The epidemiology of murder: UK physician responsible for 345 deaths?

CMAJ 2001;164(4):535

[PDF]

A year ago, the Leeds University graduate was convicted of murdering 15 patients. Now a 156-page audit assessing the medical certificates of cause of death (MCCD) during his 24-year career reveals an excessive death rate, particularly among older female patients. The suspicious deaths date to 1975. The audit [PDF format] was released Jan. 5 by the UK Department of Health. It compared the medical records, death certificates and cremation forms of Shipman's patients with those of comparable local GPs.

The percentages of cases certified as caused by old age by Shipman and by the physicians he was compared with, 1973–98 (UK Department of Health audit report)

Shipman started general practice at Todmorden, West Yorkshire, in 1974. A year later he was convicted of dishonestly obtaining drugs when his practice partners noticed he was signing prescriptions for meperidine that his patients weren't receiving. Shipman paid his fine and worked 2 years as a clinical medical officer before resuming general practice in 1977. He practised in a group setting in Hyde until 1992, when he entered solo practice.

Shipman's crimes first came to light in 1998 when a local GP contacted the coroner about what he saw as an unusual number of deaths. A local undertaker also voiced suspicions, but there was insufficient evidence for police to proceed. When the former mayor of Hyde, Kathleen Grundy, died suddenly on June 24, 1998, her daughter, a lawyer, contacted police. Grundy, 81, had bequeathed Shipman £350 000 in her will. Within 3 months, the GP was charged with murder and bodies of ex-patients were being exhumed. By February 1999 he had been charged with the murder of 15 former patients; within a year he was convicted and is now serving 15 life sentences.

But the audit means the case doesn't end there. Richard Baker, the Leicester University professor and quality-of-care expert who conducted the audit, concluded that more than half the patients who died under Shipman's care after 1985 were murdered.

During his career, Shipman issued a total of 521 MCCDs; over the same period the highest number issued by another Hyde doctor was 210. As well, Shipman was 25 times more likely than comparable GPs to be present at time of death — attending in 20% of cases compared with a norm of 0.8%. Relatives were present at 40% of his patients' deaths, compared with 80% for other doctors.

Baker made several recommendations, including monitoring death rates, but the UK's chief medical officer, Liam Donaldson responded: "Everything points to the fact that a doctor with the sinister and macabre motivations of Harold Shipman is a once-in-a-lifetime occurrence." — Barbara Sibbald, CMAJ

Copyright 2001 Canadian Medical Association or its licensors