Thesis Statement
Total___
/ 4 |
Excellent
4
|
Good
3
|
Satisfactory
2
|
Unsatisfactory
1
|
A concise, clear statement that puts forward a position or point of view
for development. Some complexity of thought. |
A statement that puts forward a position or point of view for development. |
A position or point of view is expressed but not clearly or concisely. |
Lacks position or point of view. Needs more work. |
Research & Documentation
Total___
/ 4 |
Uses a number of primary sources appropriately to develop the thesis. Determines
the reliability of the source.
Demonstrates understanding of connections and relationships in the evidence. Proper
documentation and bibliography. |
Missing one key component of an excellent essay. Heavy reliance on one type of
primary source. Clear documentation. |
Missing two components of an excellent essay. Uses only one type of primary source. |
Missing three components of an excellent essay. Uses only one primary source. Insufficient
documentation |
Conclusion
Total___
/ 4 |
Concluding statement summarizes appropriately the findings of the research. Refers
to the thesis. Is stated in a clear and succinct manner. |
Summarizes and draws some appropriate conclusions. Refers to the thesis. Is somewhat
clear. |
Draws a few conclusions. Does not refer to the thesis. Lacks clarity. |
Conclusion is missing. Does not refer to the thesis. Conclusion does not follow from
the evidence or research. |
Clarity of Presentation
Total___
/ 4 |
Use of clear, concise language. Flowing paragraphs. Good sentence structure.
Free of major grammatical errors and spelling mistakes. |
Generally clear language with complete sentences. Few grammatical and spelling errors. |
Presentation is understandable. Some errors in sentence structure. Grammatical errors
are noticeable. |
Presentation is confusing. Numerous errors in sentence structure. Many errors in grammar
and spelling. |
Organization of Presentation
Total___/
4 |
Logical development of thesis with well organized paragraphs, including: clear
introduction, body (5 flowing paragraphs), and conclusion. Use linking
words as indicators of development of thesis. |
Paragraph organization including: introduction, evidence, and conclusion. Some clear
development of the thesis. |
Lacks clear development of the thesis. Lacks logical paragraph organization. |
Lacks paragraphs. Does not develop the thesis or proceed in an appropriate direction. |
TOTAL
SCORE
/20
|
Clarity of Message
Total___
/ 4 |
Excellent
4
|
Good
3
|
Satisfactory
2
|
Unsatisfactory
1
|
Theme is clearly and coherently presented and stated. |
Theme is clear in either the presentation or written statement. |
Some aspects of the theme are clearly presented in the project. |
Theme is not clear. |
Creativity and Originality
Total___
/ 4 |
Effective, innovative or imaginative approach that captivates or attracts the attention
of the audience. |
Effective and interesting approach with good visual appeal. Some creativity or originality. |
Some visual appeal with limited creativity or originality. |
Lacks creativity and visual appeal. |
Research and Effort
Total___
/ 4 |
Thoughtful, thorough, and well documented. Obvious signs of an exceptional effort. |
Thoroughly researched and documented. A complete piece of work. |
Some significant research and documentation but not complete in all aspects. |
Incomplete research and documentation. Little evidence of independent thought. |
Written Support Material
Total___/4 |
Well organized and clearly expressed written material that enhances the viewers
understanding of the project. Minimal mechanical errors. |
Organized written material that helps the viewer understand the project. A few mechanical
errors. |
The written statement is not clear and is only somewhat organized. Numerous
mechanical errors. |
Unorganized and unclear written statement with serious mechanical errors. No written
support material. |
Format and Style
Total___/4 |
The medium of presentation is most appropriate to convey the theme of the project. |
Medium helps to convey the message or theme. |
Medium is not particularly effective for the theme. |
Medium is not appropriate for the theme. |
TOTAL
SCORE
Peer Evaluation Average
/10
|
Complete Folder: All Project Worksheets Completed
/ 10
|
Project Total
/60
|