much’ because the new location was still easy to get to and 10% were affected ‘not at all’ because they do most of their banking online.

7. Suggestions for Improving Bank Products and Services

Suggestions for improving bank products and services
When asked what banks could do to improve how they provide their products and services, 37% of seniors were satisfied and had no suggestions to offer. An additional 19% did not know how banks could improve their products and services.

Suggestions among seniors included improving policies and practices in general (10%), lowering fees (8%), incorporating more personal and flexible customer service (7%), and providing more information in plain language (6%). Other suggestions (5% or less) included hiring more employees and staff, better interest rates, better training for employees, ending the practice of closing branches, spending more time with clients, more advertising, longer hours, improving online or mobile banking, providing information in other languages, opening more branches, locations or kiosks, and improving products in general.

4. Conclusions

The Survey on Banking of Canadians yielded several important findings concerning the banking experiences of Canada’s seniors.

• Seniors use and prefer more traditional forms of banking and communication. Nearly one-third of seniors most commonly bank in person, with six out of every ten seniors banking in person at least once a month. In contrast, only one out of every ten non-seniors most commonly bank in person. Similarly, seniors prefer to receive information about their banking products and services through more traditional methods, such as by mail or in person at a branch. The preference for receiving this information in person increases with age.
• One-third of seniors never bank online. This is largely due to safety and security concerns as well as a preference for banking through traditional service channels. In contrast, only three percent of non-seniors never bank online. One-quarter of seniors who have used online banking in the past 12 months reported having experienced issues such as website crashing, trouble navigating the website or forgetting a password.
• In general, seniors who bank in person report the most positive relationship with their banks. Seniors who most commonly bank in person are most likely to agree that bank employees make an effort to understand their needs, ensure they understand products and services, and treat them with respect.
• A small minority of seniors have been affected by the closure of a bank branch in the past 5 years. However, of these seniors, four in ten were greatly affected due to a lack of other branches or banks nearby.
• Seniors were less likely to say they have received information about financial abuse, fraud or scams. Most notably, half of Canadians aged 75 and older reported they have not received information from their bank about protecting themselves from financial abuse, fraud or scams.

5. Appendix

1. Technical Specifications of Research

The following specifications applied to this survey:

• A 15-minute random digit dialling (RDD) telephone survey was administered to 3,007 Canadians, 18 years of age and older who held an account with a bank at the time of the interview.
• Interviewing was conducted by Elemental Data Collection Inc. (EDCI) using Computer Aided Telephone Interviewing (CATI) technology.
• Following survey best practices, the questionnaire was pre-tested in advance of the fieldwork to ensure that it measured what it was intended to measure.
  • Respondents had the choice of participating in the official language of their choice.
  • The pre-test interviews were digitally recorded and reviewed by Phoenix SPI team members and FCAC officials.
  • There were 10 pre-test interviews in each official language.
  • Overall, the questionnaire worked well. There were no significant problems in terms of design or respondents’ comprehension of the questions. The only issue was the questionnaire length; it was too long. As a result, several questions were removed to bring the average interview length down to 15 minutes.
• All survey participants were informed that their participation is voluntary, and that information collected is protected under the authority of the Privacy Act.
• Calling was conducted at different times of the day and the week to maximize the opportunity to establish contact.
• A minimum of eight call-backs were attempted to reach potential respondents in the landline sample before a sample record was retired. A minimum of five call-backs were attempted to reach potential respondents in the cell sample before a sample record was retired.
• Interviewers mentioned in their introduction that the study was sponsored by FCAC.
• A total of 3,007 interviews were completed:
  • 2,254 interviews were completed with Canadians aged 55 and older, and 753 interviews were completed with Canadians under 55 years of age.
  • 1,807 interviews were completed with the landline sample, and 1,200 interviews with the cell phone sample.
  • The sample of Canadians aged 55 and older included an oversample of 703 Canadians over the age of 74.
  • Canadians under 55 were sampled in proportion to the population.
• The sample of 2,254 Canadians aged 55 and older can be considered accurate to within ±2.1% at the 95% confidence level. The sample of 753 Canadians under the age of 55 can be considered accurate to within ±3.6% at the 95% confidence level.
• The fieldwork was conducted February 8 to March 10, 2019.
• The table below presents information about the final call dispositions for this survey, as well as the associated response rates^[8]. The overall response rate was 7% (10% for the landline sample and 5% for the cell phone sample).

