Guide to Making Federal Acts and Regulations
Bill Preparation Process in Detail
Who does what in the preparation of bills?
Departmental officials
Who are they?
A wide range of officials in the sponsoring department may be involved in the
preparation and enactment of a bill. They are responsible for developing the
policy that the bill expresses as law and are generally referred to as
"program officials."
Knowledgeability
Program officials should be knowledgeable about the various aspects of the
bill's subject matter, particularly in terms of the organization and operation
of the Government. Their knowledge permits them to guide the drafters and
channel difficult questions toward those who can answer them.
They should have ready access to senior officials in their department so that
they can get answers or decisions about priorities and policies. Many questions
necessarily arise during drafting, usually requiring a quick response.
Departmental legal advisers
Who are they?
Legal services to each department of the Government are provided by the
Department of Justice through its Legal Operations Sector. Each department has
a legal services unit staffed by legal advisers from this Sector.
What is their role?
Departmental legal advisers can explain how the legislative process works
and what it requires. They can also provide information about the time it
takes to draft a bill and ensure that the detailed drafting instructions are
carefully formulated.
They can also explain what effect particular provisions may have and can
help departmental officials correct provisions that are likely to present
legal problems, particularly as regards the Canadian Charter of Rights and
Freedoms.
Departmental legal advisers can also sensitize departmental officials to
the possibility that particular proposals may limit guaranteed rights and
freedoms and may have to be justified as reasonable limits under section 1 of
the Charter. They can provide information on the kinds of evidence that may be
needed to justify the resulting Act if it is ever challenged. They also help
provide advice on the constitutional implications of proposed bills through
the Cabinet support system. (See "Constitutional Issues and the Cabinet
Support System" in Chapter 2.2)
Finally, departmental legal advisers are in a good position to remind their
clients of the importance of putting together a team of instructing officers
who are familiar with the legislative process. They will also stress the
uniquely Canadian bilingual and bijural aspects that must be addressed to
produce quality legislation. (See "Co-drafting" in this chapter).
Instructing officers
Who are they?
Generally speaking, the instructing officers are departmental legal
advisers in the sponsoring department. Because a bill is a complex legal
document, the legal advisers are well-suited to the task of giving drafting
instructions and commenting on both language versions of the successive drafts
of the bill. Departmental legal advisers are familiar with the subject matter
of the bill as well as the legal difficulties that it may involve. They also
appreciate the care required in preparing drafting instructions and commenting
on both versions of each draft.
Alternatively, instructing officers may be program officials from the
sponsoring department. However, they should contact the director of their
legal services unit as early as possible to involve the director or, at the
very least, ensure the involvement of departmental legal advisers. The legal
advisers assigned to the bill should be experienced, have a sound
understanding of the subject matter and be capable of communicating
effectively in both official languages.
How many instructing officers should there be?
The number of officials giving instructions varies with the scope and
complexity of the bill. However, as a general rule, the group of instructing
officers should be small. The role of instructing officers is to distill
policy decisions made in the sponsoring department into drafting instructions.
If there is a large group of officials involved in a drafting meeting, much of
the time may be spent discussing policy issues, rather than providing drafting
instructions.
Occasionally, the subject matter of a bill involves more than one
department. In these cases, instructing officers may come from several
departments.
Why should instructing officers be bilingual?
Instructing officers must be capable of working in both official languages.
The Cabinet Directive on Law-making requires draft legislation to be
prepared in both official languages. It also requires sponsoring departments
to ensure that they have the capability to:
- instruct in both languages;
- respond to questions about the proposed legislation from drafting
officers in either language and relating to each legal system; and
- critically evaluate drafts in both languages.
Because bills are drafted in both official languages, drafting is much
easier when all the principal participants have a sound understanding of both
languages. The resulting bill will take less time to draft and its quality
will be better assured.
Drafters
Drafting involves transforming Government policy into legislative form and
style. Drafters in the Legislation Section of the Department of Justice are
active partners with the instructing officers and are equally responsible for
ensuring that the bill gives effect to the policy.
Drafters are also concerned with the coherence and consistency of federal
Acts, as well as their fairness and the integrity of the legal system. They
have an advisory role on many issues involving legal principles and policies
(See "Particular Legal and Policy Considerations" in Chapter 2.2).
In this way, and by keeping in mind the effectiveness and efficiency of the
entire legislative process, drafters provide valuable advice on a number of
matters, such as:
- the time required to draft and print the bill;
- whether the proposed provisions are appropriate to achieve their
objectives;
- whether there are gaps in the proposals that need to be filled with
additional details or whether it is better to leave matters to be dealt
with through general provisions;
- the appropriate form of the provisions;
- the inclusion of certain types of provisions in the bill.
