|
 |
Alberta's Gambling Boom
Alberta
is Canada's gambling hotbed. Nine out of ten adult Albertans gamble on some form
of legally-sanctioned "game" and this province has the distinction of having
the widest array of gaming entertainment options available to its citizenry of any
jurisdiction in North America. Even the kids are getting into the act as seven out
of ten adolescents age 12 to 17 have gambled for money, either on a legal game or
informally with family or friends (Wynne, Smith, & Jacobs, 1996).
Further
evidence of Albertans' preoccupation with gambling is apparent when one examines
the staggering amount that is wagered in this province each year. In the research
report Gambling and the Public Interest (Smith & Azmier, 1997), the Canada
West Foundation reported that the gross amount wagered on all forms of gambling in
Alberta rose from $1.6 billion in 1993 to $2.7 billion in 1996-a shocking increase
of $1.1 billion, or 70%, in only three years! This translates into every Albertan
over 18 spending $1,344 each year on gambling in 1996. This was the highest per capita
wagering total in the country (Saskatchewan was second highest at $1,183 and British
Columbia was the lowest at $589). No other industry in Alberta or in the rest of
the country - not even the banking fraternity, long chided for its revenue generating
propensity - has experienced this phenomenal financial growth in the past few years.
This gambling
boom has translated into a windfall of revenue flowing to provincial government coffers.
In crafting the 1999-2000 budget, the Alberta government projects that lottery revenue
will total $770 million. This lottery revenue comes from video lottery terminals
(VLTs), slot machines, and ticket lotteries only and it does not include other gambling
revenues, such as licensing fees or income to non-profit organizations derived from
horse racing, bingos, raffles, or charitable casino gambling. To place this in perspective,
the estimated $770 million in lottery revenue compares with $1.1 billion collected
annually from school property taxes, $690 million from health care insurance premiums,
$570 million from fuel taxes, $452 million from liquor taxes, $350 million from tobacco
taxes, and $346 million from crude oil royalties. Fully 4.5% of Alberta's estimated
budget of $17 billion is expected to come from lottery revenues and this compares
with 37% from combined personal and corporate income taxes and 14% from all natural
resource revenues.
Clearly,
as well as providing entertainment for the citizenry, gambling has become a major
component in Alberta's fiscal policy. In fact in the 1999 spring cabinet shuffle,
the Alberta government created the new Ministry of Gaming (www.gaming.gov.ab.ca)
to oversee gambling operations throughout the province. "Gaming" now has
a permanent, high profile place at the cabinet table alongside Learning, Health and
Wellness, Environment, Community Development, Children's Services and other significant
portfolios.
Recent Gambling Happenings in Alberta
It is much
easier to describe what is happening on the Alberta gambling scene than why gambling
has been so enthusiastically embraced in this province. The latter necessitates an
examination of the settlement history, socio-political climate, and economic forces
at play in a diverse and bountiful environment - all considerations far beyond the
scope of this article. It is, however, instructive to track recent gambling happenings
in a province that is so preoccupied with this form of entertainment for two main
reasons: first, as a precursor to understanding why gambling is paramount in Alberta
and second, as a harbinger of gambling trends that may spread to other Canadian provinces.
The Great VLT War
There are
about 6,000 VLTs in over 1,200 sites across Alberta. On October 19, 1998, Albertans
in 36 communities voted on whether to keep VLTs in their villages, towns and cities
or to ask the province to remove these gambling machines from bars and lounges. In
the end, most communities, including the major cities of Edmonton and Calgary, voted
to retain VLTs, although in Edmonton the vote margin was very narrow.
This is
a watershed event in Alberta and Canada's gambling history as it represents the first
time the people have exercised a direct vote on any form of gambling expansion. The
proponents of the "yes" (VLT removal) side engaged in a media war with
the "no" (VLT retention) advocates and the rhetoric raged for months. Those
who are interested in the details of the Great VLT War can find details in the Canada
West Foundation (www.cwf.ca) report entitled Rolling the Dice: Alberta's Experience
With Direct Democracy and Video Lottery Terminals (Azmier, 1998).
In the final
analysis, the people of Alberta have spoken. Petitions signed in Edmonton and Calgary
that forced the VLT plebiscites garnered nearly a quarter of a million signatures,
which is an extremely strong indication that many Albertans insist on having a say
in gambling decisions that affect their communities. Based on this highly visible
and successful experience with direct democracy, it is very likely that the people
will continue to lobby the Alberta government to be more involved in the gambling
policy decision-making process.
Alberta Hotel Operators Lobby for More Gambling - Again
Several
weeks ago, the Alberta Hotel Association approached the Alberta government with an
idea for a "pilot study" that involves swapping VLTs for coin slot machines
in 40 bars and lounges. The hoteliers are proposing giving up the VLTs in 40 establishments
in return for 50 coin slots to be placed in new "gaming rooms" to be developed
in these selected hotels. Interestingly, although the government has capped VLTs
at 6,000 province-wide, there is no similar limit on the number of coin slots permitted
(these presently number about 3,000). The hotel association proposes creating a foundation
to funnel 15 per cent of the slot machine revenues into medical research with hotel
operators getting another 15 per cent and the province getting the final 70 percent.