• The potential for non-response bias was assessed by comparing the unweighted sample distribution to the actual population. Non-response is the result of a unit of the sample refusing to take part in the survey (a refusal) or not being reached during the data collection period (non-contact). Non-response can bias a survey sample when there are differences between respondents and non-respondents. Consistent with most telephone surveys of the general public, younger Canadians are under-represented, and 45 to 54 year olds are over-represented in the survey sample. The survey data were weighted using population figures from Statistic Canada’s 2016 census data to address these variations and to correct the sample design, which included an oversample of Canadians 75+. Weighting serves to reduce bias should it be present, but not to eliminate it completely.

2. Survey Questionnaire

Survey on Banking of Canadians

Section 1: Introduction

Good morning/afternoon/evening, my name is [Interviewer's name]. I’m calling on behalf of Phoenix SPI, a public opinion research company. We are conducting a survey for the Government of Canada on issues of interest to Canadians. Would you prefer to continue in English or French? / Préférez-vous continuer en anglais ou en français?

Please be assured that we are not selling or soliciting anything. The survey takes about 15 minutes and is voluntary. Your responses will be kept entirely confidential and anonymous.

[LANDLINE SAMPLE]

1. We choose telephone numbers at random and then select one person from each household to be interviewed. To do this, we would like to speak to the person in your household, 18 years of age or older, who has had the most recent birthday. Would that be you?
   
   Yes                  GO TO E
   No                   ASK TO SPEAK TO ELIGIBLE PERSON; REPEAT INTRO

[CELL SAMPLE]

2. Are you 18 years of age or older?
   
   Yes                  CONTINUE
   No                   THANK/DISCONTINUE

3. Are you in a place where you can safely talk on the phone and answer my questions?
   
   Yes                  GO TO E                   
   No                   ASK D

4. We would like to conduct this interview with you when it is safe and convenient to do. When would it be more convenient for me to call back?
   
   SCHEDULE CALL-BACK IF POSSIBLE (TIME/DAY): _______________     

[EVERYONE]

5. Do you work in any of the following areas? [READ LIST; IF RESPONDENT VOLUNTEERS HE/SHE IS RETIRED: STOP READING AND PROCEED WITH SURVEY]
   
   Advertising or Market Research or Public Relations   
   The media (i.e. TV, radio, newspapers)
   Banks or other financial institutions
   THANK/DISCONTINUE IF ANY OF THE ABOVE

6. In what year were you born?
   
   [RECORD YEAR]
   REFUSAL – ASK G

7. Would you be willing to tell me in which of the following age categories you belong?
   [READ LIST]

1. 18 to 24
2. 25 to 34
3. 35 to 44
4. 45 to 54
5. 55 to 64
6. 65 to 75
7. 75 to 80
8. 81 to 84
9. 85 or older
10. DO NOT READ: Refusal TERMINATE

8. In which province or territory do you live? [DO NOT READ]

1. Newfoundland and Labrador       
2. Prince Edward Island                   
3. Nova Scotia                                 
4. New Brunswick                            
5. Quebec                                        
6. Ontario                                         
7. Manitoba                                      
8. Saskatchewan                             
9. Alberta                                          
10. British Columbia                           
11. Yukon                                           
12. Northwest Territories                   
13. Nunavut                                       
14. Refusal                              TERMINATE

9. Do you hold an account with a bank?
   
   Yes                  CONTINUE   
   No                   THANK/DISCONTINUE

The questions in this survey deal with banking, but please be assured that you will not be asked to provide any information about your personal finances. The Government of Canada would like to find out what Canadians think about their banks. IF A RESPONDENT QUESTIONS THE LEGITIMACY OF THE SURVEY, PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION:

Can contact the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada Consumer Services Centre from Monday to Friday 8:30am to 5:00pm eastern time:
For service in English: 1-866-461-3222
For service in French: 1-866-461-2232

[NOTE TO INTERVIEWER: READ IF RESPONDENT HOLDS AN ACCOUNT WITH MORE THAN ONE BANK AND SEEKS CLARIFICATION ABOUT WHICH BANK THE SURVEY QUESTIONS REFER TO: IF YOU BANK WITH MORE THAN ONE FINANCIAL INSTITUTION, PLEASE FOCUS ON THE ONE THAT YOU USE MOST OFTEN]

INTR_1: To start, who does the majority of your banking? [READ LIST]

1. You, or
2. You share responsibility equally with someone else, such as a family member or friend, or
3. Someone else, such as a family member or friend
4. [DO NOT READ] Don’t Know
5. [DO NOT READ] Refusal

INTR_2: Do you currently act on behalf of someone else with regards to banking? This could be formally through a Power of Attorney or informally by helping a family member with his or her banking, such as paying bills or managing accounts. If asked by the respondent, paying bills refers to managing one’s bill payments.