Drafters also provide a sense of perspective. Because they are less
involved in developing the underlying policy, they are better able to draft
language that will be understood by members of Parliament, the public and the
courts. Drafters are attuned to the need for clarity and certainty in
legislation. This need is met by adhering to legislative drafting conventions
as well as keeping in mind the rules and principles applied by the courts when
they interpret legislation.
The legislative process sometimes demands quick responses to problems as
they arise. Given the importance of the drafters’ role in influencing
policy, it is essential that they be consulted as soon as possible in such
circumstances since it is more difficult to change the course of policy
downstream in the process than to do so further upstream.
Jurilinguists
Jurilinguists in the Legislative Services Branch of the Department of
Justice are specialists in legal language. Their primary role is to help
drafters achieve the highest possible quality of language when drafting
legislation. They keep a watchful eye on linguistic quality, focusing in
particular on style, terminology and phraseology, to make certain that the
linguistic quality is appropriate to legislative drafting and the subjects
dealt with. They also ensure that the two official-language versions of
legislation are parallel in meaning.
The first jurilinguists were employed in conjunction with the
implementation of co-drafting. Their services were essential because the
French version of federal Acts had been neglected for decades. Despite the
constitutional rule that the French and English versions are equally
authoritative, hasty translations from the English had peppered the French
versions of federal legislation with peculiar anglicisms and clumsy
constructions, which have been difficult to eradicate. The jurilinguists were
given the mandate of ensuring that in future the French version of legislation
would be true to that language and its idiom. More recently, with the growing
impetus toward plain language, a need has emerged for similar support for the
English version. In these circumstances the Jurilinguistic Services Unit was
established in 1998. It consists of jurilinguists who work under the
supervision of the Chief Jurilinguist and legislative counsel.
Jurilinguists keep abreast of the evolution of language in terms of both
the law and legislation and the subjects dealt with, and, by carrying out the
necessary research, they provide advice to drafters, either during the
systematic revision of bills or in response to specific questions. The
recommendations of jurilinguists are not binding on the drafters, who are
ultimately responsible for their own files. However, through the high calibre
of their skills and the soundness of their advice, jurilinguists have been
instrumental in bringing about a marked improvement in the quality of federal
legislation over the years.
Legislative revisors and paralegals
Legislative revisors of the Legislative Revising Office in the Legislative
Services Branch of the Department of Justice provide support to drafters by
revising and editing draft legislation. The Office also prepares Acts for
printing and maintains consolidated versions of all federal Acts and
regulations.
Revising relates to the substance, form and language of legislation. In
addition to checking for correct grammar and spelling, the legislative
revisors check for clarity, consistency of language and the logical expression
of ideas. They also verify the accuracy of cross-references, check historical
precedents and citations, and ensure conformity with the rules and conventions
governing the drafting and presentation of legislation. Revisors provide
advice on appropriate wording of amending clauses, the format of schedules,
the standard wording of particular expressions, the formulation of coming into
force provisions, and other matters of a technical nature. Finally, they edit
motions to amend bills and review reprints of bills amended by parliamentary
committees.
In addition to performing revising functions, legislative paralegals in the
Office also assist drafters by drafting consequential and related amendments
to lengthy bills.
Another function carried out by the Office is overseeing the printing of
government bills before they are introduced in Parliament and the printing of
Acts after Royal Assent. Acts are published in the "Assented to"
service, the Canada Gazette and in the Annual Statutes. The Office is
also responsible for publishing the consolidation of the Constitution Acts,
1967 to 1982 and the Table of Public Statutes and Responsible Ministers,
an indispensable reference tool.
Finally, the Office maintains master copies of all federal Acts and
regulations, including historical indexes of amendments. These master Acts and
regulations are for internal use and are essential tools in the drafting of
bills.
How are drafters assigned?
Once a legislative proposal has received Cabinet's approval, the Director of
the Legislation Section assigns responsibility for drafting.
Each proposal is assigned to a team of two drafters: one responsible for the
English version, the other for the French version. In exceptional cases, several
teams of drafters may be assigned to draft very lengthy bills.
The choice of drafters depends on:
- the workload and experience of the drafters; and
- the complexity, subject matter and urgency of the bill.
Although specialization in particular fields is not encouraged, drafters are
frequently assigned files on the basis of their experience in the same area or
in a related area.
How are drafting timetables established?
Time constraints are among the most important matters to be considered in
drafting a bill. Drafting timetables are based on the priorities established by
the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons and approved by Cabinet.
A bill is much like a book: once the outline is out of the way, it still has
to be written and published. The time required depends on its nature, the
complexity of its subject matter, the quality of drafting instructions and
comments from the instructing officers and the political requirements that the
bill is called upon to answer. But, in every case, enough time is needed for
drafting to produce an acceptable product. Without this time, the quality or
effectiveness of the bill may be compromised.
The drafting phase ends with printing a series of page proofs of the bill.
