"Globalization
issues make Canada more
relevant
than ever"
Notes for
an address by the
President
of the Privy Council and
Minister
of Intergovernmental Affairs
the
Honourable Stéphane Dion
Canadian
Student Leadership Conference
Ottawa,
Ontario
January
25, 2001
Check
against delivery
You have invited me to tell you how I view Canada's future in this era of
globalization and interdependence. I appreciate the opportunity, for
this is an important subject from the standpoint of my own responsibilities
in government.
Three days ago, for example, Mr. Bernard Landry argued that the times we are
living in tend to favour the formation of new states and that, as a result,
Quebec's independence would be consistent with current trends.
[TRANSLATION:] "Sixty new countries have joined the United Nations
since the Parti Québécois was founded, including some 30 in the last
decade alone," he pointed out.
Quebec separatist leaders regularly point to the growing number of countries
in the world, linking the phenomenon to globalization. For example, Jacques
Parizeau stated on April 29, 1999: [TRANSLATION] "One must not be
surprised by the multiplication of countries, the number of nation-states.
(...) In that sense, the debate on globalization (...) touches directly on
the concept of sovereignty."
I believe, quite the contrary, that the recent appearance of numerous new
countries in no way bolsters the case for Quebec separating from Canada. In
fact, the issues surrounding globalization are an argument in favour of
Canadian unity.
1. The circumstances
surrounding these new countries differ from our own
The world comprised 69 nation-states in 1945. It now has 191, that is 122
more. No fewer than 93 of them are former colonies. Needless
to say, Quebec is not a colony. Consequently, these many cases cannot be
used as an argument to advocate the break-up of Canada.
Outside the decolonization process, only six nation-states were created
between 1945 and 1989: Israel, North and South Korea, Senegal (after the
disintegration of the Federation of Mali), Singapore (expelled from the
Federation of Malaysia), and Bangladesh (which seceded from Pakistan). You'd
be hard pressed to link any of those different cases to the Canadian
situation.
Since 1990, 23 new countries have appeared, all of them, without exception,
born out of the chain of events that accompanied and followed the
disintegration of the Communist empires: the three Baltic republics, Russia,
eleven other former Soviet republics, five nation-states born out of the
former Yugoslavia, the Czech Republic, Slovakia and Eritrea (which separated
from Ethiopia following a civil war). Communism has been described as a type
of historical deep-freeze, and in that
sense, these countries' accession to independence stems from the death of a
19th century ideology. Here again, their birth cannot be attributed to a
recent phenomenon of modernization to which Quebec would be a party.
The fall of colonial and totalitarian empires in no way threatens the unity
of countries which, like Canada, are already democratic and liberal. Thus,
there is no historical basis to the claim that the birth of numerous new
countries argues in favour of Quebec's separation from Canada.
It can be said, however, that the recent trends surrounding such realities
as market globalization make Canadian unity an even more valuable asset for
all the citizens of our country.
2. The advantages of
Canadian unity in the era of globalization
Globalization is a trend toward economic, social and political integration
among the different populations of the world. In economic terms, it
comprises all of the forces that tend to bring the world toward a single
market-space. It is characterized, among other things, by the increasing
proportion of external trade in countries' economies, by the enhanced role
of international organizations, and by the scope of international
agreements.
There are few countries better positioned than ours to succeed in this
global village. Canada is a country that is respected, that has an excellent
reputation, a country that has successfully combined cohesion as a whole
with great diversity: the strength of provinces and territories that
complement one another, two official languages that are international
languages and two legal systems, civil law and common law, which allow us to
speak the legal language of the vast majority of countries, a geographic
position that puts us at the gateway to the Americas, Europe and Asia, and a
multicultural population that gives us a foothold on every continent. There
is no doubt that we have made our diversity into a strength that we will
need more than ever before.
Canada is a decentralized federation which provides each of its provinces
with maximum flexibility to optimize its assets, but it provides us at the
same time with a cohesion, an exceptional capacity to pursue common
objectives, both at home and abroad, strengthened by the diversity of our
experiences.
Speaking of experience, Canada has it in spades, when it comes to
globalization. It did not wait for globalization to become fashionable
before it started taking an interest in it. Since the end of the Second
World War, it has played a key international role in the creation of
institutions that provide an effective framework for globalization. Such
examples include the International Monetary Fund and the GATT, which became
the World Trade Organization in 1995. One could also mention other examples
such as the World Health Organization, whose first director general was a
Canadian. When we speak of globalization, we, Canadians, are like fish in
water.
