Chapter 34
1998 March
Index with links to the other chapters
[ICS (webmaster) comment: The PC Party has made one of the most fundamental mistakes in organizing their new website — they have not set up an adequate management structure for the site.
For example, at the top of the candidates' page at http://www.pcparty.ns.ca/cand.html, we see: "This page requires use of a modern browser." That's all. They do not state just what they consider to be a "modern browser." I am using Netscape Navigator 4.0, which I would classify as being a modern browser at this time. The latest survey (that I have seen, it covers the month of February 1998) of Internet browser usage, gives this: |
Browser | Total Requests |
---|---|
Netscape 3.x | 30.6% |
Microsoft IE 3.x | 20.4% |
Netscape 4.x | 17.9% |
Microsoft IE 4.x | 8.8% |
Netscape 2.x | 7.0% |
WiseWire-Widow-1.0r | 5.4% |
Scooter/1.0 scooter@pa.dec.com |
3.6% |
Gulliver/1.2 | 2.9% |
Microsoft IE 2.x | 1.9% |
WiseWire-Spider-1.0 | 1.5% |
This report of recent browser usage tells me that my Netscape 4.0 is about as modern as there is right now, at least among widely-used browsers. But there are some features of the PC Party website that do not work properly with my browser. If my Netscape 4.0 is not able to cope with some features of the PC Party website, perhaps the problem is with the website design.
After all, this is a website for a political party, which, one would think, would prefer to reach as large an audience as possible. When a website is designed by technicians they often want to use the latest technology gizmo, to show off their technical skills. There is a need for supervision by someone who has in mind the main purpose of the website, to keep the project on track. If there is a proposal to insert a cutting-edge technical feature which will have the effect of seriously reducing the number of people who are able to view the site properly with their current browser, the supervisor must decide which is more important — using the latest technical doodad or maintaining wide accessibility. It is this conflict that the PC Party has failed to recognize in the management of its new website. It is a typical weakness one finds when technical projects are implemented by an organization whose leaders have little knowledge of or interest in technology, and who are unwilling or unable to compensate for their lack by finding and utilizing competent advisors. ICS |
[ICS (webmaster) comment: And I thought the PC Party website was badly managed! (See above) At least I can look at the PC site. But this new Liberal website is so far gone in the direction of "Look ma, what I can do" that I cannot even view the entry page (remember, I'm using Netscape Navigator 4.0, one of the most advanced browsers now generally available). If you can believe it — the Liberal website is heavy with numerous graphics, and Java crap, and Applets running crawlers — as if this was the kind of stuff the average citizen is looking for in a political party website in the middle of a close election campaign.
I will look again at this Liberal Party website only with reluctance. The design of this site is clear evidence of a breathtaking level of incompetence combined with bad judgement, when one thinks of the fundamental purpose of a political website. IMHO.] |
At this point, the Liberal website again crashed my browser. Apparently the site designer assumed that all viewers have pretty much the latest in computer technology, such as a 150 megahertz Pentium, with 56k modem on a T1 line, and with high-level plug-ins. The website explicitly states:
"To find out who the Liberal Candidate is for your constituency, click on one of the corresponding ridings below or find it on our riding map by clicking on the icon to the right. (map requires the "macromedia flash" plug-in to operate in your browser ... Note: If the words on the map are too small to read, try hiding some toolbars in your browser using the View menu at the top of your screen. The map will scale to a larger size." There is no mention of what hardware capabilities are necessary to make this "macromedia flash" plug-in operate in my browser, so I have no idea whether my system is capable of accomodating it. Apparently the Liberal Party is happy to exclude from its website all those who have computer systems that are a bit less than brand new, even though they still work fine on all the other party websites. They are also happy to require that viewers all be comfortable with the arcane inner workings of complex software ("...try hiding some toolbars..."). They seem to be blissfully unaware that there is a substantial proportion of people who can get around on the Net if things do not get too hairy, but who are likely to be scared away by such rigid (and unnecessary) technical skill requirements.My question is — Is this a smart way to design a website for a political party? Obviously, my answer to that question is No. My main concern is that the political leaders have allowed themselves to be misled by a few people who put flashy technical gimmicks first, and making the site widely accessible second. Here's a quote from Jim Carroll's Ten Things to Watch Out for in the Future. Mr. Carroll was making a general comment, which was written a year before the three Nova Scotia political parties got their websites running. But his comment is so close to the bone, and so apt for those in charge of these political websites, that I quote it here. IMHO, this should be printed in large type, framed, and displayed prominently in the office of each of the three political party leaders, along with the offices of their most influential advisors.