Printing is interspersed with revisions made by drafters, jurilinguists, editors
and instructing officials. The time needed for these aspects also has to be
taken into account. This is the quality control stage. It deals with not only
the wording, but also the substance that the wording conveys. It is often only
at this stage that central agencies (Privy Council Office, Treasury Board
Secretariat, Department of Finance) can fully appreciate the proposed
legislation.
It is no exaggeration to say that three weeks should be set aside for the
printing stage. Printing in bill format is an effective way to focus attention
on the details of the proposal.
Before promising the sponsoring minister to produce a bill within a
particular time frame, instructing officers should discuss with the drafters the
timetable for producing the bill. Once the instructing officers are attuned to
the drafting considerations, they will be able to advise their minister
realistically. It is crucial not to underestimate the time required to prepare a
bill that is well-drafted and effective.
The following are some of the things that should be taken into consideration:
- the legislative priorities of the Government;
- the parliamentary calendar http://www.parl.gc.ca/information/about/process/house/calendar/calpre-e.htm;
- the schedule of the sponsoring minister;
- the workload of the drafters;
- the amount of drafting to be done by the drafters and the amount of review
required by the sponsoring Department and central agencies;
- the amount of editing required and the comparison of the two versions;
- the time needed for printing the bill;
- the number of departments involved; and
- if Cabinet has agreed that the draft bill may be used for consultation,
the amount of time needed for that consultation.
Questions about drafting priorities are determined by the Director of the
Legislation Section and the Assistant Secretary to the Cabinet,
Legislation and House Planning/Counsel Secretariat, taking into account the
factors listed above. The approval of the Leader of the Government in the House
of Commons is sought when necessary.
When does the drafting begin?
Ordinarily, drafting begins once a legislative proposal has been authorized
by Cabinet through a Record of Decision. In exceptional circumstances, when it
is necessary to meet the priorities of the Government, the Leader of the
Government in the House of Commons may give approval for drafting to begin
before the Cabinet authorization has been formally obtained. The sponsoring
Department must contact the Assistant Secretary to the Cabinet, Legislation and
House Planning/Counsel, who consults with the Director of the Legislation
Section.
Co-drafting
What is co-drafting?
Co-drafting involves drafting the two versions of a bill together using a
team of two drafters. One is responsible for the English version, while the
other is responsible for the French. The Legislation Section uses the technique
of co-drafting to ensure that each language version is properly drafted and
reflects both the civil and common law systems.
History of co-drafting
Section 133 of the Constitution Act, 1867 requires Acts to be enacted,
printed and published in both official languages. The two versions must be
enacted at the same time and are equally authoritative. If these requirements
are not met, the Act is invalid.
It is also important to keep in mind that, when a federal Act is considered
in court, the court interprets and applies both versions. This underscores even
further the importance of ensuring that both versions reflect the intention of
the Government.
In 1976, in response to severe criticism from the Commissioner of Official
Languages, the Department established a committee to propose ways of ensuring
the equality of French and English versions throughout the legislation
preparation process and providing the Government with bills of the highest
possible quality. The committee concluded that there was no magic solution and
recommended co-drafting, an original drafting method that has since been adopted
by other countries.
Co-drafting is now a well-established practice that has proven to be
effective in drafting federal bills to reflect the equal status of both official
languages enshrined in the Official Languages Act and later in the Canadian
Charter of Rights and Freedoms. (See Chapter 1.2 "Legal
Considerations").
What is the object of co-drafting?
The object of co-drafting is to produce two original and authentic versions
through the close and constant cooperation of the two drafters. Each version
should fully reflect the departmental instructions while respecting the nature
of each language as well as Canada’s twin legal systems (common law and civil
law).
In co-drafting, neither version is a translation of the other. In contrast to
the traditional approach of translation, one version is not unchangeable. The
two drafters often prompt each other to change or improve their versions.
Both versions include the same headings, sections and subsections. Although
they need not be parallel at the level of paragraphs or subparagraphs, an effort
is made to arrive at a parallel structure in order to make it easier to read
both versions together.
How does co-drafting work?
The main feature of co-drafting is that each bill is carefully thought out
and drafted by two drafters, rather than just one. Both work together very
closely from beginning to end to produce a better bill. One of them co-ordinates
the various steps in drafting the bill, but this drafter does not assume sole
responsibility.
How does the Record of Decision affect the drafting?
The drafting instructions in a Cabinet Record of Decision form the basis on
which a Government bill is drafted. These instructions both determine and limit
what the draft bill contains. The instructions should be general enough and
flexible enough to permit the bill to be drafted to express the underlying
policy but to leave room for developing the details of the legislative scheme.