1. Yes
2. No
3. [DO NOT READ] Don’t Know
4. [DO NOT READ] Refusal

Section 2: Communication and Disclosure

CD_R1:  The first few questions ask about your banking experience and how you prefer to get information on banking products and services.

CD_1 Over the past 12 months, what is the most common way you did your banking? [READ LIST]

1. In person at a branch
2. By phone
3. Using an ATM (automated teller machine)
4. Online or using your bank’s website
5. Via a mobile app
6. [DO NOT READ] Other_ Please specify
7. [DO NOT READ] Don’t Know
8. [DO NOT READ] Refusal

CD_2 Over the past 12 months, how often did you do your banking at a branch by speaking with a bank employee? Would you say… [READ LIST]

1. Daily
2. At least once a week
3. Several times a month
4. Once a month
5. Once every few months
6. Once a year
7. Never
8. [DO NOT READ] Don’t know
9. [DO NOT READ] Refusal
10. [DO NOT READ]: Never; I do it all online or by telephone
11. [DO NOT READ]: Never; my bank does not have physical branch locations

CD_3 Which of the following banking products and services do you currently have? [READ LIST. ACCEPT MULTIPLE RESPONSES] INTERVIEWER: IF NEEDED, REMIND THE RESPONDENT THAT YOU ARE NOT ASKING FOR ANY ACCOUNT SPECIFIC INFORMATION – JUST WHETHER OR NOT THEY HAVE ONE OF THESE PRODUCTS.

1. Chequing or savings bank account
2. Credit card
3. Personal Line of Credit or other loan
4. Mortgage
5. Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC) [INTERVIEWER: IF NEEDED, A HELOC IS A REVOLVING CREDIT PRODUCT THAT IS SECURED BY THE BORROWER’S RESIDENTIAL PROPOERTY]
6. Reverse mortgage
7. Registered account such as RRSP, RRIF or TFSA
   
   [INTERVIEWER: USE FULL TERMS IF NEEDED]:
   1. RRSP: A Registered Retirement Savings Plan
   2. RRIF: A Registered Retirement Income Fund
   3. TFSA: Tax-Free Savings Account

   [INTERVIEWER: THE FOLLOWING ADDITIONAL REGISTERED ACCOUNTS MAY BE ACCEPTED]:

   4. RESP: Registered education savings plan
   5. RDSP: Registered disability savings plan
   6. LIRA: Locked-in retirement account
   7. LRSP: Locked-in retirement savings plan
   8. LRIF: Locked-in retirement income fund
   9. LIF: Locked-in income fund
   10. PRPP: Pooled registered pension plan
   11. RPP: Registered pension plan
   12. Spousal RRSP: Spousal registered retirement savings plan.

8. Other savings such as a Guaranteed Investment Certificate
9. Other_ Please specify
10. DO NOT READ: Don’t know
11. DO NOT READ: Refusal

CD_4 Over the past 12 months, did you experience any issues when using these banking products or services?

1. Yes
2. No
3. DO NOT READ: Don’t know
4. DO NOT READ: Refusal

CD_4A [CD_4=1] With what product or service did you experience an issue? IF RESPONDENT VOLUNTEERS THAT ISSUES WERE EXPERIENCED WITH MORE THAN ONE PRODUCT/SERVICE SAY: If you experienced issues with more than one product or service, please tell me which product or service you experienced the biggest issue with.  [READ LIST; LIST TO BE POPULATED WITH ITEMS MENTIONED AT CD_3]

1. Chequing or savings bank account
2. Credit card
3. Personal Line of Credit or other loan
4. Mortgage
5. Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC)
6. Reverse mortgage
7. Registered account such as RRSP, RRIF or TFSA
   [INTERVIEWER: USE FULL TERMS IF NEEDED]:
   1. RRSP: A Registered Retirement Savings Plan
   2. RRIF: A registered retirement income fund
   3. TFSA: Tax-Free Savings Account
8. Other savings such as a Guaranteed Investment Certificate
9. Other _Please specify

