Government of Canada, Privy Council Office
Francais Contact Us Help Search Canada Site
What's New Site Map Reference Works Other PCO Sites Home
Subscribe
Archives - Press Room

Archives - Press Room


MINISTER DION STATES THAT IT IS TIME
TO MOVE BEYOND THE "CONSTITUTIONAL OBSESSION"

 

TORONTO, ONTARIO, January 28, 1999 – The President of the Privy Council and Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, the Honourable Stéphane Dion, speaking today to students and faculty at the University of Toronto, emphasized the importance of respecting the Constitution. "It is essential to the proper functioning of our democracy and our whole political system," said Mr. Dion. "The Government of Canada scrupulously respects the Canadian Constitution and has every intention of continuing to do so."

Mr. Dion criticised the "constitutional obsession" which he believes has clouded past political discourse in Canada, though it has lost ground in recent years.

This obsession stems from a "false belief that the existence of a strong separatist movement in Canada is proof that the country’s Constitution does not work and that is must be completely overhauled if the country is to survive." The Minister added that "constitutional changes must not be bargaining chips. Every proposal must be considered on its own merits, according to how it would benefit Canadians."

The Minister noted that, as we move away from this constitutional obsession, we gain a greater understanding of the secessionist phenomenon, we are becoming more successful at distinguishing this phenomenon from other Canadian realities and we are looking at the respective powers and roles of governments in a more tangible and productive way.

Mr. Dion rejected suggestions that "sovereignty-partnership" is a moderate solution: "It’s simply not true that the concepts of renewed federalism and sovereignty-partnership belong side by side. They are separated by the chasm of secession." He went on to add, "You either secede or you don’t. You either stay in Canada or you leave Canada and make Quebec an independent country."

The Minister stated that "the best way to divide Quebecers is to plunge them into an attempted secession on the basis of an unclear question and an uncertain majority, without a legal framework."

One of the key problems of "constitutional obsession", added the Minister, was that it "leads people to include all sorts of considerations in the issue of secession that simply don’t belong there."

The Minister stated that reform to the division of powers must be based on a desire to better serve Canadians. "Transfers of power cannot allay separatism if they are made for that purpose alone," said Mr. Dion. He added one does not make a country stronger by relying on such a logic of internal separatism. "Every new transfer would lead Quebecers to withdraw even further into their territory, to define themselves by an exclusive ‘us’, to see other Canadians increasingly only from afar, and to reject the Canadian government and common Canadian institutions as a threat to their nation, a foreign body."

The Minister concluded that "there is increasing agreement that our Constitution does ‘work’, even though it could work better." He went on to remind the audience that, most of the time, issues can be more effectively resolved outside the rather inflexible constitutional reform process. "The solution to our political, economic and social problems and the promotion of the values we believe in does not require constitutional upheaval," stated Mr. Dion.

-30-

For information:
André Lamarre
Press Secretary
(613) 943-1838
 


  Printer-Friendly Version
Last Modified: 1999-01-28  Important Notices