Because it's nice to know what
other spinners think about a fiber you haven't
yet tried, welcome to the Knittyspin Fiber
Fiesta feature! Each type of fiber is tested
by up to 5 average spinners, each with a different
background and level of experience. Each spinner
is provided with the same amount of fiber,
and each spinner spins, plies, finishes and
knits each fiber as it speaks to them. Their
feedback is collected on a standardized form
and summarized below. New! Follow
one spinner's comments all through each review,
right up to the yarn they spun and swatch they
knit.
Fiber that did not receive good feedback
will not be featured in Knitty, in accordance
with our review policy, so if a fiber
is featured here, it means the majority of
spinners liked it!
Retail prices are in USD.
Our spinners this issue:
Spinner
Spinning
how long?
What do you
spin on?
What
is the next spinning skill you'd like
to learn or brush up on this winter?
A
About 7 years
Majacraft Rose
I want to work on
different ways to spin with color, creating
different effects in my yarn and knitted
fabric.
AS
About 4 years,
mostly on handspindles
Schacht Sidekick
I need to spend some quality
time getting to know my Sidekick and taking
more control of the yarn I spin
C
Approx. 19 years.
I started knitting when my oldest was 1
and then I wanted to make my OWN yarn.
It was a logical next step to start spinning.
Schacht Cherry Matchless,
Louet S75
There’s too much I
want to brush up on this winter. There’s
the fiber sampler I bought from Beth that
I haven’t even cracked open. There’s
the giant bag of odds and ends I’ve
saved from my Phat Fiber boxes that I want
to core spin. There’s the project
I’ve been meaning to start at the
beginning of fall for the last several
years – spinning enough for an entire
sweater…
CK
I've been spinning for 2
1/2 years
Schacht Matchless and Ladybug
I'd like to work on cables
and crepes to get a consistent result.
E
I have been spinning in
my imagination for about 45 years. My secret
wish was granted about 5 years
ago
Schacht Matchless
I am planning on making
this winter a 3-ply exploration with a
bit of double and triple marl investigation
thrown in for good measure.
J
Started 15 years ago, took
a big hiatus (8 years?), obsessively spinning
for the past 7 years.
Schacht Matchless, Schacht
Sidekick, Majacraft Suzie Pro
Learn to core spin with
enough consistency to make a sweater
K
About 12 years.
Schacht Matchless that I
use to spin singles and my first wheel,
a Louet S51 DT, for all my plying needs.
I want to learn to make
mohair boucle this winter.
L
Not sure but I think at
least 6-7 years. I can't
believe I can't remember.
Schacht Cherry Matchless
I am going to work on spinning
more regularly this winter. Beth says I
need to spin every day. That will be hard
but I am going to try.
R
I've been spinning about
18 months but in the last 4 to
5 months mainly.
Schacht Matchless
I'd like to try to spin
raw wool fleece, washed and combed by me
Three
Waters Farm New colors from Three Waters
Farm. My approach to color is intuitive,
responsive, and relational. Often,
while working, I feel like I am at
the center of a vibrant, colorful conversation.
In those moments, I am dyeing of happiness!
Fiber
BFL
Color
Hurricane,
Safari and Morocco
Weight
4 oz
Put
up
top
Price
$17.95
#
of spinners
5
overall
impression
C:
I love Three Waters Farm! I would have
been happy if I had to choose blindfolded – all
the colors are gorgeous and they all
spin beautifully (plus I get to order
soap when I order fiber – how
can I lose?). J:
The new colorways are deep and wonderfully cozy. The reds especially
are entrancing. K : It’s BFL love
with beautiful color L: Lovely subtle colors
and excellent preparation. I want to
buy some now!
how does it
feel? 1: pot scrubber
5: baby’s bum
how
much predrafting needed?
1: a ton
5: none
how did it
spin? 1: fought me like Moby Dick
5: aaaaaah
dye leak? 1: lots
5: none
describe it
in a phrase
C: Tea and toast with
a very good friend J:
Storm skies K: Chocolate Easter Bunny L: Puffy clouds of autumn
leaves R: Gorgeous
how did you
spin it?
