How Proust Can |
Marcel Proust's great multivolume novel
is entitled A la Recherche du Temps Perdu. The English translation is called
Remembrance of Things Past, but Alain de Botton refers to the novel by the
more accurate translation In Search of Lost Time, because, as he sees it,
the central theme of the novel is "a search for the causes behind the
dissipation and loss of time. Far from a memoir tracing the passage of a
more lyrical age, it [is] a practical, universally applicable story about
how to stop wasting time and start to appreciate life." Indeed, de
Botton feels it would not be an exaggeration to call Proust's novel a self-help
book. Proust was, after all, born into a family where the art of making
people feel better was taken very seriously. Both his father and his brother
were eminent physicians, and Proust senior was the author of no fewer than
thirty-four improving books, including one entitled Elements of Hygiene,
published in 1888, a book of aerobic exercises for girls. After the death
of both his parents, when Marcel Proust set out to write his novel, he confided
to his maid, "Ah, Celeste, if I could be sure of doing with my books
as much as my father did for the sick."
The nine improving lessons that de Botton draws from In Search of Lost Time
are the titles of his book's nine chapters:
1. How to Love Life Today
2. How to Read for Yourself
3. How to Take Your Time
4. How to Suffer Successfully
5. How to Express Your Emotions
6. How to Be a Good Friend
7. How to Open Your Eyes
8. How to Be Happy in Love
9. How to Put Books Down
Proust's brother Robert said, "The
sad thing is that people have to be very ill or have broken a leg in order
to have the opportunity to read In Search of Lost Time." The most evident
thing about the novel is its great length, and yet there have always been
those who, without a grave illness or a broken leg, will sit down with the
first volume, Swann's Way, not knowing where it will take them nor how long
the journey will be. I cannot imagine that any of those readers will deny
that one lesson they learned from Proust was How to Take Your Time. The
novel is not only long but immensely slow, and yet no one who has gotten
into it could ever want to hurry it. I know a man, in fact, who spent years
reading it and died without finishing it. He did skip to the last volume,
it is true, to find out how it ended, like a good reader of mystery novels,
but never got through the intervening volumes because instead of reading
forward he kept going back, savouring the first three volumes again and
again until he nearly knew them by heart, concentrating on Loving Life Today,
a good day with a good book, and Reading for Himself -- identifying the
people and places of his own life with those in the novel, and then seeing
reflections of Proust's scenes and characters in the world around him, until
eventually he came to feel at home everywhere, since he carried with him
Proust's familiar view of the world. While many of us feel the world moving
faster and faster, my friend came to see it moving more and more slowly
as he observed more and more detail, in the same way that he read the novel
more and more slowly until the idea of finishing it made no sense.
I see de Botton's book as a useful antidote to the two prevailing trends
in academic literary studies, politics-mongering and theory-grinding. De
Botton takes the old-fashioned humanist approach that art is neither remote
from life nor meant to relieve human misery, but has instead a special middle
place, a limited function, to make human misery more meaningful -- that
is, to teach us How to Suffer Successfully. He says,
Though philosophers have traditionally been concerned with the pursuit of happiness, far greater wisdom would seem to lie in pursuing ways to be properly and productively unhappy. The stubborn recurrence of misery means that the development of a workable approach to it must surely outstrip the value of any utopian quest for happiness. Proust, a veteran of grief, knew as much.
De Botton then gives us a series of characters
from Proust (patients, he calls them), analyses each one's problem and the
character's response to that problem, and gives us the better solution to
such a problem that is implied in the story. Madame Verdurin, for example,
allows herself to be convinced that anyone who refuses to invite her or
to come to her salon is merely a "bore". This is "the direct
opposite of what Madame Verdurin in fact judges any grand figures to be.
These figures excite her so much and yet are so inaccessible to her that
all she can do is camouflage her disappointment in an unconvincing display
of insouciance." How much more charming she would be and how much more
desirable an invitation to her salon would be if she made light of her frustration,
confessed to it directly, even joked about it. Instead she is suffering
unsuccessfully. But she is only a character in a novel, and is as such the
only one who cannot learn from her mistake and change.
The writer that changed Proust's life was John Ruskin. Ruskin opened Proust's
eyes through his writings on Venice, Turner, the Italian Renaissance, Gothic
architecture, and alpine landscapes. What Ruskin did for Proust, according
to de Botton, is "what all books might do for their readers -- namely,
bring back to life, from the deadness caused by habit and inattention, valuable
yet neglected aspects of experience". Proust discovered the great cathedrals
of northern France, Bourges, Chartres, Amiens, and Rouen, with Ruskin's
The Seven Lamps of Architecture as his guide. He then endeavoured to translate
Ruskin into French and add footnotes, but in time he gave up this scholarly
work and, in so doing, gave us an example of the lesson How to Put Books
Down.
Books, in Proust's view, even the greatest books, cannot in the end make
us aware of enough of the things we ourselves are capable of seeing and
feeling. There comes a moment with every great author when we must leave
our guide behind and continue our thoughts alone. We cannot allow reading
to constitute our entire spiritual life, or we become artistic idolaters
and forgo the directness of our own experience in favour of things perceived
indirectly through the sensibility of our author. I am certain that the
Proustophile of my acquaintance, had he lived, would eventually have thrown
In Search of Lost Time from the window of a fast-moving train, perhaps on
his way to Venice, as a final act of homage to its author's greatness.
Joseph Miller is a librarian and lives in New York
Copyright © 1997 Duthie Books Ltd.
All Rights Reserved. Literascape is a Trademark of Duthie Books Ltd.