Initial Master plan - continued

The image shown below consists of a composite of four cartographic images brought together, three from the architect's 1953 plans and one previous topographic map of the site. It illustrates the two preliminary concepts of Balharrie. One scheme consisted of five interconnected buildings; the other three. The latter scheme incorporated the arts and sciences activities into a long structure with a large, enclosed central area, much like the interior courts one might find in today's shopping malls. That main building was to have been nearer the river below the other campus structures.

At their next meeting the executive committee approved a building committee to advise on the "development of the new campus site layout and facilities required for such specified buildings and such other matters as the landscaping and beautification of the campus"

Historical evidence suggests no further action was taken by architects and planners for nearly a year. This hiatus may have been a result of unresolved expropriation intentions by the Federal District Commission. During 1953 the College tried repeatedly to have the FDC's resolution to expropriate rescinded. The conflict involved personalities, local issues, and ultimately issues within the federal government. Finally, it seems to have become clear Carleton's support within the federal cabinet was sufficient to overturn decisions at the regional or local level.

	Balharrie plans (1953) : two campus plan schemes
	Carleton University Library, Special Collections and Archives

The FDC's power of expropriation was dependent upon cabinet approval.

In October 1953, as part of the many arguments presented to the FDC during the year, Coyne and MacOdrum had stated: "It is the firm belief of those entrusted with the destinies of Carleton College that the establishment of a well-planned university on this campus will not detract from, but rather much enhance the prospects of the National Capital Plan for the beautification and improvement of the City of Ottawa." (Correspondence, 14 October 1953, p.4)