CD_4B Over the past 12 months, what issues did you encounter with [INSERT PRODUCT/SERVICE FROM CD_4A]? [DO NOT READ LIST; ACCEPT MULTIPLE RESPONSES]

1. You didn’t know where to obtain information
2. You were given incorrect information
3. You were given unclear information
4. You received conflicting information/advice from different people/sources
5. Did not receive requested information/service/form(s)
6. It took too long to process your application/get a decision
7. It took too long to get information/service
8. Mistake(s)/error(s) on the bank’s part
9. Other (specify) _____________________
10. Can’t recall
11. Refusal

CD_5 How do you prefer to receive information about your banking products and services? [READ LIST]

1. In person at a branch
2. By phone
3. Via online bank account, bank website, mobile app or online chat support
4. Via email or text message
5. By regular mail
6. DO NOT READ: Other_ Please specify
7. DO NOT READ: Don’t know
8. DO NOT READ: Refusal

CD_R2: Could you please tell me if the following statements describe your experience getting information on banking products and services from your bank. If something does not apply to you, please just say so.

CD_6 Over the past 12 months, have there been times when you’ve received information from your bank that was difficult to understand?

1. Yes
2. No
3. DO NOT READ: Don’t know
4. DO NOT READ: Refusal

 CD_6A [IF CD_6=1] How often would you say this tended to happen? [READ LIST]

1. Rarely
2. Sometimes
3. Often
4. Nearly always
5. DO NOT READ: Don’t know
6. DO NOT READ: Refusal

CD_6B [Ask if CD_6 = 1] What could your bank do to provide you with information that is easier to understand? [DO NOT READ LIST. ACCEPT MULTIPLE RESPONSES]

1. Use larger text/font
2. Use videos
3. Use visual aids such as pictures, charts or graphs
4. Provide a better explanation of terminology
5. Make pages less cluttered
6. Give more detailed information
7. Improve the organization of content
8. Other _Please Specify
9. Don’t know
10. Refusal

Section 3: Relationship with Banks

TR_R1: We would now like to ask you about your interactions with bank employees - including in-person, by phone or online. Thinking about the interactions you’ve had during the past 12 months, please tell me how much you agree or disagree with the following statements, using a 5-point scale where ‘1’ means strongly disagree, ‘5’ means strongly agree, and ‘3’ means neither agree nor disagree. If something does not apply to you, please just say so.

[ROTATE STATEMENTS; REPEAT SCALE INSTRUCTIONS AS NEEDED]

TR_1 Bank employees make an effort to understand your needs.
TR_2 Bank employees know how to address your needs.
TR_3 Bank employees ensure that you understand your banking products and services.
TR_4 You rely on the advice of your bank when you make decisions about your banking products and services. 
TR_5 You are treated with respect and professionalism when you do your banking.

[RESPONSE OPTIONS; INTERVIEWER: IF A RESPONDENT GIVES THE LABEL – AGREE/STRONGLY AGREE, ETC. ACCEPT AND DO NOT CONFIRM SCALE NUMBER]

1. Strongly disagree
2. Disagree
3. Neither agree nor disagree
4. Agree
5. Strongly agree
6. Don’t know
7. Refusal
8. Not applicable

Section 4: Fraud and Financial Abuse

FR_R1: The next few questions ask about scams, fraud and financial abuse - including times when a bank account has been used without permission or someone felt pressure to share their money or property.

FR_R2: Please tell me how much you agree or disagree with the following statement. To do so, please use a 5-point scale where ‘1’ means strongly disagree, ‘5’ means strongly agree, and ‘3’ means neither agree nor disagree. [INTERVIEWER: ACCEPT ANSWER IF RESPONDENT PROVIDES RESPONSE AS STATEMENT]

FR_1 Bank employees have the skills and knowledge to help you if your bank identified questionable transactions in your accounts that might be signs of financial abuse, fraud, or scams. 

1. Strongly disagree
2. Disagree
3. Neither agree nor disagree
4. Agree
5. Strongly agree
6. Don’t know
7. Refusal
8. Not applicable

FR_2 Has your bank ever provided you with information about protecting yourself from financial abuse, fraud, or scams?

