The Cult of Quick
Repair
by Dede Crane
Coteau Books, 2008
Skin Room
by Sara Tilley
Pedlar Press, 2008
After the Fires
by Ursula Pflug
Tightrope Books, 2008
Reviewed by Katelynn Schoop
I typically don’t like narration by women, chick lit, or books
written by women, for that matter. This, of course, is an entirely
opinion-based generalization and nothing if not a debilitating bias when
it comes to the task of reviewing three books by female authors. Also, I
hate to be wrong (I may have been wrong). Crane, Tilley, and Pflug write
stories of love and hate that hardly deserve my dismissal – these are
not your mother’s romance novels and effeminate heroines.
Having said that, do not be fooled by the stilettos that grace the
cover of Dede Crane’s The Cult of Quick Repair, unless you read
the broken heel as emblematic of the kind of
heel-breaking-reversals-and-appropriation of female stereotypes the
stories present. But that may be a little too cultural studies of me.
Crane’s narration is surprisingly direct and unabashedly honest on the
difficult or transgressive subjects of abortion, phone sex, and the
female orgasm: "Seven? She wonders if Shannon is being facetious […]
How much better do they get? And why ice a cake seven times?"
Unabashed sexuality is tempered by poetic and cutting satires of the
cultural community, in particular the hierarchy and distribution of
authority implicit in a dance company’s development of new works,
articulating the supposed inverse relationship between art and
commercial gain. Crane’s writing is practiced and clear, effortlessly
transitioning from playful to critical.
In Skin Room, the debut novel from Sara Tilley, the narrator
Teresa’s voice is similarly sharp and unforgiving. The narrative moves
between Teresa’s youth and adulthood, juxtaposing Inuit elementary
school against the contemporary arts scene in downtown St. John’s. I’m
reluctant to call the book a coming-of-age story because that phrase
typifies a kind of self-discovery of sexuality thing for women, but this
story is the real coming of age story. It’s heartbreaking and
sometimes disturbing, but always presented with a deliberate sense of
honesty. Because of this, it is a difficult narrative to enter in to –
it isn’t as immediately accessible as Crane’s searing wit –
however, having read every last page, I can tell you it’s well worth
pressing on.
Entirely divergent from both Crane and Tilley is Ursula Pflug’s
collection of stories and (what could be called) prose poems, After
the Fires. Pflug’s impressive control of language creates a
manageable framework for the imaginative content of her stories in which
reality is shifted slightly, turned on its axis. Characters confront the
impossibility of true communication with another person as their various
relationships are mediated or perhaps enabled by letter-writing, drugs,
and parallel worlds. The highly visual and often abstract prose makes
for an uneasy reading experience in which the narrative begins to
interrogate the reader’s perception of reality. This is the kind of
reading that requires a little, god forbid, work – it forces thought
and reconsideration and discomfort in a great way. It’s often the case
that writing that seems difficult or challenging on a formal level
manages to best articulate the complexities of human life, and Pflug’s
collection is no exception.
As it turns out, these women write stories that I like. Their prose
all exhibits a degree of maturity and wisdom that tempers the narratives
of women’s perception of the world and the social relationships that
maintain it to create books that tread the boundary between heartfelt
and critical. Though the stories are all approached from different
phases of life – youth, twentysomethings, and parents alike – and
range from traditional short story form to that of prose poetry, themes
of alienation and self-discovery resonate in all.