C: Split it in half in preparation
for a 2-ply yarn. Spinning was a breeze
and I was finished before I even knew
I had started.
J: Sliding long draw
then fulled
K: Divided in half
width-wise then stripped each half
into finger-width strips. Held 2 finger-width
strips together with the colors reversed
for a marled effect. Then plyed for
a double marl.
L: Split it down the
middle, broke off chunks & spun long-draw
from the fold
R: I spin in a worsted
style so far as I learned that method
from the woman who taught me and haven’t
spent the time to acquaint myself with
other methods. I look forward to doing
so.
how did you
ply it?
C:
2-ply
J: Single
K : 2 ply double marl
L: 2 ply with more
twist in the plying than in the singles
R: 2 ply —with
balanced tension in mind.
WPI
C: 10 J: 9 K: 10 L: 8 R: 10
how did you
finish it?
C:
Rinse and hang J: Alternate hot and
cold with brief agitation to full K: Hot soak and hang L: Quick dunk and a few whacks R: Soak in
very hot water
did
it do what you expected, or were you
surprised?
C:
I knew exactly what I was getting – love
her fiber prep – no surprises.
J: This batch of Three Waters Farm
BFL seemed extra silky to me the spinning
was a dream.
K: It looked like it would be lovely
and it was.
L: No surprises. It
was soft and lovely like I dream all
BFL should be.
R: I found the twist
ran into the fibers very fast so had
to spin with less tension and a bit more
on my toes. I was surprised by the color
of the finished yarn, the reds dominated
the field. I expected to see a
strongly variegated look and it was much
less so. The finished yarn color is very saturated and candy bright.
what
would you make with it?
C: This would make a really lovely, thick, warm shawl. The kind I want
when I’m reading in bed on a cold, winter weekend. J: Cozy, cozy mittens K: Anything that
you’d wear next
to the skin L: Baby sweaters, socks,
hats, mittens, scarves R: So many things -- bed
socks or a hat that’s got room for
big hair.
Ms
Gusset ms.gusset specialises in the
gussetslam™ method of small batch
dyeing, which gives kick-ass color. Optim
is one of our favourite fibres to dye,
due to its unusual uptake of colour, and
the amazing softness and sheen. Australian
colors inspire us, and we've been known
to get lost in the black hole of Rothko.
Fiber
optim
Color
yellow/orange,
purples, blues/greens
Weight
3.5 oz
Put
up
top
Price
$19.99
#
of spinners
4
overall
impression
A:
Great colors, yarn silky smooth E: Sticky wicket J : Super soft smooth
and fluffy K: It makes a smooth
yarn that feels like cotton to me
how does it
feel? 1: pot scrubber
5: baby’s bum
how
much predrafting needed?
1: a ton
5: none
how did it
spin? 1: fought me like Moby Dick
5: aaaaaah
dye leak? 1: lots
5: none
describe it
in a phrase
A:
Silk soft E : Butterfly
drying its wings.
J : Dandelion fluff K: Cottony
how did you
spin it?
A:
I spun for a double marl effect and
I really like how it turned out.
E: I spun this short
draw worsted
J: Long draw, slow treadle
K: I cabled this
yarn – spun
two 2-plys then plied together. I
wish I had reversed the two halves for
better color distribution. I think my
plies were too tight, since the yarn
doesn’t have a very soft
hand.
how did you
ply it?
A: 2-ply E : 2 ply with intermittent, squirrel plying. J : 2-ply barely K: cable
WPI
A:
10 E: 12
J: 6 K: 15
how did you
finish it?
A:
Rinse and hang E: Gentle wash J: Soak and hang K: Hot soak, whack
and hang
did
it do what you expected, or were you
surprised?
A:
The roving was soft and beautiful and
the knitted fabric ended up being more
smooth and beautiful than I expected.