(See "Preparing Bill-drafting instructions for a Memorandum to
Cabinet" in Chapter 2.2)
In the course of drafting a bill, problems sometimes arise that were not
foreseen when Cabinet approved the drafting instructions. The relevant PCO
policy secretariat and the Legislation and House Planning/Counsel Secretariat
must be consulted to determine whether any changes require approval by Cabinet.
Approval is required if the changes have an impact on the policy approved by
Cabinet or raise policy considerations not previously considered by Cabinet. The
changes are subject to the same procedure as the initial proposal, namely, the
submission of a Memorandum to Cabinet for consideration by the original policy
committee of Cabinet and approval by the Cabinet.
Urgent major changes need not follow the full procedure, but may be approved
by the Prime Minister and the Chair of the relevant policy committee of Cabinet
together with other interested Ministers.
How are detailed drafting instructions given?
Who is responsible for giving detailed instructions to the drafters?
Instructing officers are responsible for providing drafters with the
instructions they need to prepare a bill that fits within the framework set out
in the Cabinet decision and that will be legally effective in implementing the
proposals of the sponsoring department.
These detailed instructions are especially
important because the drafting instructions in the Cabinet decision are usually
quite general, regardless of how carefully they have been formulated. (See
"Preparing Bill-drafting Instructions for a Memorandum to Cabinet" in
Chapter 2.2)
What is their purpose?
In addition to being a necessary tool for drafters, the detailed
instructions provide an opportunity for the sponsoring department to
think through its proposals in order to produce a coherent set of provisions to
implement the proposals.
What should they contain?
The instructions should contain complete and detailed information, as well as
supporting documentation, about the following:
- the context of the desired provisions;
- the problems to be resolved and the solutions proposed;
- the particular objectives of the sponsoring department and the means by
which they may be implemented;
- any regulations that may be needed;
- any amendments required to other Acts;
- any relevant legislative precedents;
- any legal difficulties;
- how contraventions of the Act will be dealt with; and
- any transitional provisions necessary to implement changes to an existing
legislative scheme.
The quality of drafting instructions largely determines whether the drafting
deadlines will be easily met, and whether the general quality of the resulting
bill will be high. This is why it is important that instructions conform to a
number of rules.
The instructions must be as complete as possible. They should reflect
definite policies and decisions of the sponsoring department, rather than a
range of options. They need not contain every detail involved in drafting the
bill: details of lesser importance can be dealt with later in the course of
examining, discussing and revising the drafts.
What form should they be in?
The instructions need not be in any particular form, as long as they are
clear and concise.
When the bill is long and complex, the initial instructions should be in
writing. However, instructions can also be orally transmitted at drafting
meetings dealing with the intended meaning of particular provisions.
Should they be in the form of a bill?
In general, drafting instructions should not be in the form of a bill. Rather
than making it easier to draft, this usually slows things down because the
drafters have to interpret the text of the instructions to extract the policy
objectives before they can begin to formulate their own drafts. The role of the
instructing officials is to communicate these policy objectives to drafters
clearly and precisely. The best way to accomplish this is through instructions
expressed as simply as possible.
Occasionally, at the request of the drafters, it may be helpful to point to
precedents in existing legislation to help them achieve a similar legislative
effect. If the drafters clearly understand the policy objectives, reference to
precedents can help them prepare a bill that fits into the body of federal
legislation. However, precedents must be used with caution and can seldom be
adopted without making adjustments so that they work effectively in the new
legislative scheme.
How are drafts prepared, discussed and revised?
When are meetings held to discuss drafts?
Meetings are scheduled by the lead drafter after consultation with the second
drafter to ensure her or his availability.
Who attends the meetings?
The meetings are attended by the drafters, the instructing officers and other
officials from the sponsoring department as
required.
It is of the utmost importance that both drafters actively participate at the
meetings. The positions and points of view of the sponsoring department should
be expressed and explained in as much detail as is required, as should the
problems and situations that the bill is intended to deal with.
How to prepare for meetings
Before the first drafting meeting, the departmental officials and their legal
advisers should prepare to brief the drafters on the background of the proposals
and the Cabinet decision. Before meetings to discuss drafts, they should study
both versions of the drafts to verify that each version reflects the policy
developed by their department and approved by the Cabinet. They should also
determine whether any legal or other problems are raised by either version.
The departmental review of the drafts must not be confined to one version on
the assumption that the other will necessarily say the same thing. (See
"Co-drafting" in this chapter). Both versions must be carefully
examined by the sponsoring department to ensure that they accurately express the
policy in each language.
As noted above, it is important to keep in mind that the courts interpret and
apply both versions of federal legislation, and so it is crucial to ensure that
both reflect the government’s intentions.
Drafters encourage instructing officers to be critical when they review a
draft of the bill. The goal is to put together, with the support of each
participant, a bill that meets the Government’s needs and is consistent with
the policy and direction approved by Cabinet.
How are the meetings conducted?