Actually, the most tangible expression of market globalization for us
involves a greater opening up to the American market. The United States is
increasingly our largest trading partner. In 1988, 74% of Canada's foreign
trade in goods was with our neighbour to the south. By 1999, the figure had
risen to 86%. In 1999, our exports of goods to the United States came in at
around $309 billion. You might say that, more and more, the U.S. is Canada's
best friend... whether we like it or not.
This intensified interdependence with the great giant to the south in the
context of globalization presents us with two challenges: challenges that
are not new, but that will be even more important for your generation. The
first is the challenge of maintaining our beneficial access to the large
U.S. market in the face of inevitable protectionist pressures. The second is
the challenge of remaining true to ourselves - our cultural expressions, our
"gentler" way of life, our more generous social policies - all the
threads of the pluralistic social fabric we have woven together.
Our Canadian unity is more essential than ever as we work to meet these two
objectives. Today like yesterday, and perhaps even more than yesterday, the
Canadian federation is a tremendous asset for further opening the American
market, for resisting US protectionism and for maintaining our sense of
Canadian identity.
Regarding the first challenge, access to the U.S. market, I could mention
the tremendous means Canada deploys to make its voice heard in the United
States: our embassy (which is the third largest in Washington) and our 14
consulates and trade offices. We really need the professionalism of these
diplomats, trade and investment officers, lawyers specialized in commercial
law and science and technology advisors, because they are the ones who in
large part advance our interests in the host of centres of influence in the
Unites States: civil society, the business community, the White House, the
House of Representatives and the Senate, not to mention the states.
But what is most important is that these impressive resources are being
deployed by a country that the United States knows and respects. While the
American market is vital to us, the Canadian market is also very important
to the US. Canada is its largest trading partner, far ahead of Japan and
almost equal with all the European Union countries combined. We may be only
slightly more than 30 million Canadians, but those 30 million traded around
$1.25 billion in goods and services with 272 million Americans every day in
1998. It is a trading relationship that is unique in the world, and that
allows us to exert a strong influence on our big southern neighbour when
necessary.
But there's more. Canada is an ally to be reckoned with in terms both of
trade policy and of foreign policy in general. The US authorities know full
well that few countries are as influential in so many international forums
as Canada.
We have, and will continue to have, our difficulties with certain forms of
US protectionism. But our main asset for breaking into the US market is our
unity. Trying to do so in disorder and division would weaken us dangerously.
Regarding the second objective, maintaining our own identity in the face of
the powerful U.S. influence, our sense of unity will also be of immense
help. In all our efforts to reduce trade barriers, whether with the U.S.,
Latin America or around the world, our objectives are always to maintain the
ability of all levels of Canadian government to take measures in key public
policy areas such as health, education, social services and culture.
In fact, Canada is a leader in pushing for what is called a "cultural
exemption" in trade negotiations, to ensure the maximum flexibility for
Canada to pursue its domestic cultural policy objectives. We are not alone
in this effort, but we are certainly a world leader and have been recognized
as such by other countries that have similar interests when faced with the
American behemoth.
Conclusion
I have placed special emphasis on the ties between Canada and the United
States in this era of globalization. But when I look beyond the United
States to our relations with other parts of the world, I am just as
optimistic about the future of our country.
In the face of our powerful neighbour to the south, which is increasingly
our largest trading partner, we need to rely on a united Canada. At a time
when international agreements are affecting our lives more and more, we need
to be able to count on our country's prestige and influence. To take on the
challenges of the new economy, solidarity among all Canadians is more
essential than ever.
This is what Canada is all about: a synergy of cultures which yields
excellent results. And that's why Canada works so well. And, I might add,
that is why Canada plays such a useful role in the world, both for
established countries and for those which have emerged more recently out of
circumstances that have nothing to do with our own. It is this optimism in
and enthusiasm for the future of our country that I wanted to convey to you
as you contemplate leadership in an interdependent world.
And I commend you for what you are all doing together here in Ottawa over
the next few days - young Canadians from across the country coming together
to learn, to share ideas and experiences and to prepare for the future. It
is a bright future, one that offers you great potential, and one that you
will continue to share with your fellow Canadians.
|