"We are all in the gutter, but some of us..."
Taking Trash Seriously.
"...are looking at the stars."
-- Oscar Wilde
August 2, 2007
Price: Your 2¢

This site is updated Thursday at noon with a new article about an artistic pursuit generally considered to be beneath consideration. James Schellenberg probes science-fiction, Carol Borden draws out the best in comics, Chris Szego dallies with romance, and Ian Driscoll stares deeply into the screen.

While the writers have considerable enthusiasm for their subjects, they don't let it numb their critical faculties. Tossing away the shield of journalistic objectivity and refusing the shovel of fannish boosterism, they write in the hopes of starting honest and intelligent discussions about these oft-enjoyed but rarely examined artforms. Click here for the writer's bios and their individual takes on the gutter.


Recent Features


HOW WOULD LUBITSCH DO IT?

lubitsch_bild_80.jpg

INT. DRISCOLL’S OFFICE - EVENING

It's a big office, and dark, which makes it feel even larger, cavernous. The theme from Dr. Who (Delia Derbyshire’s 1963 version) reverberates in the space, buzzing up your spine like a telegraph signal.

Continue reading...


Detroit Metal City: No Music, No Dream

dmc krauser 80.jpg

We live in a time of film adaptations of comic books massive and tiny, from Iron Man and The Dark Knight to Wanted and the upcoming Surrogates. But I don't need to see any more. I have seen Detroit Metal City and it is a testament to awesomeness.

Continue reading...


Sequelitis

sequel-small.jpgYou'd think that writing a sequel would be down to a science, considering how many get cranked out every year. Three parts more-of-the-same to two parts brand-new-adventure or some such recipe. I recently read two sequels, one that was fantastic, the other not so much. The difference? As far as I could tell, it was because of the books that came before.

Continue reading...


Forgetful?

Perhaps you'd like an e-mail notification of our weekly update.

 
 

Mary, Queen Of Hearts

by Chris Szego

Mary StewartDespite being a rapacious reader of just about everything, during my formative years I managed to miss any number of writers who are the bedrock of their particular genres. For instance, I read Terry Brooks long before Tolkien (and yes, I'm aware of the gravity of that mistake). I didn't discover Diana Wynne Jones until my mid-twenties, around about the same time I found Georgette Heyer. Another standard bearer I missed during my younger years, one who had a huge impact on many Romance writers who followed her, is Mary Stewart.

Born in 1916, Mary Florence Elinor Rainbow was a trendsetter in many ways. In a time when higher education was possible, though not terribly popular, for women, she received her BA in 1938, and her MA in 1941. She was an Observer during WWII, and for many years taught at the high school and university level. She married Frederick Stewart in 1945, and shortly after that, began to pursue writing as a serious career.

She wrote more than twenty novels, more than two-thirds of which were huge international best-sellers. Not all were Romance -- or ‘Romantic Suspense', as they would be called today (ie: romances that are also mysteries). In fact, Stewart is almost more famous for her Arthurian saga, which consists of The Crystal Cave, The Hollow Hills, The Last Enchantment, and The Wicked Day. She followed those four up much later with The Prince And The Pilgrim. Oddly enough, though I love Stewart's work, I've never read any of these. It's not personal: I run an F & SF specialty bookstore, and had to bar all things Arthur for the sake of my sanity. But if I ever come out from behind that barricade, Stewart's take on the Matter of Britain will be what I turn to first.

Mmm, gothic goodnessThe books I love best are the ones Stewart wrote in the 50s and 60s. They tend to be about young(ish) educated women, who are out making their ways in the world. Her heroines all have real lives: they have bills to pay; they're interested in travel, education and opportunity. But one of the things Stewart's strongest skill is her ability to capture atmosphere. She was one of those women, and it's evident. A thorough understanding and acceptance of the daily privations of life in post-war England runs through her early works, and with it, that sense of gleeful joy when those privations are eased.

Several of Stewart's books are set in the UK, but others are set across the wider European stage. A few take place on the Greek islands, and though some of her ruminations on the nature of the immutable Greek ‘character' would cause fits in students of post-colonial post-modernism, she has a near-perfect touch with description. When I discovered Stewart, I was not long returned from an extended stay in the Greek Islands, and reading This Rough Magic, My Brother Michael, and Moonspinners instantly transported me back. Moonspinners, by the way, was made into a movie. Sadly, the studio was Disney, and the film stars Haley Mills, so I haven't quite worked up the nerve to watch it.