Drafters pose any questions that they think will help them to understand the
principles and objectives of the bill. The instructing officers explain the
intention of the sponsoring department and allow the drafters to propose
alternative solutions or solutions that are simpler or more compatible with
existing federal Acts.
The meetings proceed in both official languages. The instructing officers
provide their instructions and comments, as well as any supporting
documentation, in both English and French. By the same token, the drafters
usually ask questions and make comments in the language of their choice. The
bilingual character of the meetings poses few problems when the instructing
officers have been carefully chosen.
How are drafts prepared?
After each meeting, the drafters consult together on the best way to reflect
the results of the meeting in their drafts. They also regularly consult the
jurilinguists on terminology, syntax and other linguistic questions. Toward the
end of the process, the drafters send their drafts to the jurilinguists as well
as to the legislative revisors, who make suggestions for improving grammar,
syntax, style, arrangement and coherence.
The drafters may also consult other sections or units of the Department of
Justice in order to check particular points of law that arise when drafting.
The drafting shuttle
Depending on the urgency of the bill and the drafters' other priorities, they
prepare a draft reflecting the consensus reached at the meeting.
Drafts are sent out in both languages at the same time for review by the
instructing officers.
Other drafting meetings and drafts follow until those involved in the
drafting process, and particularly the sponsoring Minister, are satisfied with
the ultimate draft.
What security measures must be taken with draft bills?
A draft bill is a confidence of the Queen’s Privy Council for Canada and is
protected by section 69 of the Access to Information Act and section 39
of the Canada Evidence Act. As a general rule, draft bills are classified
as secret and should be handled accordingly. They should not be shown to persons
outside the public service without prior Cabinet authority, which may be sought
in the Memorandum to Cabinet.
Bill summary
The sponsoring department must prepare for each bill (with minor exceptions
such as Appropriation bills) a summary of its contents. The purpose of
the summary is to help parliamentarians and members of the public understand the
bill. The summary is printed on page 1a of the bill. If the bill is enacted, the
summary is to be printed with the resulting Act.
The summary should be a clear, factual, non-partisan overview of the bill and
its main purposes and provisions. It should not contain any reference to Cabinet
decisions, Records of Decision or other Cabinet confidences.
The summary must be prepared in both English and French. Its length should be
proportionate to the length of the bill and should not as a rule exceed two
pages of single-spaced type in each language.
The sponsoring department should provide the summary (in electronic format,
if possible) to the drafters at least one week before the bill is to be printed
as a page proof.
Finally, the summary should be drafted so that no changes are needed when the
note is published with the resulting Act. For example, verbs should be in the
present indicative and the words "enactment" or "amendments"
should be used, rather than "bill".
Explanatory notes
Explanatory notes provide details about particular provisions that are being
amended by a bill. The Legislation Section of the Department of Justice is
responsible for the preparation of these notes, which are published in bills at
first reading to explain changes being made to existing Acts. These notes
describe only the changes being made or quote the existing provisions of the
Acts being amended.
Printing and Distribution of draft bills
Introduction
This section deals with the printing of draft bills in final form for
introduction in Parliament. It also discusses how and to whom the copies are
distributed. This process is distinct from the production and distribution of
computer printouts of earlier drafts by the drafters themselves. Printing occurs
once the drafters and the instructing officers are satisfied that the text of a
draft bill will not require major changes. The drafters arrange for printing
instructions to be given to St-Joseph Ottawa-Hull.
Requests for release of government bills
Draft government bills are classified "Secret". Consequently, the
text or partial text of draft bills may be released only to members of the
Legislation Section or the Legislation and House Planning/Counsel Secretariat
(L&HP/C) (Privy Council Office) or to the instructing officer of the
sponsoring department or a person designated by that officer. Requests from
other persons for information about a Government draft bill not yet introduced
in Parliament should be referred to the instructing officer.
Printing
Normally, a bill is printed and revised three times before it is scheduled
for review by the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons to determine
whether it should be approved for introduction. The first version is called the
page proof. (If there is another version before the examination page proof, it
is called the revised page proof.) The examination page proof is the version
that goes to the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons for review.
The next version is called the final page proof. (If the bill is printed again
before introduction, it is called a revised final page proof.)
The examination page proof must be sent to L&HP/C no later than 10 days
before the day on which the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons
will be conducting the bill review. This rule may be varied only in exceptional
circumstances. Once the Government House Leader has reviewed the bill, it may be
printed in final page proof. No further changes may be made, except those
requested by the Government House Leader.
Draft bills are printed by St-Joseph Ottawa-Hull. Printing is requested by
the Director of the Legislation Section by letter when the drafters
of the bill, in consultation with the instructing officers, consider that it is
ready for printing. The bill is printed from electronic data provided by the
drafters to Informatics Services in the Legislative Services Branch of the
Department of Justice. The data is coded and verified by Informatics Services
before being transmitted to St-Joseph Ottawa-Hull for photo-composition (the
production of a camera-ready page) and the printing of proofs. For subsequent
"press runs", changes to the data are input by Informatics Services on
the basis of a manuscript prepared by the legislative revisors responsible for
the bill on the instructions of the drafters. The data is then transmitted to
St-Joseph Ottawa-Hull for printing.
