Periodic health examination, 1995 update: 3. Screening for visual problems among elderly patients


Table 3: Summary of manoeuvres, effectiveness, levels of evidence and recommendations for screening for visual impairment among elderly patients
ManoeuvreEffectivenessLevel of evidence* Recommendation*
Snellen sight chartUse of chart reliably detects reduced visual acuity in community studies

Population screening can lead to useful improvements in vision

Cohort study [11,12] (II-2)
 

Cohort study [15] (II-2)

Fair evidence to include in the periodic health examination (PHE) (B)
Funduscopy or retinal photography in diabetic patientsFunduscopy and retinal photography are sensitive for detecting retinopathy; early detection preserves vision

Photocoagulation in proliferative diabetic retinopathy preserves vision

Expert opinion [96] (III)
 
 

Randomized controlled trials [85-87,89] (I)

Fair evidence to include in the PHE of diabetic patients (B)
Funduscopy to detect age-related macular degeneration (ARMD)ARMD can be detected by those trained in ophthalmoscopy

Photocoagulation preserves vision in patients with neovascular changes from ARMD

Expert opinion [38] (III)
 

Randomized controlled trials [37-40] (I)

Insufficient evidence to include in or exclude from the PHE (C)
Funduscopy, tonometry or automated perimetry to detect glaucomaExamination of optic disc (fundoscopy) is sensitive for detecting glaucoma

Schiötz tonometry has poor sensitivity and specificity for early detection of glaucoma

Automated perimetry (Humphrey) is sensitive for detecting glaucoma

Topical application of beta-adrenergic blocker lowers IOP and may retard vision loss

Cohort study [37] (II-2)
 

Case series [42,53,54] (III)
 

Case series [60] (III)
 

Randomized controlled trials [62-70] (I)

Insufficient evidence to include in or exclude from the PHE (C)

*For descriptions of the other levels of evidence and classification of recommendations see Appendix 1 in part 1 of the 1992 update (CMAJ 1992; 147: 443)


Return to text