The specter
of hotel operators lobbying government for more gambling business is nothing new
in Alberta. In the early 1990s, the hotel lobby was a major factor in the government's
decision to conduct the VLT "pilot projects" in Edmonton and Calgary that
ultimately resulted in the wide distribution of VLTs in bars and lounges throughout
the province.
Once again,
the hotel lobby is attempting to influence the Alberta government to expand gambling
to the industry's benefit. If approved, the coin slot "pilot project" suggested
by the hotel industry will see some 2,000 coin slots rolled out in 40 new gaming
rooms, replacing about 300 VLTs in the process. So far, government MLAs who have
been quoted in the media do not favour the hotel association proposal. Ironically,
both the pro- and anti-VLT spokesmen in Calgary are also quoted as being opposed.
Nevertheless, history shows that the hotel lobby in Alberta is powerful, so I wouldn't
bet the farm against lobbyists ultimately succeeding in getting their gaming rooms-
starting with coin slots at first and, perhaps, expanding to table games in the future.
Is Internet Gambling Coming to Alberta?
Internet
gambling is already available in Alberta, as it is in other provinces. On-line gambling
is presently illegal and is typically operated from offshore locations, such as the
Caribbean islands, which are outside the jurisdiction of Canadian governments. In
our recent study Gambling and Crime in Western Canada (Smith & Wynne 1999)
Garry Smith and I conclude that, because the present laws against Internet gambling
are inadequate and unenforceable, consumers are vulnerable to crimes such as fraud,
credit card theft, and cheating. Moreover, there is no way for provinces to stop
under-age gamblers from playing. Consequently, we speculate that legalization of
Internet gambling seems likely because prohibition is futile in the face of advanced
technology and there is tremendous potential for governments to raise large revenues.
Coincidentally,
the day after our study was released, provincial newspapers ran a story "Internet
Gambling Could Be in the Cards" referring to the Alberta government's plans.
In the Edmonton Sun, Gaming Minister Murray Smith was quoted as saying, "You
never rule anything out categorically. But we're not considering it at this point.
We don't see it as viable at this point" (Beazley, 1999). The story was sparked
when it was learned that the Alberta Gaming and Liquor Commission (AGLC) executive
was to get a briefing on Internet gambling operations in Canada and abroad. The purpose
of the briefing was ostensibly to bring AGLC up to speed on which Internet gambling
operators offer their product in Alberta.
This is
not the first time that the prospect of Internet gambling in Alberta has surfaced.
The Sun also reported that, in 1995, a Caribbean-based Internet gaming company, Internet
Casinos Inc., offered to make a personal pitch to Premier Ralph Klein to set up an
Internet gambling service in Alberta. The outcome of this overture was not reported.
The Liberal opposition has made a Freedom of Information request for any studies
and documents relating to Internet gambling and the government has promised these
will be delivered in early October.
Clearly,
The prospect of Internet gambling in Alberta promises to be a political hot potato
in the near future. The government is in the unenviable position of having to either
enforce and attempt to eradicate illegal Internet operations or sanction and regulate
this form of on-line gambling. Of course, doing nothing is also a government option
as is legalizing, promoting and regulating a made-in-Alberta Internet gambling operation.
It will be very interesting to watch how the Alberta government deals with this difficult
issue in the months ahead.
Charities Are Hooked on Gambling Revenues
A recent
Canada West Foundation study of 400 non-profit charities across Canada (Berdahl,
1999), concluded that "gambling revenues are an increasingly important source
of funding for the non-profit sector, despite the facts that such revenues are often
unstable and present ethical conflicts for a number of organizations." Of the
400 non-profits participating in the study, 28% rated gambling grants as their top
funding source and 50% said gaming grants were in the top three sources of their
funding. Furthermore, about 20% said they received over half of their annual revenues
from gaming grants.
Alberta
charitable organizations are especially dependent on gambling revenues. Twenty per
cent of Alberta non-profits receive more than half of their revenues from charitable
gambling as opposed to 10 per cent in Ontario and 5 per cent in Saskatchewan. More
than 8,000 charitable organizations in Alberta currently either have a gaming licence
or have conducted a gaming activity in the past two years. The list includes agricultural
societies, service clubs, community associations, community leagues, and various
types of groups (e.g., youth, music, multicultural, sports, religious, seniors, social
action). In the current fiscal year, it is estimated that these non-profit organizations
will share in $146 million in net revenue realized from four charitable gambling
sources - bingo, $58 million; casinos, $60 million; pull tickets, $9 million; and
raffles, $19 million (Berdahl, 1999).
Depending
on gambling revenues for charitable "good works" causes an ethical dilemma
for some board members and volunteers. The Canada West study found, however, that
the prevailing sentiment among non-profits was that the "commitment to their
cause overrides their ethical concerns about gambling" (Berdahl, 1999). In other
words, most take the money and hold their nose. The study concludes by offering 10
recommendations, with the main focus being on reducing charitable organizations'
reliance on gambling revenues by replacing these with government grants to organizations
to meet community needs.