Special printing arrangements
If the sponsoring department requires extra copies, the instructing officers
should indicate this to the drafters who will make sure the extra copies are
ordered. The instructing officers should also advise the drafters if they wish
to pick up their copies from the printer, for example when a bill is printed on
Friday evening and they want to have copies Saturday morning.
Changes to printer’s copy
A printer's copy is controlled by the Legislative Revising Office to ensure
that all changes have been properly proofread and to provide an authoritative
record of the changes so that there is no confusion about what the changes are.
After a draft bill has been printed, drafters make changes by writing them in
hand on a copy of the bill or by preparing "strips". A strip is typed
text that is inserted where the change is made and should be used whenever the
changes are lengthy.
Successive printer’s copies are kept on file in the Legislative Revising
and Publishing Office and are not to be taken from that office without the
knowledge of its members.
Minor, necessary technical changes to draft
bills that are in final or revised final page proof form may be made if the
signature copy (the copy that is to be tabled for introduction) has not been
signed by the Government House Leader. The legislative revisors responsible for
the bill communicate the changes to L&HP/C and to the House of Commons
Legislative Services. This ensures that changes made on the signature copy are
included in the printed copies for first reading.
Steps involved in each printing
The following describes in detail the steps usually involved in each printing
and the time they may take. The times are given as a general model and may be
shortened or lengthened in particular cases.
Page proof and revised page proof
Instructions for the printing request letter should be given before noon
and all English and French WordPerfect documents of the draft bill and any
table of contents and explanatory notes should be available to Informatics
Services by noon. Draft bills are printed overnight and copies are available
in the morning on the next working day.
Examination page proof
This printing should be regarded as the last chance for changes before
introduction, other than those required as a result of the examination by the
Leader of the Government in the House of Commons.
Instructions for the printing request letter should be given before noon.
All corrections and changes, in English and French, should be given to the
legislative revisors before 1 p.m. The legislative revisors process the
corrections and changes and provide a printer’s manuscript to Informatics
Services. Copies will be available on the next working day after processing by
Informatics Services. This print should be available no later than the Friday
that is 11 days before the scheduled meeting of Cabinet at which the bill is
to be considered. L&HP/C may waive this requirement in exceptional
circumstances.
Final Page proof and revised final page proof(s)
This is the print of the bill that will be introduced in Parliament.
Instructions for the print request letter should be given before noon
and all corrections and changes, both English and French, should be given to
the legislative revisors before 1:00 p.m. The legislative revisors process the
corrections and changes and provide a printer's manuscript to Informatics
Services. Copies will be available on the next working day after processing by
Informatics Services.
Time required for printing
The time required to print a bill must be taken into consideration in
determining when the bill will be ready for examination by the Leader of the
Government in the House of Commons and delegation of authority for introduction.
The time required may vary depending on a number of factors:
- The timetable is based on average-length bills (50 pages or less); larger
bills will likely require more time.
- Bills that have been significantly changed since the last print will
require more time.
- Priorities will be set by the Director of the Legislation Section in consultation with L&HP/C if many bills are being
processed and printed on the same day. This will likely delay the printing
of some lower-priority bills.
- Bills that contain non-standard text (for example, schedules with tables,
equations) usually require more time.
Sample calendar
The following sample calendar illustrates the time requirements. Each step in
the printing process is represented by a letter. The meaning of each letter is
explained after the calendar.
SUN |
MON |
TUE |
WED |
THU |
FRI |
SAT |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5
A |
6
B |
7 |
8 |
9 |
10 |
11 |
12
C |
13
D |
14 |
15 |
16 |
17 |
18 |
19 |
20
E |
21 |
22 |
23
F |
24
G/H |
25 |
26
I |
27 |
28 |
- Page proof printing: The drafters notify the Director of the Legislation
Section before noon of page proof printing and send all
documents in French and English to Informatics Services by noon.
- The page proofs are delivered in the early morning to the Legislative
Revising Office and distributed in the Legislation Section. The drafters,
jurilinguists, legislative revisors and sponsoring department have five
working days to review the page proofs.
- Examination page proof printing: The drafters notify the Director of the
Legislation Section before noon of examination page proof
printing, and all changes in French and English are given to the legislative
revisors by 1 p.m. The legislative revisors prepare the printer’s copy in
the afternoon and Informatics Services processes the changes in the evening
and sends the document to the printer.
- The examination page proofs are delivered in the early morning to PCO and
to the Legislative Revising and Publishing Office for distribution in the
Legislation Section.
