The Charlotte Austin Review
-
Mystery -
charlotteaustinreview.com
Home
Get Reviewed
Editor's Office
Editors
Reviewers
Interviews
Columns
Resources
Short fiction
Your letters
Editor
Charlotte Austin
Webmaster Rob Java
Review
Who Was Sylvia
Who Was Sylvia by
Carol Cail
Deadly Alibi Press Ltd
178 pages, 2000
ISBN 1886199043
Reviewed by PJ Nunn


As owner of the small alternative newspaper, The Blatant Regard, Maxey Burnell usually doesn’t have many serious worries aside from deadlines. She might have sensed trouble brewing when she was called to authorize the release of Sylvia Wellman’s dead body to the funeral home, for no reason besides the fact that Maxey’s business card was found in Sylvia’s belongings. Maxey missed that clue, but when she and Calen Taylor - her sometimes live-in lover who happens to be the Fire Marshall - are awakened in the early hours by a nearby fire, Maxey begins to get the picture. There are secrets in her neighborhood that someone will kill to keep.

When Maxey discovers that she did know Sylvia in the form of a seemingly destitute woman known in the neighborhood as Packy, Maxey sets out to gather enough information for fitting obituaries, for Sylvia and the man killed in the fire. Maxey’s superficial investigation reveals more secrets however, and she’s soon desperate to discover who Sylvia really was and what she knew, before Maxey becomes the next victim.

WHO WAS SYLVIA is a gentler, more cerebral mystery. Gratuitous sex and violence are at a minimum without sacrificing relationships and action. Cail’s neighborhood descriptions allow readers to glimpse a small part of Boulder, in much the same way as a native would visualize it, with colorful characters in occupancy and vivid interactions that strike resonant chords. While the storyline doesn’t inspire that 'lock the door and leave on the lights' tendency, it does present enough twists and surprises to result in a satisfying, case-closed reaction.



© 2000 The Charlotte Austin Review, for Web site content and design, and/or writers, reviewers and artists where/as indicated.