I find it very difficult to choose a favourite among Stewart's novels, but Airs Above The Ground is a perennial front-runner. Drugs, spies, a circus and the fabulous Lipizzan horses of the famed Spanish Riding School all come together in a delightful road-trip of a tale through rural Austria. It's also unusual in that the heroine has sex. Okay, yes, with her husband, and it happens off the page, but still! It marks a distinct departure from the strictures of the times. Stewart certainly wasn't the first person to put sex in her books, but she normalized it. Even more importantly, without graphic or explicit language, she made sex mutally enjoyable.

Mary Stewart epitomizes the voice of her generation: educated, thoughtful and forthright, with the sense of being both forward-looking and aware of the past that is particular to those who lived through WWII. The fantastically pulp nature of her cover art is a brilliant contrast to the deliciously crisp nature of her prose. For millions of readers, many of whom went on to become writers, she opened up the world.

~~~

Chris Szego's degree was more heavily flavoured with post-colonial post-modernism that she would have liked, which is why she now runs a bookstore.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Mary Stewart's Arthur books were the first Arthurian novels I ever read - I quickly came to realize the same thing as you, Chris, about the crazy stacks of Arthur-related stuff out there, so Stewart, plus T.H. White were probably my main Round Table encounters when I was a kid. A not bad representation I think.

Her other books sound fascinating - thanks for letting me know they existed!

—James Schellenberg

Sadly, because of my late acquaintance with Stewart, my Arthurian ban was firmly in place by the time I encountered Hollow Hills. Every once in a while, when I'm longing for something new from her, I think 'Maybe I should read these...', but I always back away.

Sad, really. And it's not because I hate Arthur. Quite the opposite, really.

—Chris Szego

It's interesting how iconic Stewart is--so many of us have had similar experiences with her.

I adore Stewart's intelligent young women traveling in interesting regions, e.g. The Gabriel Hounds and This Rough Magic.

When I first heard of Harry Potter I said, "It sounds just like The Little Broomstick."

Like you, I hit the wall with Arthurian books before I discovered Stewart. I doubt I'll ever read her Arthur trilogy.

RfP


Chuck your 2¢ into the Gutter
Mary, Queen Of Hearts - The Cultural Gutter
Lost your 2¢? Write us.

Paw through our archives

It's interesting how iconic Stewart is--so many of us have had similar experiences with her.

I adore Stewart's intelligent young women traveling in interesting regions, e.g. The Gabriel Hounds and This Rough Magic.

When I first heard of Harry Potter I said, "It sounds just like The Little Broomstick."

Like you, I hit the wall with Arthurian books before I discovered Stewart. I doubt I'll ever read her Arthur trilogy.

RfP

3 comments below.
Pitch in yours.


Of Note Elsewhere
A 1953 3-D comic online? My brain doesn't have the power to contain the glory of past, present and retro-future colliding in Brain Power!
~
Kyoto University of Art and Design's newest teacher is none other than JJ Sonny Chiba. Prof. Chiba will be teaching film acting and swordfighting. And I bet ninjutsu, but secretly. (via Kaiju Shakedown)
~
No more Plain Janes from DC. It's nixing Minx, it's line directed at girls. Shannon Smith breaks it down in bookstore terms.  When Fangirls Attack has more. 
~
Let your cursor drift to the right and all the way down for Ozploitation trailer goodness like a giant razorback, a postapocalyptic drive-in, erection jokes as well as Donald Pleasance, George Lazenby and Jimmy Wang Yu at Flyp magazine's look at Not Quite Hollywood.
~
Vampirella's been needing a make-over for a long time.  Project: Rooftop has original Vampirella costume designer and feminist historian Trina Robbins judge the results.
~

View all Notes here.
Seen something shiny? Gutter-talk worth hearing? Let us know!

On a Quest?

Pete Fairhurst made us this Mozilla search plug-in. Neat huh?

Obsessive?

Then you might be interested in knowing you can get an RSS Feed here, and that the site is autoconstructed by v4.01 of Movable Type and is hosted by No Media Kings.

Thanks To

Canada Council
We acknowledge the support of the Canada Council for the Arts which last year invested $20.3 million in writing and publishing throughout Canada.