- Final page proof printing: The drafters notify the Director of the
Legislation Section before noon of final page proof printing,
and all changes in French and English are given to the legislative revisors
by 1 p.m. The legislative revisors prepare the printer's copy in the
afternoon. Informatics Services process the changes in the evening and send
the document to the printer. This print may be as late as the Monday before
the Cabinet meeting, depending on when the Leader of the Government in the
House of Commons examines the bill.
- The final page proofs are delivered in the early morning to PCO and to the
Legislative Revising Office for distribution in the Legislation Section.
- Cabinet meeting.
- Notice of introduction must be published in the House of Commons Notice
Paper 48 hours in advance(no notice is required for introduction in the
Senate).
- Introduction in Parliament.
Printing alternative copies
Unless a bill is of extreme urgency or importance (such as strike
legislation), only one version, drafted in accordance with the record of
decision of Cabinet (the RD) should be printed in page proofs.
If additional alternative versions of the bill are desired, they should be in
computer printout form only. This practice will prevent the possibility of the wrong draft being
introduced.
Distribution and number of copies of bills
The Privy Council Office and the Department of Justice each require a fixed
number of copies of each print page. The sponsoring department receives 10
copies, unless it requests additional copies. Usual distribution:
- page proof and revised page proof (39 copies)
- 20 for Justice
- 9 for PCO
- 10 for the sponsoring department
- examination page proof (48 copies)
- 20 for Justice
- 18 for PCO
- 10 for the sponsoring department
- final page proof and revised final page proof (98 copies)
- 20 for Justice
- 66 for PCO
- 10 for the sponsoring department
- Two for the House of Commons Legislative Counsel (including bills that
are introduced first in the Senate).
Bills are printed and distributed in accordance with the instructions in the
print-request letter for each printing.
All copies for the sponsoring department and the Department of Justice
(unless the print-request letter indicated that the sponsoring department will
pick up its copies) are received in the Legislative Revising and Publishing
Office, which is responsible for internal distribution. The first drafter
provides the sponsoring department with its copies.
Printing costs
The department sponsoring the bill is responsible for all printing costs of a
draft bill before its introduction in Parliament and for the cost of copies of
the bill that it requires after it is introduced.
St-Joseph Ottawa-Hull currently charges $8.50 for each camera-ready page it
produces for a page proof, revised page proof or examination page proof and
$10.50 per page for final page proofs. It then charges six cents for each page
printed from the camera-ready copy. To estimate the cost of printing, use the
following formula:
Cost of camera-ready pages: $8.50* X no. of printed pages
*$10.50 for final or revised final page proof
Cost of copies: six cents X no. of copies X no. of printed pages
= cost of camera-ready pages plus cost of copies
Thus, if a bill is 20 pages long and 32 copies are printed, St-Joseph
Ottawa-Hull will charge
(8.50 X 20) + (20 X .06 X 32) = $208.40 (for page proof, revised page proof
or examination page proof)
(10.50 X 20) + (20 X .06 X 32) = $248.40 (for final page proof or revised
final page proof).
Printing and reprinting of bills in Parliament
Once a bill is introduced, subsequent printings are arranged by the Office of
the Legislative Counsel of the House of Commons or the Senate.
Obtaining copies after introduction
A limited number of copies are provided to Ministers and other Members of the
House of Commons and Senators.
Bills are available on the Internet at http://www.parl.gc.ca/common/bills.asp?Language=E&Parl=37&Ses=1.
Paper copies can be obtained through Canadian Government Publishing (45
Sacré-Coeur Blvd., Hull, Québec K1A 0S9, (613) 956-4800) if they are ordered
in advance. Copies may also be obtained from the Lowe-Martin Group (363 Coventry
Road, Ottawa, Ontario K1K 2C5, (613) 741-0962). However, they must be ordered
from Lowe-Martin before the bill is printed.
Copies are also available through stores that sell government publications.
Activities and Products
for Bill Preparation and Approval
This table sets out the steps that a legislative project team must
follow to prepare a bill and have it submitted for Cabinet approval.
Key activities and products are indicated for each step.
Throughout this stage it is essential for instructing officers to keep in
touch with the Legislation and House Planning/Counsel Secretariat (L&HP/C)
of the Privy Council Office about their progress in preparing the bill and when
it will be ready for review by the Leader of the Government in the House of
Commons.