Gambling Megatrends
In his pop-futurist
best seller Megatrends (1982), John Naisbitt identified "ten new directions
transforming our lives." Ironically, Naisbitt ignited a trend of his own as
his seminal work spawned a parade of similar futurist publications - Faith Popcorn's
The Popcorn Report (1992) and Clicking (1996), Naisbitt and Aburdene's
Megatrends 2000 (1990), David Foot's Boom, Bust and Echo (1996) and
Angus Reid's Shakedown (1996) to name a few. Each of these authors uses different
methods to read the tea leaves in an attempt to enlighten us as to where Western
society is heading. In the original Megatrends, Naisbitt describes "bellwether
states" as those wherein "social invention" in response to social
issues and local conditions, seems to occur time and time again. He identified five
bellwether states as the leaders and trendsetters in the United States - California,
Florida, Washington, Colorado and Connecticut - and through monitoring local media
accounts of social invention in these states, he extrapolated the first 10 "megatrends."
While other
futurists use different approaches - Foot examines demographic shifts, Popcorn depends
on interviews, and Reid relies on polling data and research - there is merit in Naisbitt's
observation that there are bellwether states wherein socioeconomic trends are most
likely to be conceived, incubated or, at least, quickly adopted.
I believe
that Alberta is such a bellwether state when it comes to gambling expansion, regulation
and experiencing the inevitable socioeconomic fallout. Therefore, I suggest that
it is instructive to monitor the gambling happenings in Alberta for clues about emerging
"gambling trends" that may ultimately be experienced in other provinces.
At the risk of being labeled a gambling futurist, I offer for consideration four
gambling trends inferred from these Alberta happenings:
- Gambling in Canada will continue to expand in the foreseeable future and machine-based
gambling - including VLTs, coin slots, electronic Keno and bingo, and video poker
- will grow significantly and become the most pervasive gaming format.
- This high-tech gambling future will include legalized Internet gambling where
citizens will wager on the outcome of table games, horse races, sporting events,
elections, and a myriad of yet-to-be determined gambling opportunities, all on their
personal computer and in the privacy of their home.
- The Canadian hospitality and tourism industry will be successful in lobbying
governments to allow special "gaming rooms" or "mini-casinos"
in larger hotels, convention centres, and tourist destination facilities as part
of providing a better entertainment package to attract guests.
- Canadian charitable organizations will rely heavily on gambling initiatives -
lotteries, raffles, casino nights, bingos, and grants from government-sponsored gambling
- to fund their programs and administration.
The Alberta
people have also clearly voiced that they want a say in the government's future gambling
expansion plans and other provincial governments would be prudent to involve the
public in gambling decision-making lest they, too, suffer the wrath of the citizenry.
In Alberta,
gambling is on the edge. But the edge of what? Proponents would argue that the province
is on the leading, trendsetting edge of crafting responsible gambling expansion plans
while mitigating the harmful effects of gambling - in other words, creating a healthy
balance. In contrast, detractors argue that Alberta is on the edge of a precipice.
They see unfettered gambling expansion as a black hole that impoverishes the vulnerable,
enriches governments and a few fat-cat operators, and generally seduces people into
valuing "luck" above sacrifice and hard work. Which is the true Alberta
gambling edge - precipice or trend-setting? It will be interesting to watch the gambling
happenings in this bellwether province as the answer to this question emerges.
References
Azmier, J.J. (1998). Rolling the Dice: Alberta's Experience With Direct Democracy
and Video Lottery Terminals. Calgary, AB: Canada West Foundation.
Beazley, D. (1999, September 15). Internet gambling could be in the cards. The
Edmonton Sun, p.16.
Berdahl, L.Y. (1999). The Impact of Gaming upon Canadian Non-Profits: A 1999
Survey of Gaming Grant Receipts. Calgary, AB: Canada West Foundation.
Foot, D.K. & Stoffman, D. (1996). Boom, Bust and Echo: How to Profit from
the Coming Demographic Shift. Toronto: Macfarlane Walter & Ross.
Naisbitt, J. (1982). Megatrends: Ten New Directions Transforming Our Lives.
New York: Warner Books.
Naisbitt, J. & Aburdene, P. (1990). Megatrends 2000: Ten New Directions
for the 1990s. New York: Morrow.
Popcorn, F. & Marigold, L. (1996). Clicking: Seventeen Trends That Drive
Your Business-and Your Life. New York: Harper Business.
Popcorn, F. (1991). The Popcorn Report: Faith Popcorn on the Future of Your
Company, Your World, Your Life. New York: Doubleday.
Reid, A. (1996). Shakedown: How the New Economy Is Changing Our Lives.
Toronto: Doubleday Canada.
Smith, G. & Wynne, H. (1999). Gambling and Crime in Western Canada: Exploring
Myth and Reality. Calgary, AB: Canada West Foundation.
Smith, G.J. & Azmier, J. (1997). Gambling and the Public Interest.
Calgary, AB: Canada West Foundation.
Wynne, H., Smith, G. & Jacobs, D. (1996). Adolescent Gambling and Problem
Gambling in Alberta. A report prepared for the Alberta Alcohol and Drug Abuse
Commission.
|
|
Go
to Current Issue