Home About TB TB History Human Impact Timeline People Profiles Sanatorium Age Preventing TB Finding TB Treating TB International TB Today Index

  Treatments of Tuberculosis

 Resistance


Another difficulty results from the long chemotherapy necessary to suppress the tubercle bacilli in tuberculosis: the bacilli have time to become resistant to the drug. Tubercle bacilli become resistant to streptomycin and isoniazid rather easily – if these drugs are used separately. This was a disappointing feature of streptomycin in the early days of its use Patients would improve for the first few weeks on treatment and then fail to make any further progress. Culturing the bacilli from their sputum and testing the culture in various concentrations of streptomycin would reveal that their bacilli had become resistant to the drug; in other words, no longer affected by it and able to grow and multiply in spite of its presence. Incidentally it is the bacteria or parasites that become resistant – not the patient. Often one hears even doctors quite wrongly talking about patients being resistant to streptomycin.




 Treatment
 Traditional
 Bed Rest
 Heliotherapy
 Postural
 Surgeries
 Phrenicotomy
 Thoracoplasty
 Pneumothorax
 Lobectomy
 Chemotherapy
 Antibiotics
 Resistance

Soon after streptomycin was introduced, sulfetrone was widely tried with it and found to reduce greatly the appearance of resistant strains of tubercle bacilli. But sulfetrone was rapidly supplanted by PAS which is more effective, while isoniazid is even better. As long as two drugs are used together the chances of the bacteria producing a strain resistant to either drug is very slender. If three drugs are used together the chances of a resistant strain arising are completely negligible – provided the original strain of bacteria were sensitive i.e. not resistant, to all three drugs.

We have at last learned that to give any anti-tuberculous drug by itself is to invite almost certain failure in the long run, because resistant strains will certainly develop. To a less extent the same applies to chemotherapy of all diseases. The indiscriminate use of valuable drugs like penicillin for trivial complaints has already produced numerous strains of the commoner bacteria resistant to penicillin, the sulfas, streptomycin, and even to aureomycin. In future perhaps chemotherapy will always be by two or three drugs used together for all infective diseases, while a wiser public will be less likely to demand chemotherapy for the most trivial infections, and a wiser medical profession will be less ready to accede to such demands. Apart from the risk to the community in spreading resistant strains of bacteria by indiscriminate use of chemotherapy, the individual patient runs a risk from unnecessary contact with these powerful and valuable drugs. This is the risk of becoming allergic or hypersensitive to the drug, so that the drug may have to be denied the patient in future when he might have serious need of it. Some people develop allergic symptoms of such severity that they are actually a threat to life. In view of the risk of spreading allergy amongst the human population and drug-resistance amongst the parasitic bacteria, the treatment of ordinary colds and minor infections with antibiotics valuable in other diseases is obvious folly, especially as none of the antibiotics so far discovered has any action on the common cold virus.

Modified from "Chemotherapy 2" by Dr. AG Richards, a physician at the Saskatoon Sanatorium, in the 1954 Valley Echo [volume 35(4), pages 2-3].