1. Yes
2. No
3. DO NOT READ: Don’t know
4. DO NOT READ: Refusal

FR_3 What do you think your bank could do to help protect you from financial abuse, fraud or scams? [MARK ALL THAT APPLY. DO NOT READ]

1. *To be populated fully following the first few interviews*
2. Provide alerts when there are scams or frauds taking place
3. Better fraud detection through technology (e.g, predictive analytics)
4. Provide customer education on financial abuse, fraud, and scams
5. Improved authentication for transactions
6. Permit biometrics (e.g., use of fingerprints, hand geometry, retina patterns, voice patterns, etc.) to authenticate the person
7. Human review of transactions
8. Contact consumer if questionable transactions identified
9. Contact an authorized representative (e.g., POA)
10. Better training for bank employees
11. Modify transaction limits
12. Hotline to report financial abuse, fraud, or scams
13. Other [TEXT FIELD]
14. Don’t know
15. Refusal
    

Section 5: Technology and Accessibility

TE_R1: Next, we would like to ask you about your experiences with online banking.

TE_1 How often do you use online banking? This includes banking on your computer, tablet, or other mobile device. [READ LIST]

1. Daily
2. At least once a week
3. Several times a month
4. Once a month
5. Once every few months
6. Once a year
7. Never
8. [DO NOT READ] Don’t know
9. [DO NOT READ] Refusal

TE_2A [If TE_1=5, 6] What are the main reasons you do not frequently bank online? [DO NOT READ LIST; ACCEPT MULTIPLE RESPONSES]

1. You do not have reliable access to the internet at home
2. You have safety or security concerns
3. You find online banking to be too difficult or complex
4. You prefer banking in-person or by phone
5. Bank products or services you need are not available online
6. You have never been shown how to use online banking
7. Other_ Please specify
8. Don’t know
9. Refusal

TE_2B [If TE_1= 7] What are the main reasons you do not bank online? [DO NOT READ LIST; ACCEPT MULTIPLE RESPONSES]

1. You do not use the internet
2. You do not have reliable access to the internet at home
3. You have safety or security concerns
4. You find online banking to be too difficult or complex
5. You prefer banking in-person or by phone
6. Bank products or services you need are not available online
7. You have never been shown how to use online banking
8. Other_ Please specify
9. Don’t know
10. Refusal

TE_3 [If TE_1=1,2,3,4,5,6] Over the past 12 months, what issues, if any, did you encounter when using online banking? [DO NOT READ; ACCEPT MULTIPLE RESPONSES]

1. Trouble navigating the website
2. Forgetting your password
3. Transferring money accidentally
4. Difficulty reversing or stopping transactions
5. Did not remember how to log in
6. Lost/misplaced log in information
7. Did not encounter any issues when using online banking
8. Other_ Please specify
9. Don’t know
10. Refusal

TE_R2 We would now like to ask you about your experience accessing banking products and services.

TE_4 Over the past 12 months, have you had any health issues that made it difficult to access products or services from your bank?

1. Yes
2. No
3. Don’t know
4. Refusal

TE_4A [Ask if TE_4A =1] Over the past 12 months, what health issues made it difficult for you to access products or services from your bank?  [DO NOT READ; ACCEPT MULTIPLE RESPONSES]

1. Difficulty hearing
2. Problems with vision
3. Mobility issues
4. Difficulty remembering
5. Diagnosed mental health condition
6. Chronic illness/injury
7. Other_ Please specify
8. You have not had health related issues
9. Don’t know
10. Refusal

TE_5 Over the past 12 months, did any of the following make it difficult to access services at your bank? [READ LIST; RANDOMIZE]

• You could not make it to your bank during their normal business hours
• When you visited your bank, there were not enough employees to assist you
• You lived far from a bank branch
• You were not able to access a bank branch via public or personal transport
• Your bank did not present information in your language of choice
• You were not treated with respect
• [VOLUNTEERED] Other_ Please specify

 [RESPONSE OPTIONS; DO NOT READ]

1. Yes
2. No
3. Don’t know
4. Refusal
5. Does not apply

TE_5 Over the past 5 years, have you been affected by the closure of your local bank branch? [DO NOT READ]

1. Yes
2. No
3. Don’t know
4. Refusal

TE_5A [If TE_5=1] How did this branch closure or relocation affect your ability to conduct your regular banking activities? [DO NOT READ; ACCEPT MULTIPLE RESPONSES]

1. Not at all since you do most of your banking online
2. Not much since the new location was still easy to get to
3. A little since you had to change where you did your banking
4. A lot because there are few or no other branches or banks nearby that you can get to easily
5. Other_ Please specify
6. Don’t know
7. Refusal

Section 6: General

GE_R We would now like to ask you a few general questions about your banking products and services.

