"We are all in the gutter, but some of us..."
Taking Trash Seriously.
"...are looking at the stars."
—Oscar Wilde
February 23, 2006
Price: Your 2¢

This site is updated Thursday at noon with a new article about an artistic pursuit generally considered to be beneath consideration. James Schellenberg probes science-fiction, Carol Borden draws out the best in comics, Chris Szego dallies with romance, and each month we feature a Guest Star writer on a gutter subject on their choosing.

While the writers have considerable enthusiasm for their subjects, they don't let it numb their critical faculties. Tossing away the shield of journalistic objectivity and refusing the shovel of fannish boosterism, they write in the hopes of starting honest and intelligent discussions about these oft-enjoyed but rarely examined artforms. Click here for the writer's bios and their individual takes on the gutter.


Recent Features


Superheros on a Slant

"Justice pared down to punishment"

Evil Will Not Enter the World Through Me

"Fantasy novels can be like a violent club"

Love For Sale

"Untruths about Romance books."

Hopped Up on Speedrunning

"Keeping up with the Joneses in the fast lane"

Tired of Saving You

"Worn down and fighting the good fight"

The Well is Dry

"Tolkien was king, at least when I was young"

Forgetful?

Perhaps you'd like an e-mail notification of our weekly update.

Add Remove

Cheerfully Lecherous and Unabashedly Lazy

by James Schellenberg

She's the most powerful wizard in the world...If you had unlimited power - magical power as a wizard, or even unlimited built-in power like Superman - what would you do with it? Would you act responsibly and protect us regular folks? Or would you become greedy and try to take over the world, like a super-villain?

Pop culture takes those two extremes as the only options, and also dictates that anyone who is all-powerful has a flaw or limitation, again like Superman, with Kryptonite. It just doesn’t seem possible to tell a story any other way. What would the conflict be if there were no obstacles in the heroine’s way?

In Tanya Huff’s Stealing Magic, the all-powerful wizard Magdelene likes nothing better than to laze around in the sun and ogle hot young men. And more than ogle them, as we find out in each of the seven stories featuring her exploits. Magdelene is cheerfully lecherous and unabashedly lazy (as Huff puts it in the Afterword) which means that she’s not going to hustle around saving people like a superhero - especially when her demon housekeeper makes such good breakfasts - and that she definitely has more sex than typically happens in a fantasy narrative. The stereotype of the genre is that it’s from an adolescent’s point of view… that couldn’t be further from the truth here.

Fortunately there is a plot to each story; while the outcome is never in doubt because of the limitless magic at Magdelene’s disposal, it’s precisely Magdelene’s laziness that causes the conflict. She doesn’t feel much responsibility, so when people pester her for help, as they inevitably do, it’s an internal struggle. She really does just want to have a good time, as Huff shows in a scene where Magdelene’s magical arrival in a nearby town has been mistaken for the return of the goddess Hersota. Who is this goddess?

“According to her believers, she was a stern and unforgiving demiurge who preached that hard work and chastity were the only ways to enlightenment.”

Magdelene stared at him in astonishment. “And they want her to come back?” (47)

She's the most powerful wizard in the world...Like in many of her other books, Huff throws away the typical ways of constructing a story and does her own thing. And as she often does, this is with humour, like in her Keeper series (see my review of The Second Summoning for another example). However, it is true that not every book could replicate what Huff does here. Conventional storytelling structures are around for a reason, i.e. they are capable of supporting a larger scale narrative. There are only seven short stories here, and I would be hard pressed to see a complete novel (although some of Huff’s other books come close to anarchically laughing at everything).

I could much more easily see a full length story about Terazin. The book is called Stealing Magic - Magdelene represents the magic half of the equation; you’ll find the stealing part in the form of four stories about the smart, masterful thief Terazin. An enjoyable gloss on the standard fantasy thief, if not as iconoclastic as the other stories. I would read more adventures in the life of either character.

Stealing Magic was originally published by Tesseracts, and is now reprinted with one extra Magdelene story by Edge Books (which acquired Tesseracts recently). The two lines couldn’t be more different - Tesseracts always felt a bit stuffy, as if we should read the books because they were good for us (sometimes they were but not always). Edge has a notably more pulpy feel to their titles. They even go for the retro two-books-in-one thing. Magdelene is on one front cover and if you flip the book over, Terazin is on the other. Edge’s website has both covers here - it doesn’t quite convey the strange feeling of having no back cover.

Did I say pulpy? In fact, I would call the two Stealing Magic covers gloriously low-brow. It’s been a while since I’ve been embarassed to read a book on the bus, so kudos for that. I suppose the flip-book approach also lets the cover artist do a portrait of each character without trying to mash their storylines together somehow.

Stealing Magic includes Tanya Huff’s very first story, “Third Time Lucky,” which was published in 1986. Since then she has written over 20 novels, most fantasy, as well as the popular Blood series, which is set in a modern-day Toronto with vampires. She has continued writing her Keeper series and has written a few spin-offs to the Blood series that take place in Vancouver.

James--Oh man! What is it with SF book covers? They can be super bad. It's like everyone uses the same artist, and he REALLY spent too much time painting those little D&D figures as a kid.

Emily

Hey Emily, thanks for the comment! Yeah, mysterious, about those covers. On one hand, it's a happy lack of false advertising... you really know what you're getting. Unfortunately, I think that also means a lack of reaching out to new audiences. The Huff stories are quite funny, and they would probably appeal to many people outside the subset of epic fantasy readers who also don't mind being made fun of.

(Of course there's no formula for grabbing new readers, or else someone smart would be making a ton of money! So probably the D&D-figure art that you mention is a fallback.)

James Schellenberg

All SF cover artists were all brought up by elderly, fundamentalist grandmothers who drummed into them the notion that masturbation is wicked. As a displacement activity they fiddled with airbrushes while thinking about women. This cover is a fairly representative result.

Tim

I think the cover art for "Stealing Magic" is a lot of fun. While some people are calling it "low brow" and others are making elitest caustic comments, there are many others on the net that are calling the flipbook cover concept "brilliant" - so it is kind of interesting to see how doing something a little bit different can have such a significant effect on people and cause them to have such strong opinions. The book is definitely excellent, all Tanya Huff fans should have a copy of it in their collections - especially since it is an expanded collection since the original work. I am really glad it came out.

—Janessa

Hey Janessa,

I don't think I dissed the flipbook, but just to clarify, I did like the forward/backward thing a lot. It was a bit odd at first, since most publishers don't use that format anymore, but it definitely suited the material at hand. I also agree that Huff fans should have this collection, as it's one of her best. But what interests me about the cover art is the intersection between appealing to Huff fans and trying to create a wider appeal. I'm not sure if the covers will widen the audience for the book... I tend to take the so-called elitist comments as ammunition for my point, but I could be convinced otherwise.

James Schellenberg


Chuck your 2¢ into the Gutter


(Not made available on the site.)
Send e-mail notification of new comments

(If included it will be hyperlinked to your name.)
Remember info fields for next time?


You can use simple HTML for italics, bolding and links.

Get notified via email when new comments are made to this post.


Paw through our archives

Hey Janessa,

I don't think I dissed the flipbook, but just to clarify, I did like the forward/backward thing a lot. It was a bit odd at first, since most publishers don't use that format anymore, but it definitely suited the material at hand. I also agree that Huff fans should have this collection, as it's one of her best. But what interests me about the cover art is the intersection between appealing to Huff fans and trying to create a wider appeal. I'm not sure if the covers will widen the audience for the book... I tend to take the so-called elitist comments as ammunition for my point, but I could be convinced otherwise.

James Schellenberg

5 comments below.
Pitch in yours.


Of Note Elsewhere

Fascinated by the ocean's abyss? There's a gallery of mysterious wonder and beauty--and even more mysterious occasional cuteness--at the website for Claire Nouvian's new book about abyssal species.

~

Over at Salon.com, Douglas Wolk writes a dense article about comics culture, graphic novels, collecting and nostalgia and urges comics fans, whether art or pop, to grow up: "The medium's new enemies are internal: the much less casual snobbery of the commercial mainstream and the art-comics world toward each other, and cartoonists' nostalgic yearning for the badness of the bad old days."

~

Gamers With Jobs looks at the pendulum that's swinging from fantasy back to science fiction: "After ten years of elves and magic, I could use a bit of a change."

And The Escapist is the new home of Shoot Club! Awesomely nerdy dialogue reproduced faithfully, and some insights too: "There's nothing like bald math to undermine a game. The scales fall from my eyes and I cannot bear to earn another XP."

~

Steam Trek: The Moving Picture is a silent setting the starship Enterprise in the steam era. In space, no one can hear you--though the music cues are neat. Go here for a full version and here for more information. (Updated and thanks to Hellblazer.net).

~

Do you think someone can come up with 300 brand-new never-before-used gameplay ideas? In 300 days? Sean Howard is giving it a try!

~

View all Notes here.
Seen something shiny? Gutter-talk worth hearing? Let us know!

On a Quest?

Pete Fairhurst made us this Mozilla search plug-in. Neat huh?

Obsessive?

Then you might be interested in knowing you can get an RSS Feed here, and that the site is autoconstructed by v3.2 of Movable Type on the No Media Kings server.

Thanks To

Canada Council
We acknowledge the support of the Canada Council for the Arts which last year invested $20.3 million in writing and publishing throughout Canada.