E: I was happy with
the way that the fibers separated from
their sticky wicket pre-drafted presentation.
J: The fiber was
compacted, but it was worth the time
it took to fluff, because the final
yarn was very soft.
K: It’s pretty compacted and looks like it would be a difficult to
spin, but once I fluffed it , it was an easy spin
what
would you make with it?
A:
Silky smooth for cowl or a shawl E : It will knit up into a lovely baby sweater. The colors are gorgeous. J: Chunky cowl K: Anything that you’d
make with cotton yarn
Forbidden
Woolery Everything you see is inspired by
my favorite stories, fairy tales, legends,
natural wonders, and anything else that
tickles my fancy.
Fiber
Polwarth
Color
Sangria
Weight
4 oz
Put
up
top
Price
$16.00
#
of spinners
4
overall
impression
A:
Beautiful colorway C: It’s
my color – so I loved it before
I ever laid hands on it. CK: Subtle colors. Nicely
prepared fiber made for easy drafting
even for low twist singles. Squishy! E: Gracious Polworth goodness. Thick, puffy, nice colors soft colorway
how does it
feel? 1: pot scrubber
5: baby’s bum
how
much predrafting needed?
1: a ton
5: none
how did it spin? 1: fought me like Moby Dick
5: aaaaaah
dye leak? 1: lots
5: none
describe it
in a phrase
A:
Cozy and soft, beautiful colorway
C: Rolling
in a pile of fallen maple leaves
CK: Cushy and muted E: Fall oranges with a tinge of sun
rise. Sturdy puffy bouncy Polworth perfection
how did you
spin it?
A: Spun
end to end worsted
C: Stripped
the top into about 4 pieces and spun
it as it came CK: Low-twist single.
Slow whorl, fast short-forward draw, fairly
consistent thickness. E: Worsted, long supported
draw. It was a breeze to spin, the tinges
of sun rise purple made it a pleasure to
spin.
A:
Rinse and whack C: Rinse
and hang CK: Hot, cold, hot ,cold with
some plunging and a good whack to full
a bit. E: Finish hot cold wash
with a nice thwack to finish it off.
did
it do what you expected, or were you
surprised?
A: It
did what I expected – it was a
nice soft roving that created a nice
soft yarn. I really liked the subtle
color variation so I wanted to Navajo
ply to preserve this. C: It
was easier to spin than I expected and
I really like the resulting yarn. CK: I didn’t like how the colors played when plied so I decided
ot make singles, which kept the colors truer and less muddy. E: This fiber
spun up like a dream. Sturdy, fluffy, perfect.
what
would you make with it?
A:
Something cozy for winter – chunky
cowl, mitts, hat. It also would make
a nice sweater.
C: I
am a fan of the workhorse sweater. You
know the kind where when it’s a
little chilly and you have something
to do outside, that’s the sweater
you grab. This would be awesome! With
the subtle color variations I got, I
love just the idea of this sweater.
CK: Hat, scarf, shawl
anything yummy and warm
E: Mittens for certain
Briar
Rose Fibers I have some art training in
oil landscape painting and I love the
deep dark rich colors of fall. But
I am easily swayed by steely blue,
black and charcoal. I really
do hand paint my stock, and I don't
name my colors. When I first
began knitting some time ago, I
was not able to find a sweater's worth
of dark colors. So I began to
dye my own yarn.... and now look
what has happened!
Fiber
Silk
Color
Oranges,
Pink/blue/green
Weight
4 oz
Put
up
brick
Price
$45.00
#
of spinners
4
overall
impression
AS:
very magenta but very not, in a very good way C: I wanted to fill a bathtub with this
fiber and sink into it slowly. E: Copper dessert
goodness K: Absolutely love the color depth
how does it
feel? 1: pot scrubber
5: baby’s bum
how
much predrafting needed?
1: a ton
5: none
how did it spin? 1: fought me like Moby Dick
5: aaaaaah
dye leak? 1: lots
5: none
describe it
in a phrase
AS:
sheeeeeeeeeny C: A couple of ounces
of sex in a plastic bag. Absolute decadence. E: silk
K:
rose petals
how did you
spin it?