GE_1 If given the opportunity, would you give your bank permission to contact someone you trust if your bank had concerns about your well-being or about questionable transactions in your accounts? [DO NOT READ; INTERVIEWER: IF ASKED BY RESPONDENT, WELL-BEING REFERS TO MENTAL HEALTH, PHYSICAL HEALTH, AND SAFETY FROM FINANCIAL FRAUD]

1. Yes
2. No
3. Don’t know
4. Refusal

GE_2 In general, how do you feel about dealing with your bank?
[TEXT FIELD]

GE_2A Please briefly describe why you feel this way.
[TEXT FIELD]

GE_3 What do you think banks could do to improve how they provide their products and services? [DO NOT READ LIST; ACCEPT MULTIPLE RESPONSES]

1. *To be populated fully following the first few interviews*
2. Stop closing branches
3. Spend more time with clients
4. Provide information in plain language
5. Provide information in different languages
6. Better train bank employees
7. Open a kiosk
8. Other_ Please specify
9. Don’t know
10. Refusal
11. I am satisfied and have no suggestions

Section 7: Demographic and Socio-Economic Questions

DM_R1 The last few questions are for classification purposes only

DM_1 [RECORD BY OBSERVATION] If unsure of respondent’s gender, please confirm.

DM_2 What is your current marital status? [DO NOT READ]

1. Married
2. Living with partner (common-law)
3. Separated
4. Divorced
5. Widowed
6. Single (never married)
7. Don’t know
8. Refusal

DM_3 Were you born in Canada? [DO NOT READ]

1. Yes
2. No
3. Don’t know
4. Refusal

DM_3A [If DM_3=2] In what year did you first immigrate or move to Canada?

1. [Min: 1899 Max: 2019]
2. Don’t know
3. Refusal

DM_4 Do you identify as an Aboriginal person, that is, First Nations (North American Indian), Métis or Inuk (Inuit)? [DO NOT READ] INTERVIEWER: IF THE RESPONDENT ANSWERS ESKIMO, CODE YES.

1. Yes
2. No
3. Don’t know
4. Refusal

DM_5 What is the highest level of formal education that you have completed? [READ LIST; STOP WHEN A RESPONSE IS SELECTED]

1. Grade 8 or less
2. Some high school
3. High school diploma or equivalent
4. Registered Apprenticeship or other trades certificate or diploma
5. College, CEGEP or other non-university certificate or diploma
6. University certificate or diploma below bachelor's level
7. Bachelor's degree
8. Post graduate degree above bachelor's level
9. [DO NOT READ] Prefer not to answer

DM_6 Which of the following categories best describes your current employment status? Are you…[READ LIST; STOP WHEN A RESPONSE IS SELECTED]

1. Working full-time, that is, 35 or more hours per week?
2. Working part-time, that is, less than 35 hours per week?
3. Self-employed?
4. Unemployed, but looking for work?
5. A student attending school full-time?
6. Retired?
7. Not in the workforce? [Full-time homemaker, unemployed, not looking for work]
8. [DO NOT READ] Other – [Do not specify]
9. [DO NOT READ] Refused

DM_7 Which of the following categories best describes your total household income for 2018? That is, the total income of all persons in your household combined, before taxes. Please be assured that your response to this, and all, questions in the survey is confidential [READ LIST; STOP WHEN A RESPONSE IS SELECTED]

1. Under $20,000
2. $20,000 to just under $40,000
3. $40,000 to just under $60,000
4. $60,000 to just under $80,000
5. $80,000 to just under $100,000
6. $100,000 to just under $150,000
7. $150,000 and above
8. [DO NOT READ] Refused

DM_8 Overall, who in your household is primarily responsible for making sure that the regular ongoing bills and other financial commitments are met? [DO NOT READ UNLESS HELPFUL]

1. You
2. Your spouse/partner
3. You share responsibility equally with <your spouse/partner> / <someone else in the household>
4. Someone else in the household
5. Nobody in particular
6. Someone outside of the household
7. Don’t know
8. Refusal

DM_9 Would you please provide your postal code? [TEXT FIELD: ENTER POSTAL CODE]
DM_9A [IF NO] Would you be comfortable providing the first 3 digits of your postal code? [TEXT FIELD: ENTER FSA]

That concludes the survey. Thank you very much for your thoughtful feedback. It is much appreciated. This survey was conducted on behalf of the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada.