The Ploughshares Monitor
September 1998, volume 19, no. 3
Roundtables call for action
(Excerpt from Report of Discussions with Community Leaders
across Canada, September 1998)
For the second time, September 8-26, 1998, Project
Ploughshares conducted a series of Roundtables on the subject of
nuclear weapons for community leaders and interested citizens across
Canada. The first such exercise, in 1996, produced a national report
recommending that Canada formally review its policies on nuclear
weapons. This recommendation was accepted by the Government of Canada
and a review launched by Parliament's Standing Committee on Foreign
Affairs and International Trade.
On the eve of publication of the Parliamentary Committee's
report, Project Ploughshares carried out a second set of Roundtables
in 16 cities in all 10 provinces to discuss the current non-proliferation
crisis and to consider ways to encourage stronger Canadian Government
policies for nuclear weapons abolition and deeper public support
for such policies.
The Roundtables were attended by 384 persons representing
a wide range of Canadians: MPs, members of provincial legislature,
mayors, municipal counsellors, school board members, a former Lieutenant
Governor, a survivor of the Nagasaki bombing, business and religious
leaders, academics and educators at all levels, students, peace
group activists and military experts, health professionals, artists
and environmentalists.
The participants attended by invitation, and each
person received a 55-page Briefing Book: "Nuclear Weapons:
The Problem, The Solution, Canada's Role." Each Roundtable
lasted two-and-a-half hours. It began with a short video recalling
the scenes of the aftermath of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima and
Nagasaki, and then showing military and political leaders speaking
out against nuclear weapons.
A presentation at most of the Roundtables was made
by Douglas Roche, O. C., former Canadian Ambassador for Disarmament
and Chairperson of the Canadian Network to Abolish Nuclear Weapons.
At one point in the tour, Mr. Roche was appointed by the Prime Minister
as Senator from Alberta and absented himself for a few days. His
place was taken by Ernie Regehr and Bill Robinson of Project Ploughshares.
There was virtually a unanimous call at the Roundtables
for Canada to join the New Agenda Coalition (NAC), a new initiative
of eight middle-power States now pressing the Nuclear Weapons States
(NWS) to commit themselves unequivocally to the elimination of nuclear
weapons and to immediate practical steps and negotiations required
for elimination.
Since the core of NAC's program is contrary to NATO's
policy, which holds that nuclear weapons continue to be "essential,"
Canada has, so far, refused to join in with NAC. The Roundtable
participants specifically asked the Canadian Government to vote
for the NAC resolution at UNGA 53, and to work to get nuclear weapons
out of NATO.
While deploring the nuclear weapons testing by India
and Pakistan, participants pointed out that the real problem continues
to be the reluctance of the NWS to agree to commence negotiations
leading to the elimination of nuclear weapons. Special attention
was paid to the determination of the United States to retain the
strategy of nuclear deterrence as a cornerstone of its military
doctrine, and to ways to encourage the U.S. to accept its responsibilities
to uphold humanitarian law.
Congratulating the Canadian Government for its leadership
role in the development and now implementation of the Landmines
Treaty, participants urged Canada to play a similar leadership role
in the abolition of nuclear weapons. They noted this would be much
harder than the landmines issue, but that the new mechanism of NAC
buttressed by the Middle Powers Initiative, a network of prominent
international NGOs specializing in nuclear disarmament, provides
a way for Canada to work in the good company of like-minded States,
and with a supportive international NGO community.
Canadian public opinion, though strong in numbers
(92 percent of Canadians favour Canada playing a leading role in
international work for nuclear disarmament), is weak in expression.
The NGO community in Canada needs to re-mobilize, break the silence
and educate the public about the breakdown in the non-proliferation
regime.
More work needs to be done in exploring communications
innovations. The potential of the Internet was emphasized. Young
people are growing up oblivious to the continuing dangers of nuclear
weapons. Special efforts must be made to include nuclear weapons
issues in school curriculums.
While the issues of nuclear power and nuclear weapons
are inextricably linked, participants preferred to keep public and
government attention sharply focussed on the top priority: the elimination
of nuclear weapons. The $8 trillion so far spent on nuclear weapons
has deprived countless people of resources needed for economic and
social development, which are the key to attaining human security.
It was suggested that the "right to peace" be more fully
explored as a human rights issue.
The Roundtables gave their approval to this Program
of Action as suggested by Project Ploughshares:
a) Advocate immediate steps to reduce nuclear threat.
b) Support negotiation of a Nuclear Weapons Convention.
c) Renounce the "nuclear umbrella."
d) Provide leadership in co-operation with like-minded
states.
|