AS:
stripped it into thin strips, working
across the brick. As worsted as I could
get it. C: I wanted it really,
really thin in anticipation of a 3-ply
yarn. I tried to remove all clumps and
spun it worsted and as small as I could
get it. E: I spun this
fiber with the intent of getting some
fluffiness out of it. Worsted, but
long. K:
Divided in half lengthwise – one
half spun end to end and the other half
divided lengthwise into finger widths
and spun each end to end.
how did you
ply it?
AS: 2-ply C: 3-ply E: 2-ply K : 2 ply
WPI
AS: 13 C : 14 E: 8 K:19
how did you
finish it?
AS:
Hot soak in SOAK, much rinsing and then heavy-duty
thwacking; hang to dry C: Rinse and whack.
It was stiff when dry, so I whacked it
again to soften it up a bit. E: Gentle wash K:
Hot soak and hang
did
it do what you expected, or were you
surprised?
AS:
I expected it to need more drafting than
it did. Once split down into strips,
it behaved like roving and needed nearly
no predrafting whatsoever. Surprised
me. Wish the green hadn't disappeared
in the final yarn.
C: Sometimes
you have to fight with silk to get it
to do what you want. It’s the nature
of the beast, I expected it and was ready
for it. it’s silk.
You have to expect some clumping and
some “wow! That got really thin,
really quick."
K:
silk can sometimes be difficult, but
this spun like butter, very easy to get
a lace weight yarn
E: This silk fought me like silk likes
to fight me but I won in the end.
what
would you make with it?
AS:
Silk always means lace to me. So lace. C: Something
decadent – a tank top to wear under
a suit jacket, gloves that go all the
way up to my elbows, a thick, cushy neck
warmer
E: Bed jacket or vest K:
A lacey shawl
2
Sisters Stringworks Two Sisters Stringworks is about
making a place for handwork. I provide
beautiful, handmade supplies for knitting,
spinning, crochet, weaving, and felting.
Fiber
Gotland
Color
dark
orange
Weight
2 oz
Put
up
top
Price
$16.00
#
of spinners
3
overall
impression
A:
Great subtle variegation CK : Like a shorter long wool, it’s easier to draft because of the
short fiber, but the resulting yarn feels similar and makes a nice halo. L: Earthy, strong, too easy to spin
how does it
feel? 1: pot scrubber
5: baby’s bum
how
much predrafting needed?
1: a ton
5: none
how did it spin? 1: fought me like Moby Dick
5: aaaaaah
dye leak? 1: lots
5: none
describe it
in a phrase
A:
Nice and wooly, great red colors
CK: Crisp
L: Lace as strong as nails
how did you
spin it?
A:
Worsted, end to end CK: Stripped the top into the pencil sized strips. Not because the fiber
wasn’t well prepared, but it gave me more control in drafting. Short
forward draw with a fair amount of twist. L: Worsted, short forward draw
how did you
ply it?
A:
2-ply CK: 2-ply not too tightly L: 2-ply balanced
WPI
A:
9 CK: 20 L: 16
how did you
finish it?
A:
Rinse and whack CK: Bath and a whack L: Warm dunk and a few
whacks
did
it do what you expected, or were you
surprised?
A: I
was surprised that the yarn was softer
than I expected
CK: My first experience with Gotland
top. Seemed similar to Lincoln but without
the long fiber. It actually made it easier
to spin.
L: I enjoyed spinning it and knitting
it more than I expected. It was easy to
spin a fine, even yarn, and the finished
yarn has a nice drape.
what
would you make with it?
A:Outerwear – wooly
for winter, mitten, hat
CK: Lace for a shawl. I’d also
like to try making boucle with it.
L: A magic elfin cloak, or anything that
needs a strong fine yarn that would not
be worn next to the skin. Lace that would
last forever. It would also make an excellent
rug or tapestry
warp.