|
As far as I know, this is the first time in history that there has been a website for the purpose of promoting any candidate, or credible potential candidate, for the position of a national leader of any Canadian political party. |
Thursday 12 March — Questions submitted Monday 16 March — Answer 1 Tuesday 17 March — Rebuttal 1 Wednesday 18 March — Answer 2 Thursday 19 March — Rebuttal 2 Friday 20 March — Wrap up |
Dan Bunbury wrote the following introduction:
NS-POLITICS is an e-list which is the participatory heartbeat of the Nova Scotia Electronic Democracy Forum. The forum is hosted and supported by the Centre for Community & Enterprise Networking (CCEN) of the University College of Cape Breton (UCCB). This list is open to all Nova Scotians, and those beyond its borders, who are interested in political issues and electronic democracy. The purpose of this list is to provide an electronic forum for the discussion of all matters political and social pertaining, first to Nova Scotia, and as they relate directly or indirectly to Nova Scotia, matters more national in scope. By 19 March, the list had more than a hundred subscribers. If you want to subscribe to this list, just send an ordinary e-mail To: listserv@ccen.uccb.ns.ca leave the subject line blank, and in the body of the message subscribe NS-Politics Napoleon Bonaparte except, instead of "Napoleon Bonaparte" insert your name. |
|
ICS (webmaster) comment — None of the three party leaders — Chisholm, Hamm, and MacLellan — has a personal or campaign website. Remarkably, neither the current Minister of Technology, Bruce Holland, nor the immediately preceding Minister of Technology, Gerald O'Malley, has a personal or campaign website, although both are candidates in this election. The current Minister of Education, Robbie Harrison, does not have a personal or campaign website, even though he is the driving force behind the $30,000,000 "Harrison High", a new high school currently under construction in his riding which has for years been promoted as a showcase of modern educational technology, with up-to-date electronic communications and information technology playing a prominent part in the plans.
The most glaring grammatical error I saw during this extensive tour of political websites, was in the Liberal Party site at http://www.nsliberals98.com/, which includes this statement: In Nova Scotia, unemployment has fell from (some percentage) to (some other percentage). |
[ICS (webmaster) — In the history of communications in Nova Scotia, I put this development in the same category as the first advertising to include a telephone number. In future elections, there is no doubt that party and candidate advertising will routinely include Internet and WWW contact information, in the way that, now, it is taken for granted by everyone that contact information includes a telephone number. Nowadays, it is understood that candidates and political parties have to have a telephone number and they have to tell people what it is, but it was not always thus. In the history of electric communications, one of the significant milestones is the time when the telephone reached a level of acceptance that it was thought to be of sufficient importance that businesses and other organizations began to include a telephone number in newspaper advertising. The earliest Nova Scotia newspaper ad I have found that included a telephone number was printed in 1888 — that is the earliest I have found so far, but my research in that area has barely begun and it is highly likely that earlier examples exist.] |
There may be additional material of interest in the CCTA website at http://www.ccta.com/ but, for some reason, the CCTA entry page is blank. All I get is a solid black background, with no text or graphics, thus there is no way to proceed. The link (above), using a URL I got from a search engine, works okay, but that's all. Attempts to parse that URL don't work because Access Is Denied to the directories. Thus entry to the website is not possible unless you first have the complete URL of the destination file. It is a very strange way to design a website, but that's how it is, as of 18 August 1998. (I was using an up-to-date browser, Netscape 4.0, during my attempts to obtain access, but the CCTA website wasn't cooperative.) |
Wayback Machine http://web.archive.org/index.html "Use the Wayback Machine to view web sites from the past." History of Nova Scotia, Chapter 34 The Wayback Machine has copies of this webpage from the early days: Archived: 2000 August 15 http://web.archive.org/web/20000815195509/http://www.alts.net/ns1625/nshist34.html Archived: 2000 November 20 http://web.archive.org/web/20001120132800/http://www.alts.net/ns1625/nshist34.html Archived: 2000 December 16 http://web.archive.org/web/20001216124700/http://www.littletechshoppe.com/ns1625/nshist34.html Archived: 2001 February 8 http://web.archive.org/web/20010208225057/http://www.alts.net/ns1625/nshist34.html Archived: 2001 April 19 http://web.archive.org/web/20010419134653/http://www.alts.net/ns1625/nshist34.html Archived: 2001 November 22 http://web.archive.org/web/20011122064024/http://www.alts.net/ns1625/nshist34.html |
Index with links to the other chapters
W3C HTML Validation Service
http://validator.w3.org/
W3C CSS Validation Service
http://jigsaw.w3.org/css-validator/