Step |
Activities and Products |
Assignment of drafters to draft the bill |
The Director of the Legislation Section assigns drafters in the Legislation Section of the Department of Justice to draft each language version of the bill once Cabinet approves the Memorandum to Cabinet. Drafters may be assigned before MC approval if the Leader of the Government in the House of Commons so authorizes. This authorization is granted on the advice of the Assistant Secretary to the Cabinet (Legislation and House Planning/Counsel), who should be contacted first about this authorization and who will in turn consult the
Director of the Legislation Section. |
Establish a critical path for drafting and introduction in Parliament |
Within the framework of the Government’s legislative agenda, the instructing officers and the drafters, in consultation with the L&HP/C, agree on a timetable for drafting and a target date for having the draft bill ready for Cabinet consideration. The timetable may be revised from time to time. |
Detailed drafting instructions |
The drafting instructions are contained in the Cabinet Record of Decision approving the drafting of the bill. The details of these instructions are fleshed out by the instructing officers either in writing or orally at meetings with the drafters. |
Financial aspects |
The financial aspects of a bill should be taken into account as early as possible in the drafting process in order to determine whether a royal recommendation (for spending provisions) or a ways and means motion (for taxing provisions) is needed. This will allow the drafters to advise L&HP/C on these matters. The Department of Finance must also be consulted if a ways and means motion is needed. |
Preparation, review and revision of drafts |
Drafters prepare drafts for review by the instructing officers and other departmental officials concerned. Drafters advise L&HP/C on the status of drafting through the Legislation Section’s weekly status report on bills. The Legislation Section also advises L&HP/C on the need for a royal recommendation through the weekly status report on bills. |
Jurilinguistic review |
Once the main elements of a bill are established, it is submitted for review by jurilinguists with respect to the terminology, sentence structure, style and organization of ideas. |
Drafts edited |
Once the drafting is nearing completion, the draft is reviewed by legislative revisors in the Legislative Services Branch. |
Comparison both versions of draft |
Once the drafting is nearing completion, both versions of the draft are reviewed by a jurilinguist in the Legislative Services Branch to ensure they are consistent with one another. |
Consultation |
The sponsoring department may wish to consult on drafts with other interested departments. Consultation may also take place with persons outside the Government, if Cabinet has authorized the consultation. |
Finalization of draft before printing |
The Director of the Legislation Section, on the advice of the drafters, determines when the drafting of the bill is sufficiently advanced for it to be printed. |
Draft to L&HP/C |
Instructing officers provide L&HP/C with a copy of the draft bill before it is printed in page proof form.
|
Printing draft bill |
Draft bills are ordinarily printed three times (page proof, examination page proof and final page proof). St-Joseph Ottawa-Hull prints the bill, generally overnight. Instructing officers, drafters, legislative revisors and PCO review the copies. Instructing officers provide further instructions. |
Preparation of bill-summary |
Departmental program officials prepare a short bilingual summary of the bill. The drafters review the summary and incorporate it into the printed bill. |
Advise L&HP/C on need for a royal recom-mendation |
When a draft bill is sent for final page proofs, the Director of the
Legislation Section sends L&HP/C a letter indicating whether a royal recommendation is required and, if so, the particular provisions that attract the requirement. |
Internal departmental approval of draft bill |
Approvals are required before the draft bill is sent to L&HP/C for Cabinet approval.
The draft bill and the legislative plan, which includes a communications strategy, are sent to the Minister as a package for approval.
Speeches, press releases and backgrounders are prepared.
Once the Minister approves the bill and the plan, the Minister’s staff notify L&HP/C. |
Preparation of information packages |
Legislative project team prepares information packages for the Minister, Parliamentary Secretary and the sponsoring Senator. Copies are also forwarded to the Deputy Minister and Associate DM.
Packages contain:
- backgrounder
- clause by clause explanatory notes
- Qs and As
- talking points (if necessary)
- a description of the consultation process
- an outline of the regulations, if any
- letters of support and other material such as press releases.
A version of the information package is also prepared for Members of the House of Commons, Senators, Opposition critics and committee members. These packages contain all the documents that are in the briefing book with the exception of any confidential material. |
Preparation of speeches and press releases |
This involves a speech meeting with the speechwriter, departmental communications branch, program officials, parliamentary relations officials and the Minister’s office. A meeting usually takes place after the planning session on the legislation plan.
Program officials should bring copies of any background material that would be useful to the speechwriter.
The number and length of speeches required are determined by the Minister’s Office and depend on the legislation in question.
Press releases are normally required at introduction and at Royal Assent.
|
Bill review by the Leader of the Govern-ment in the House |
The Leader of the Government in the House of Commons (LGHC) conducts a review of the bill before seeking delegated authority from Cabinet to approve its introduction.
Examination page proofs must be sent to L&HP/C in both languages at least 10 days before the bill review.
Senior departmental officials are required to present the bill to the LGHC clause by clause and they should be prepared to explain each clause and answer any questions, including technical or drafting questions. They also explain the projected time frame for passage and the reasons for it (for example, costs, implementation date, etc.). |
Cabinet approval (delegated authority) |
Depending on the outcome of the bill review, the LGHC may seek Cabinet authority to approve introduction of the bill. |
Next
Table
of Contents
|